Backward Design, Assessment Design, and Lesson Structuring in Secondary Literature
Backward Design Framework for Lesson Planning
Core Philosophy of Backward Planning:
- Backward design requires planning with the end in mind rather than starting with the classroom agenda or daily activities.
- Planning activities first without established goals leads to ineffective learning and wasted instructional time, which modern students actively resist.
Stage 1: Identify Desired Results:
- Addresses the foundational question: What should students know and be able to do?
- Learning Objective Definition: For an individual lesson, identifying desired results requires formulating a learning objective, defined as a single statement specifying what students should know and be able to do.
- Focus on Skills and Performance: The phrase "know and be able to do" designates a broad, demonstrable skill or performance that students are acquiring, rather than the specific task used to evaluate it.
- Common Planning Error: Teachers frequently confuse a learning objective with a statement of the assignment itself. While closely related, the skill to be performed and the specific assignment assigned to measure that skill are distinct entities.
- Learning Objectives vs. Learning Outcomes: A learning objective is narrow and designed for an individual lesson. A learning outcome is broader and designed for an entire unit of study.
Stage 2: Determine Acceptable Evidence:
- Focuses on establishing how student mastery of the learning objective will be measured.
- Terminology: In pedagogical practice, the terms "assignment" and "assessment" can be used interchangeably whenever student work is gathered to evaluate understanding.
- Principle of Alignment: The assessment must directly align with and agree with the learning objective. The chosen assignment must explicitly gather empirical evidence of the specific skill stated in the objective.
Stage 3: Plan Learning Experiences and Instruction:
- Encompasses the daily agenda, instructional activities, and classroom experiences designed to achieve learning.
- This is purposefully the final stage of planning. Determining the agenda last guarantees that classroom activities directly support the assessment and learning objective rather than functioning as arbitrary tasks.
Assessment Categories: Formative and Summative
Formative Assessment (Assessment FOR Learning):
- Etymology and Mnemonic: The bolded letters FOR in formative link to its definition as assessment for learning.
- Timing and Context: Occurs live, in the moment during instruction while students are engaged in assignments, participating in group discussions, or reading texts (such as short stories, poems, or novel chapters).
- Pedagogical Function: Provides immediate evidence to inform real-time teaching decisions, answering: What do students understand right now? It signals whether to deliver additional instruction, pause and review missed concepts, or advance the lesson.
- Stakes and Grading: Formative assessments are typically low-stakes or ungraded.
- In-Class Formative Examples:
- A live verbal review of the backward design stages conducted at the beginning of class.
- A preliminary learning objective creation activity on Canvas, where students received full credit ( out of points) for completion, regardless of whether the objectives required revision, serving solely to deliver instructional feedback.
Summative Assessment (Assessment OF Learning):
- Etymology and Mnemonic: The bolded letters SUMM in summative link to the concept of a summary—providing a comprehensive picture of learning as an assessment of learning.
- Timing and Context: Administered at the culmination of a learning sequence (after a lesson or unit) to determine whether students achieved the learning objective (for a lesson) or learning outcome (for a unit).
- Pedagogical Function: Documents and officially reports student achievement, answering: What have students learned?
- Stakes and Grading: High-stakes, evaluated against formal rubrics, and entered into the grade book to record mastery at that point in time (for example, receiving a permanent score of out of points).
- Grading Philosophy on Retakes: Summative assessments should serve as permanent records of student knowledge at the designated evaluation deadline, rather than flexible assessments open to retakes.
Fluidity Between Assessment Types:
- An assessment tool is not inherently formative or summative by its format alone; its classification depends on timing, execution, pedagogical intent, and how the results are used.
- Chapter Reading Quiz Scenario:
- Summative Execution: A quiz given after an assigned novel chapter where scores are entered directly into the grade book to measure comprehension and the class moves on.
- Formative Execution: The identical quiz given without recording grades, used instead as a tool to diagnose misunderstandings and prompt review of key textual scenes.
- Review Game Example (Jeopardy! Format):
- Formative Execution: A digital Jeopardy! board used for test preparation covering categories such as themes, symbols, figurative language, and author details. Teams compete for non-grade rewards (such as donuts or exam extra credit), offering diagnostic data on test readiness without entering scores into the grade book.
- Summative Execution: The identical game played where team scores are recorded directly into the grade book as an evaluative measure of student learning.
Lesson Structuring: Launches and Closes
The Launch (Stage 3 Introduction):
- Definition: An intentional, teacher-directed introduction or warm-up that prepares students for learning.
- Purposes: Activates prior knowledge, establishes connections to the upcoming lesson material, and engages student interest.
- Implementation Strategies:
- Do Now / Bell Ringer: A short activity initiated immediately upon entering class, such as a five-minute journal writing prompt connecting personal experiences to a text.
- Provocative / Philosophical Inquiries: Abstract or ethical prompts preparing students for thematic literature study (e.g., What would you be willing to sacrifice so that there could be a perfect society? or What would you do if you were living in a world where in order to escape being executed, you just had to lie about somebody else?).
The Close (Stage 3 Conclusion):
- Definition: A purposeful, teacher-directed conclusion that brings closure to the lesson.
- Purposes: Supports students in synthesizing their learning, integrating concepts, and planning practical applications or skill transfer (e.g., applying poetic analysis techniques to contemporary song lyrics).
- Consequences of Omitting a Close:
- Novice teachers frequently stop instruction with to minutes remaining, instructing students to pack bags early.
- Historical classroom consequences of dead time included severe behavioral disruptions (altercations, tearing posters, destroying books, defacing blinds).
- Modern classroom consequences center on disengagement and excessive mobile phone usage, communicating teacher indifference and wasting instructional time.
Distinction Between Closes and Summative Assessments:
- Certain instructional tools, such as an exit ticket (a discrete task turned in before departing the room), can theoretically function as either a close or a summative assessment.
- Course-Specific Rule for English 3010: In secondary teaching, a close may occasionally serve as the summative assessment; however, within English 3010, the lesson close and the summative assessment must remain completely separate, distinct items on the lesson plan template.
Gradual Release of Responsibility (GRR) Framework
Theoretical Model:
- A Stage 3 instructional model that shifts cognitive responsibility from the teacher to the students over the course of a lesson.
- Conceptualized as an inverted triangle: teacher responsibility is widest at the top and narrows as student responsibility broadens.
The Four Phases:
- 1. Focus Lesson ("I Do"):
- Teacher holds primary responsibility.
- Involves explicit instruction, introducing strategies, providing concrete examples, and conducting a think-aloud to model proficient reading habits.
- 2. Guided Instruction ("We Do"):
- Shared responsibility between teacher and whole class.
- Teacher facilitates shared tasks, guides discussion, prompts student volunteers to articulate reasoning, and records collective thinking on the board.
- 3. Collaborative Learning ("You Do Together"):
- Responsibility shifts primarily to student peers.
- Students work in small groups or pairs on targeted textual tasks (e.g., analyzing character motivations in Chapter 5).
- Teacher circulates to facilitate, answer questions, enforce on-task behavior, and monitor digital distractions.
- 4. Independent Practice ("You Do Alone"):
- Complete student responsibility.
- Individual completion of the Stage 2 summative assessment task, submitted for formal evaluation.
- 1. Focus Lesson ("I Do"):
Pedagogical Flexibility:
- The framework does not mandate a rigid, linear order ("I Do" "We Do" "You Do Together" "You Do Alone").
- Adaptive Sequencing Example: A lesson can begin with collaborative group work on meter in Shakespearean sonnets as a formative pre-assessment. If students display confusion, the teacher pivots back to an explicit "I Do" focus lesson to re-teach the concept before returning students to collaborative or independent tasks.
English 3010 Course Requirements and Lesson Plan Guidelines
Course Scope:
- English 3010 focuses on the pedagogy of secondary literature (fiction, poetry, novels, short stories). Writing instruction and nonfiction pedagogy are addressed in the subsequent spring course.
- Terminology reflects standards from the California State University, Bakersfield (CSUB) Teacher Credentialing Program and College of Education.
Lesson Plan Assignment Parameters (Due Sunday, October 18):
- Must feature a fully aligned, mandatory Summative Assessment; formative assessments are optional.
- Must include an intentional Launch and a distinct Close.
- The lesson plan template requires written explanations specifying how the lesson executes each phase of the Gradual Release of Responsibility.
- Instructional Duration: The plan should not encompass an entire week of instruction. It should represent a coherent learning sequence that realistically spans approximately two class periods (e.g., reading a short story, conducting literary analysis, and completing an assessment).
- The submission requires exactly one launch, one close, and one unified agenda section.
Canvas Instructional Resources:
- A compiled PDF list of suggested formative and summative literature assessments.
- Curated lists of suggested launch and close activities.
- A completed exemplary lesson plan model.
- A 17-minute recorded video walking through the rationale behind the exemplary lesson plan.
- Midweek Workshop Day: A Wednesday activity dedicated to revising previous learning objectives and drafting aligned assessments based on instructor feedback.
Questions & Discussion
Reusing Feedback-Approved Objectives and Assessments:
- Question: Can approved objectives and assessments from the Wednesday Canvas activity be directly copied and pasted into the lesson plan template due Sunday?
- Response: Yes. If the feedback indicates that no revisions are needed, students should copy and paste those components directly into their formal lesson plan template.
Temporal Scope of the Lesson Plan:
- Question: Should the lesson plan represent a single day of instruction, or can it span multiple days across a week?
- Response: The plan should not cover an entire week. Realistically, reading literature, discussing it, and assessing mastery spans approximately two class periods. The template does not require an explicit time stamp, and rolling over unfinished instruction (e.g., completing of an agenda in one day) is standard secondary teaching practice. The assignment requires one launch, one close, and one cohesive agenda.
Assessing Whole-Class Discussions Summatively:
- Question: Can a classroom discussion serve as a summative assessment instead of a physical written paper?
- Response: Yes, provided there is a clear, systematic mechanism to document and measure individual student learning. Teachers must specify performance criteria (such as minimum speaking requirements) and evaluate individual contributions using an instrument such as a holistic rubric to determine whether students introduced original textual insights rather than merely echoing classmates.