Hegel on History and Truth
The Historicity of Thought and Civilization
What is present is never simply given in pure, unmediated form; it's experienced through a framework of categories we can't set aside.
All human consciousness is informed by categories of thought that mediate everything we experience.
Kant's Critique of Reason
Kant argued that the mind isn't a passive recipient of sensations but actively understands them through categories and principles it brings to bear on experience.
Kant vs. Hegel
Kant
The categories we bring to experience are products of our own thought.
We can only claim that we make sense of the world through these categories, not that the world is structured accordingly.
Conceptual framework is fixed and universal for all rational beings, not giving access to things in themselves.
Framework constitutes an unchanging, timeless grid that gives human experience a uniform conceptual structure.
Hegel
Categories are preconditions for accessing the structure of things.
Categories equip us to see and understand what is.
The structure of our concepts and categories is identical with the structure of the world itself because we are born into and share its character.
Hegel's View on Categories of Thought
Categories of thought are not fixed, eternal forms but concepts that alter their meaning in history, that are the changing 'historical' preconditions of knowledge.
Categories of thought put us in contact with the world itself, but do so more or less adequately in different ages and cultures.
Hegel believed the categories are those in which the structure of being is fully revealed.
Philosophical Ideas and Civilization
Philosophical ideas, religious beliefs, aesthetic forms, and political constitutions do not have permanent validity.
They are specific products of specific times and places and must be understood in their context.
A civilization's identity is defined by the principle that constitutes the common character of its religion, political constitution, ethical life, system of justice, customs, science, art, and technical skill.
Identifying the Spirit of a Civilization
The most important thing to identify in a civilization is the fundamental spirit that makes it what it is.
Our character is constituted by the fundamental self-understanding manifest in our practices, creative activity, labor, and beliefs.
To determine the character of a people, we must examine how it lives and what it does, not just what it says.
This constitutes the substance of society.
Shifts in Categories and Self-Awareness
The most important changes in history have involved shifts in the categories through which human beings understand their world.
These shifts are brought about by humanity's self-awareness.
Hegel believed that within the vicissitudes of human history, there is a strand of development from humanity’s initial, primitive understanding.
Comparing Civilizations
Different cultures differ in the degree to which they are conscious of themselves as self-productive and self-determining.
This is the degree to which they are explicitly, self-consciously, and thus freely self-determining.
There is no given, immutable human self; there is only the human 'activity' of producing our world, of producing or determining different forms of social life from different forms of philosophical, religious, aesthetic or ethical self-understanding.
Human Self-Determination in History
The absolute truth of humanity is that human beings have no fixed, given identity but determine and produce their identity and their world in history.
They gradually come to the recognition of this fact in history.
Civilizations can be evaluated by comparing the extent to which they can incorporate new levels of human self-consciousness and freedom.
The more self-conscious civilization can prove its greater self-awareness to another.
Consciousness of Human Truth and Historicity
Consciousness of human truth and consciousness of human historicity are not incompatible.
Consciousness of human truth is essentially consciousness of human self-determination in history.
History is essentially the process whereby mankind becomes aware of itself as free, self-determining, and therefore historical.
The absolute truth of humanity is that we are historical, and the history of humanity is the process of coming to recognize our absolute, historical character.
History and truth are thus completely inseparable.
Self-Production and Self-Discovery
The human activity of self-production is, at the same time, the process of self-discovery and self-revelation.
It's a fusion of making oneself and finding oneself, of acting and of coming to know – a self-realization.
If human beings are indeed historically self-determining, they cannot simply be this, but must actively determine themselves in history to be self-determining.
We must make ourselves into self-determining beings in history because we are self-producing beings.
This process involves humanity making itself explicitly what it already is implicitly.
Marx's Misconception of Hegel
Marx sees the development of human self-consciousness as a purely intellectual matter, as simply the development of human ideas.
For Hegel, the changes in categories and the consequent reformation of the human spirit involve changes in our material interests and practical, socio-economic activity, as well as in religious belief.
History is the “spirit’s effort to attain knowledge of what it is in itself.”
Self-Consciousness and Historical Progress
Historical change is change produced by our self-conscious pursuit of the goals of the self-conscious communities – the states – in which we live.
History is the working out of the conflicts, clashes, and interactions between and within different states.
History is inseparable from the political history of human development towards greater self-consciousness and freedom in states.
Hegel’s view of history is not idealistic; it entails understanding major political, social, and economic transformations in history in the light of major reformations and developments in human self-consciousness.