Bioethics_Aristotle // Virtue Ethics

  • Actions producing moral virtue differ from those stemming from it; the latter require specific conditions.

  • Just and temperate acts indicate a person's moral character, similar to how grammatical acts indicate a grammarian.

  • Unlike arts, where the goodness of products is inherent, virtuous acts require the agent to possess certain conditions.

  • Essential conditions for virtuous actions include:

    • Knowledge of the virtue.

    • A conscious choice of the act for its own sake.

    • Actions must arise from a stable and consistent character.

    • Knowledge alone is insufficient for virtue; the other conditions are crucial for moral character development.

    • Just and temperate actions are defined by the characteristics of the just or temperate individual, not merely by the actions themselves.

What is Good?

  • Aristotle → Virtue Ethics

  • No strict focus on singular intentions/actions

    • Can’t do a good thing just once

    • Habit is essential

  • Asks one to consider the knowledge + will of the moral agent (person) involved in acting

  • Telos — “End” & “paradise”

    • Teleology — Considers the amount of good in the world

  • No moral playbook → Learn by doing rather than just learning

    • Follow the example of someone else who’s good

    • If you keep doing the good, you’ll start enjoying it

    • This common sense is more practical wisdom

  • Arete — Excellence or perfection of a thing

  • Eudaimonia — “Human flourishing”

  • “Doctrine of the Mean”

    • Vice (excess) ↑

    • Virtue (Golden Mean) =

    • Vice (deficiency) ↓

  • Types of moral character:

    • Virtuous/God-like — Rare; know, do, and delight in good

      • The right thing, at the right time, in the right manner

    • Continent/Enduring and/or Incontinent/Soft — Common; know, does, but grudgingly and/or know, don’t do, and guilty

      • Do the right thing but with regret/complaint/difficulty

    • Brutish/Vicious — Rare; don’t know, do wrong, delight in wrong and/or do know, do wrong, delight in wrong

    • Goodness is a firm habit rooted in the virtue and character of the moral agent