Social Interactionism, Labeling Theory, and Deviance
Announcements and Lecture Overview
- The lecture is in-person with the instructor.
- The second part of the lecture will focus on the instructor's research in a South African prison.
- Next week's lecture will be pre-recorded, including a general subject overview and exam information.
- The exam is moved to the 11th at 3 PM and will be online and open book.
- Students should avoid plagiarism and academic misconduct, respecting the university's policies.
- The exam will cover all lecture and reading materials, with a format similar to Quiz 1: true/false and short answer questions.
- Notes are permitted during the exam, provided they are not verbatim copies from lecture or reading materials.
- Essays should include general references (e.g., Jung 2003, or according to Marx).
Symbolic Interactionism
- Focuses on agency, both of the subject and the audience.
- Meaning is constructed through interaction and is not pre-given or solidified.
- Addresses how society is created and maintained through dynamic face-to-face interactions and repeated routines.
- Examines how reality is negotiated and responded to, including through labeling.
- Individuals actively engage in the world, not merely acting as passive objects of power.
- Language and symbols are important because they transmit meanings, which can be impactful and sometimes hurtful.
Chicago School and George Herbert Mead
- The theory originates from the Chicago School, with George Herbert Mead as one of its key figures.
- Mead introduced the concept of reflexivity: self-awareness and awareness of one's surroundings.
- Reflexivity is important in qualitative research, requiring awareness of one's own positionality.
- There are conversations between the "me" (social self), the "I" (unsocialized self), and the generalized other.
- The generalized other illustrates how we use symbols and shortcuts to understand reality.
Herbert Bloomer's Three Statements
- We know things through their meaning.
- Meanings are created through interactions.
- Meanings change through interaction.
Video Summary
- Symbolic interactionism is a sociological theory that focuses on small-scale, everyday social interactions.
- Symbols: People communicate through symbols like gestures, words, and objects.
- Meaning: Meaning is created and modified through social interactions.
- Action: People act based on the meanings things have for them.
- Self: Individuals develop their self-concept through interaction with others (the "looking glass self").
- Social Reality: Social reality is fluid and constantly reshaped through interactions.
- Strengths: People are active participants, not passive recipients.
- Criticisms: It focuses too much on small-scale interactions and ignores larger social structures.
Identity and Language
- Identities are formed from experience and prediction of experience.
- Examples of identities: professional, gender, race, parent, child, friend, social class.
- Language is used to rationalize our actions.
- Meaning and interpretation are invested in interactions and relations.
Techniques of Neutralization
- Developed by criminologists Sykes and Watson to explain responses to labels.
- Denial of responsibility: It wasn't my fault.
- Denial of injury: It wasn't a big deal.
- Denial of victim: The state isn't the victim in tax evasion.
- Condemnation of the condemners: They had it coming.
- Appeal to higher loyalties: Doing it for the gang or colleague.
Labeling Theory
- Emphasizes how negative responses to behavior can stigmatize.
- Deviance isn't a quality of the act but a consequence of applying rules and sanctions.
- Deviant behavior is behavior people label as such.
- Central issue of power: Who has the power to define?
- Recall Drew Klein’s boundary formation: defining who is "us" versus "the other."
Social Expectations
- Involve both insiders and outsiders and their expectations.
- Heteronormativity and treatment of asylum seekers as examples.
- Processes, effects, and consequences of stigmatization are important.
- Stigmatization can become self-fulfilling prophecy.
Mumbai Study
- A study in Mumbai, India, examined how young people interpret the concept of "troubled child."
- Identities are managed, and strategies are used to counter labeling.
- Young people may invert labels, labeling police officers as outsiders.
- Authors call for user-centric and participatory juvenile justice interventions.
Types of Deviance (Lemert)
- Primary deviance: Engaging in behaviors or having traits that are not responded to (not problematic).
- Secondary deviance: Strong social response, deeming traits or behaviors as problematic (can be formal or informal).
- Emphasis is on the process, and agency is important on both sides.
Garfinkel and Degradation Ceremonies
- The process of creating labels is long and involves stripping one's previous identity (mortification).
- Prisoners in Ukraine had to attend formal meetings, display their name badges, and state their crime, reinforcing their status as prisoners.
- These ceremonies were religiously enforced by officers.
- Label of prisoner is a convict who requires discipline and is lacking discipline.