Developing Topics for Your Speech (Chapter 4) - VOCABULARY Flashcards
4.1 Getting Started with Your Topic and Purpose
Public speaking has three broad general purposes: to inform, to persuade, and to entertain/inspire (third purpose can be labelled with various words like to entertain, to amuse, to please, to delight, etc.). The book uses the umbrella term “to inform / to persuade / to entertain (inspire)” for clarity, noting that a speech can blend purposes (e.g., inform, persuade, and entertain).
The concept of general purpose = the broad, overall goal of a speech (inform, persuade, entertain).
Speeches can be more than one type (e.g., an informative speech that also persuades or entertains). Special occasion speeches (tribute, after-dinner, toast, eulogy) fit under the umbrella of “to inspire” or “to entertain.” Chapters 12, 13, and 15 provide examples for those types.
The Canons of Rhetoric and Invention (the first canon) remain relevant today. Invention means the discovery of what to say, not just creating new technology. Modern emphasis remains on finding content rather than reinventing it from scratch.
Topoi (ancient rhetorical questions) are introduced as a tool to discover arguments and content. Modern teachers use two core questions to guide topic/purpose development:
What value, connection, or interest does my purpose/topic have for the audience? What needs do they meet?
Why would the audience consider me, the speaker, a credible source on this purpose/topic?
When addressing unfamiliar audiences, address question (1) early; if the audience doesn’t know you, briefly establish credibility/background in an appropriate way.
A central teaching: the most effective speeches answer questions in the minds of the audience (WIIFM – What’s In It For Me?). Keep WIIFM in mind as you design your speech.
WIIFM stands for: What’s In It For Me? (audience perspective drives content and focus).
General context for topic/purpose formation: align with audience needs, the setting, and the speaker’s own background.
Practical goal: use purpose and topic to guide organization, supporting evidence, and visual aids.
Key definitions and concepts
General Purpose: the broad goal of the speech (inform, persuade, entertain).
Specific Purpose vs. General Purpose: the specific purpose narrows the general purpose to a precise objective for the speech.
The canons remain a practical guide; invention is at least partially covered in this chapter and others (Chs. 5, 7, 12, 13).
Audience-centered approach is highlighted; aim to answer audience questions and meet audience information/credibility needs.
4.2 Formulating a Specific Purpose Statement
Once the general purpose is identified (inform, persuade, or entertain/inspire), you draft a specific purpose that narrows the focus to a precise goal for the speech.
Three contributing elements (Figure 4.1):
You: interests, background, past jobs, experience, education, major
Your Audience: the audience you analyzed in Chapter 2
The Context/Setting: time, place, reason for the event, and audience present (Chapter 2)
Inventory process: Write about what you know; start with ideas reflecting your interests/goals/passions to build credibility and engagement.
Figure 4.2 provides prompts for an inventory to generate ideas from experiences or interests you may not be aware you have (the prompts themselves are shown in the figure in the text).
The inventory approach helps you avoid topics that students commonly choose from Google lists and helps you find material that excites you and the audience.
An alternative approach is to think about what you are passionate about through two binary routes:
What you love (e.g., Simpsons; volunteer work) to propose informative or persuasive angles.
What you dislike or what annoys you (e.g., poor driving habits) to propose topics with practical relevance (e.g., safe driving).
Audience consideration: the topic should have practical value or interest for others, even if not initially interesting to them; tailor the angle to demonstrate audience benefits.
Context considerations: time limits, classroom setting, and assignment specifications shape the specificity of the purpose.
Putting It Together: write a specific purpose statement that will guide the entire speech and act as a guide for what not to say. The specific purpose should be singular and focused; avoid trying to cover too much material.
Specific Purpose Statement Formula (as described in Figure 4.1 / 4.2):
Specific Communication Word (in infinitive phrase) [to inform, to explain, to demonstrate, to describe, to define, to persuade, to convince, to prove, to argue]
Target Audience [my classmates, the members of the Social Work Club, my coworkers]
The Content [how to bake brownies, that Macs are better than PCs]
In a compact form, you can summarize the formula as:
Important constraints for the content part:
It must be singular and focused; avoid using the word "and" to join multiple purposes/topics in the same content phrase.
The content must match the purpose word (e.g., do not pair an informative purpose with a persuasive content clause).
The purpose, topic, and audience must be relevant to the audience’s lives, wallets, careers, etc.
Consider the ultimate outcome you want the audience to walk away with (know, be able to do, think, act, respond).
Examples of specific purposes (illustrative; all examples adhere to the singular, focused rule):
To inform my classmates of the origin of the hospice movement.
To describe to my coworkers the steps to apply for retirement.
To define for a group of new graduate students the term “academic freedom.”
To explain to the Lions Club members the problems faced by veterans of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
To persuade the members of the Greek society to take the spring break trip to Daytona Beach.
To motivate my classmates to engage in the College’s study abroad program.
To convince my classroom audience that they need at least seven hours of sleep per night to do well in their studies.
Important caution: never start your speech by stating your specific purpose to the audience; it’s a private guide for you and the instructor, not a public opening line. Beginning with "my speech is about…" is awkward and common to avoid.
Examples of how the specific purpose can be adapted for different audiences or contexts (the same topic can yield different specific purposes for different listeners, e.g., study abroad):
For freshmen vs. juniors; for a civic group; for a family member who benefited from Special Olympics, the specific purpose would shift in focus while the core topic remains the same.
Practical note: the specific purpose is not typically announced in a speech during delivery; it’s a planning device used to guide the speech and demonstrate alignment with assignment expectations.
4.3 Formulating a Central Idea Statement
The central idea (or central idea statement) reveals your main focus and the main points you will cover; it’s what the speech will argue or describe.
Terminology note: instructors may call it a thesis or a main idea statement. The terms are largely synonymous for this context, but you should follow your instructor’s preferred term.
Central idea vs. thesis in essays: the central idea in a speech is similar to a thesis in an essay but not as strictly formatted. It is acceptable for the central idea to reflect the speaker’s personality (using first person pronouns like I, we, you, etc.) and to be attention-getting and audience-focused. It should be a complete, grammatical sentence.
The central idea should summarize the main points or arguments you will present to fulfill the specific purpose. It should not repeat the exact wording of the specific purpose but should align with it and preview the main points.
The central idea may be introduced after an introductory device or method (e.g., as discussed in Chapter 8). It should set up the structure of the speech and guide audience expectations.
Practical guidance on the central idea:
It should be a single, succinct sentence (or capsuled in a small number of sentences). If the central idea runs to more than three sentences, you are likely trying to cover too much material.
The central idea can be written in the first person (e.g., I/we/you) and should be audience-focused.
The central idea should reveal the main points that will be developed in the body of the speech.
Examples (Illustrative) showing the relationship between specific purpose and central idea:
Specific Purpose: To inform my classmates of the origin of the hospice movement.
Central Idea: The hospice movement originated from compassionate care philosophies and evolved to provide comprehensive end-of-life support, emphasizing comfort, dignity, and patient-centered care.Specific Purpose: To describe to my coworkers the steps to apply for retirement.
Central Idea: Retirement planning involves four key steps: understanding eligibility, selecting a savings strategy, determining distribution plans, and navigating benefits.Specific Purpose: To motivate my classmates to engage in the College’s study abroad program.
Central Idea: Participating in study abroad offers personal growth, intercultural competence, and tangible benefits to academic and career goals.
Capsule approach: You can combine purpose, topic, and preview into one succinct central idea that sets expectations for the audience (though you don’t reveal the exact purpose verbatim in the speech itself).
Iterative nature of development: central ideas, like the specific purpose, may be revised during preparation as your understanding of audience, topic, and context evolves. The introduction helps reveal the central idea and main points, along with credibility and rapport-building.
Important reminder: the central idea should be a single sentence (or three-sentence capsule) that clearly outlines the main points to be covered; it should stand out to the audience and be highlighted in delivery.
4.4 Problems to Avoid with Specific Purpose and Central Idea Statements
Problem 1: Being too broad (trying to cover too much material).
Example of a broad purpose: "To explain to my classmates the history of ballet."
Better, narrower variants:
"To explain to my classmates how ballet came to be performed and studied in the U.S."
"To explain to my classmates the difference between Russian and French ballet."
"To explain to my classmates how ballet developed as an art form in the Renaissance."
"To explain to my classmates the origin of ballet dancers’ clothing."
Problem 2: Being too narrow (so specialized that only experts care).
Examples:
Inform my classmates of the life cycle of a new species of lima bean (audience: botanists, agriculturalists)
Inform my classmates about the Yellow 5 ingredient in Mountain Dew (audience: chemists, nutritionists)
Persuade my classmates that JIF peanut butter is better than Peter Pan (audience: professional chefs in large institutions)
Problem 3: Verb/content mismatch (the verb in the purpose does not match the content).
Examples:
Inform audience why capital punishment is unconstitutional (should be persuasive)
Persuade audience about the three types of individual retirement accounts (needs a persuasive content focus, not just informative)
Inform classmates that Universal Studios is a better theme park than Six Flags (opinion-based; clearly persuasive)
Problem 4: Content includes two topics joined by "and" (content too broad).
Examples:
Explain how to swing a golf club and choose the best golf shoes
Persuade classmates to be involved in Special Olympics and vote to fund better classes for the intellectually disabled
Fix: choose one topic to cover, e.g., "To explain to my audience how to swing a golf club" or "To explain to my audience how to choose the best golf shoes".
Problem 5: Formatting problems
Do not write the specific purpose or central idea as a question.
Use complete sentences for central idea statements and infinitive phrases (to …) for specific purposes.
Use concrete language and avoid slang, jargon, or acronyms (e.g., PLA is better than CBE for adult learners).
Problem 6: Drift from the specific purpose (the speech veers into unrelated material while developing main points).
The specific purpose often determines the main points and the speech structure (Roman numeral outline).
Example: If the specific purpose is to inform about the five stages of grief (Kubler-Ross), your main points should be the five stages in order, not a biography of Kubler-Ross or other tangents.
Additional note on titles: Titles are useful but not always required; the text emphasizes that the spine of the speech should be the purpose and central idea rather than necessarily focusing on the title.
Conclusion: All aspects of the speech will likely change during preparation and practice. The specific purpose should generally remain stable unless a strong reason arises; central idea and introduction are more flexible and may change during drafting and revision.
Final thought exercise (What if scenario): If your informative speech has a specific purpose like explaining the biological and lifestyle causes of Type II diabetes and practice reveals a longer duration than allotted, should you adjust the specific purpose? Consider how you would refine to fit seven minutes while preserving clarity and relevance.
Case Studies: Specific Purposes and Central Idea Statements
Case Study One: Mitchell (Mitch)
Context: Second-year Fundamentals of Speech course; wants to speak on tennis (informative, seven minutes, four external sources).
Situation: He brainstorms topics (tennis-related topics listed: famous players, rules, how to start playing, equipment, why tennis is great, organizations, origins, injuries, tennis in the Olympics, grand slam events).
Classroom dynamics: He works in a small group; classmates are 18–24, single, no children, college students with part-time jobs; none have played tennis.
Task: Critique Mitch’s brainstormed topics and propose a starting specific purpose.
Suggested approach: Narrow and tailor to audience knowledge; focus on a topic with clear audience value and manageable scope; propose a starting specific purpose such as:
To inform my classmates about the origins of tennis and its evolution into a global sport, highlighting key milestones and contemporary relevance, supported by four external sources.
Rationale: Addresses audience unfamiliarity, provides a clear narrative arc, and fits a seven-minute limit with a credible research base.
Case Study Two: Bonita
Context: Job interview presentation; 5 people in the audience: president, two board members, HR/office manager, volunteer; 5-minute to 6-minute window (5–6 minutes).
Situation: Bonita has a public relations background and knows the organization (nutrition-focused nonprofit) and its social media use (Facebook page, limited / underutilized).
Questions to consider: Should the presentation be persuasive, informative, or inspiring? What should be her specific content area? How should she address the two key questions of value to the audience and credibility?
Suggested approach: Treat the presentation as a persuasive/strategic pitch to hire her or adopt a plan, with a clear focus on a concrete PR/social media strategy tailored to a nutrition nonprofit audience. A recommended general purpose could be Persuade (to hire/approve a plan) or Inform (to explain a plan with benefit justification). A combined approach may be appropriate, but for a single-general-purpose frame, Persuade is strong for a job interview.
Possible starting specific purpose (Persuade):
To persuade the interview panel that a focused PR and social media plan can significantly improve the organization’s outreach and fundraising within six months.
Central idea (preview of main points):
A focused social media strategy (channels, content types, posting cadence, and governance) will elevate nutrition outreach; clear metrics and milestones will demonstrate impact; a collaborative plan with internal stakeholders will maximize reach and sustainability; and I bring the expertise to implement and optimize this plan.
Value and credibility considerations: Demonstrate how the plan benefits the organization (audience value) and articulate relevant experience and results from past PR/social media work to establish credibility.
Summary of Practical Guidelines to Remember
Always connect your topic to audience value (WIIFM) and establish credibility early in the process.
Define a clear three-part basis for your specific purpose: a verb (to inform / to explain / to persuade / etc.), your audience, and the content.
Keep the content portion singular and tightly aligned with the chosen purpose word; avoid combining multiple aims in one clause with an "and".
Your central idea should summarize the main points in a single, clear sentence (or a brief two-to-three-sentence capsule) and should be ready to preview the body.
Do not reveal the specific purpose aloud at the start of the speech; use it as a planning tool for yourself and your instructor.
Expect and plan for revision: the central idea and introduction may evolve during the iterative drafting and rehearsal process.
Use the two core audience-focused questions (value to audience and your credibility) to guide your topic and approach from the outset.
Titles are optional; focus on sharpening the purpose and central idea as the spine of your speech.
Case studies illustrate how to tailor specific purposes and central ideas to real audiences and situations, highlighting the need for audience awareness and practical alignment with time limits and venue constraints.
Quick Reference: Key Definitions and Pointers
General Purpose: broad goal of the speech (inform, persuade, entertain).
Specific Purpose Statement: a singular, focused sentence built from a verb, audience, and content; should be narrowly defined and aligned with the audience and context. The format can be expressed as:
Central Idea Statement: a complete, grammatical sentence that encapsulates the speech’s main points and direction; may be paraphrased as the thesis for a speech but is not bound by the stricter rules of an essay thesis.
Avoid common traps: overly broad topics, overly narrow topics, mismatched verbs/content, multi-topic content, poor formatting (questions, slang, jargon), and drift from the stated purpose.
Iterative process: plan, draft, revise, and rehearse; the introduction and central idea can be refined as you practice.
Practical implication: good notes and practice can save trouble later in speech preparation; ensure the specific purpose remains appropriate to the time and audience.
In a speech, the central idea is typically introduced after an introductory device or method. It is meant to set up the structure of the speech and guide audience expectations, clearly outlining the main points you will cover.
In public speaking, a central idea statement is largely synonymous with a thesis statement, and instructors may use either term. However, the note clarifies that while similar to a thesis in an essay, a central idea in a speech is generally not as strictly formatted. It can reflect the speaker's personality, incorporate first-person pronouns (like I, we, you), and be designed to be attention-getting and audience-focused, while still being a complete, grammatical sentence that summarizes the main points.