EC320: Intermediate Macroeconomics - The Monetary System
The Monetary System
Overview of Money
Definition: Money is the stock of assets that can be readily used to make transactions. It broadly includes currency (bills and coins) and bank deposits held by the public.
Three Main Functions of Money:
- Medium of Exchange: Money is used to buy goods and services, facilitating complex transactions that would be impossible with barter alone. Barter requires a "double coincidence of wants," where both parties desire what the other has. Money eliminates this need.
- Store of Value: Money transfers purchasing power from the present to the future. It allows individuals to save and spend later.
- Unit of Account: Money serves as the common unit by which everyone measures prices and values of goods, services, and assets.
Liquidity: An asset is considered liquid if it can be easily converted into money. Money itself is the most liquid asset.
- Financial assets (e.g., bank deposits, U.S. government bonds, publicly traded stocks) are generally more liquid than real assets (e.g., houses, cars, art).
Types of Money
- Commodity Money: Currency that possesses intrinsic value, meaning it has value even if not used as money.
- Examples: Gold coins, silver coins.
- Silver/Gold Standard: A monetary system where the unit of account is defined based on a fixed quantity of silver or gold.
- Fiat Money: Paper currency that is legal tender but has no intrinsic value.
- Example: Federal Reserve Notes (U.S. dollar).
- Implication: Societies using fiat money are more susceptible to inflation, which reduces the purchasing power of money.
Money Supply and Monetary Policy
- Money Supply: The total quantity of money available in an economy.
- Monetary Policy: The control over the money supply, typically conducted by a country's central bank.
- The Federal Reserve System (The Fed): The central bank of the United States.
- It is organized into 12 Federal Reserve Districts across the U.S.
- Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC): The primary decision-making body for monetary policy, meeting 8 times a year.
- Composition: Seven members of the Federal Reserve Board, the president of the New York Fed, and four of the other eleven regional Federal Reserve Bank presidents.
- Main Tool: The Fed controls the money supply primarily through open market operations.
- Open Market Purchase: The central bank buys government bonds from the public or banks to increase the money supply (and thus the monetary base).
- Open Market Sale: The central bank sells government bonds to the public or banks to decrease the money supply (and thus the monetary base).
Measurements of Money Supply
- The most commonly used measures are M1 and M2.
- Key Change: Since May 2020, saving deposits have been included in M1, rather than exclusively M2.
- General Formula: We write money supply as M=C+D, where C is currency and D is bank deposits.
- Specific Measures (November 2024 data):
- C (Currency): 2,359.3 billion dollars (coins and Federal Reserve Notes outside banks).
- M1: 18,340.8 billion dollars. Includes:
- Currency
- Checkable deposits (demand deposits, traveler's checks)
- Saving deposits (including money market deposit accounts)
- M2: 21,391.7 billion dollars. Includes:
- M1
- Small time deposits
- Retail money market mutual funds
- Narrower definitions of money supply (like M1) include more liquid forms of deposits.
The Role of Banking in Money Supply
- The banking system is crucial for the overall money supply because bank lending activities effectively create money.
- Banks as Financial Intermediaries: Banks transfer funds from depositors (savers) to borrowers (investors).
- Bank Balance Sheet Preliminaries:
- Liabilities (Sources of Funds):
- Deposits (checking, saving, certificates of deposit (CDs/time deposits), money market deposit accounts (MMDAs)). Some are demandable, meaning depositors have immediate access.
- Assets (Uses of Funds):
- Reserves (R):
- Bank holdings of cash and cash equivalents, primarily deposited at the Fed, with some held as vault cash.
- Banks hold reserves for day-to-day business, urgent liquidity needs, and to meet regulatory requirements.
- Reserve-Deposit Ratio (rr): The fraction of deposits banks hold as reserves: rr=R/D.
- Banks typically do not keep a high rr (unless required) because it hurts profitability, as not all depositors withdraw funds simultaneously.
- Reserve Requirement: The minimum rr that banks are legally mandated to maintain by the Federal Reserve.
Banking Scenarios: Money Creation
To understand banks' role, consider two scenarios, assuming an initial currency of C = $1,000 deposited into a bank.
Bank Capital and Leverage
- Bank Capital (Bank Equity/Owner's Equity/Net Worth): The resources a bank's owners have invested in the bank.
- Formula: Capital=ValueofAssets−ValueofLiabilities
- Example Balance Sheet:
- Assets: Reserves $200, Loans $550, Securities $250 (Total Assets = $1,000)
- Liabilities & Owner's Equity: Deposits $750, Debt $150, Capital (owner's equity) $100 (Total Liabilities & Equity = $1,000)
- Leverage: The use of borrowed money to supplement existing funds for investment.
- Leverage Ratio: LeverageRatio=Assets/Capital
- Using the example above: Leverage Ratio = $1,000 / $100 = 10 (meaning for every $1 of capital, the bank has $10 in assets).
- Bank Capital Requirement: Financial regulators impose capital requirements on banks due to the fragility caused by high leverage.
- Vulnerability: High leverage makes banks vulnerable to insolvency (liabilities exceeding assets) if asset values decline.
- Example: If the example bank's assets lose $150 in value (e.g., $100 from loan defaults, $50 from bond value drops), total assets become $850. With liabilities of $900 ($ $750deposits+ $150debt),thebankbecomesinsolvent.</li></ul></li><li><strong>Regulation</strong>:Bankswithcapitallevelsatleast8</ul><h4id="amodelofmoneysupply">AModelofMoneySupply</h4><p>Thismodelexplainshowthecentralbankinfluencesthemoneysupply,expandinguponthedepositcreationconcept.</p><ul><li><strong>ExogenousVariables</strong>:<ul><li><strong>Reserve−DepositRatio(rr)</strong>:rr = R/D(Reserves/Deposits).Influencedbyregulations(reserverequirements)andbankpolicies(e.g.,holdingexcessreserves).</li><li><strong>Currency−DepositRatio(cr)</strong>:cr = C/D(Currency/Deposits).Reflectsthepublic′spreferenceforholdingcashversusdepositingitinbanks.</li><li><strong>MonetaryBase(B)/High−PoweredMoney</strong>:B = C + R(Currencyincirculation+BankReserves).Directlycontrolledbythecentralbank.</li></ul></li><li><strong>EndogenousVariable</strong>:<ul><li><strong>MoneySupply(M)</strong>:M = C + D(Currencyincirculation+BankDeposits).Thecentralbankprimarilyinfluencesthisvariable.</li></ul></li></ul><h4id="solvingforthemoneysupplymoneymultiplier">SolvingfortheMoneySupply(MoneyMultiplier)</h4><p>Themoneysupply(M)relatestothemonetarybase(B)throughthemoneymultiplier(m).</p><ul><li><p>Given:M = C + DandB = C + R(whereCiscurrency,Disdeposits,Risreserves).</p></li><li><p>DividingMbyB:<br/> rac{M}{B} = rac{C + D}{C + R} </p></li><li><p>DividingthenumeratoranddenominatorbyD:<br/> rac{M}{B} = rac{(C/D) + (D/D)}{(C/D) + (R/D)} = rac{cr + 1}{cr + rr} </p></li><li><p>Thisratioisdefinedasthe<strong>moneymultiplier(m)</strong>:<br/> m = rac{cr + 1}{cr + rr} </p></li><li><p>Therefore,themoneysupplyis:M = m imes B</p></li><li><p><strong>MoneyMultiplier(m)</strong>:</p><ul><li>MeasurestheincreaseinMwhenBchangesbyonedollar.</li><li>misgreaterthan1(m > 1)aslongasrr < 1(i.e.,fractional−reservebankingexists).</li><li>Avalueofm > 1indicatesthatchangesinB(centralbankactions)haveamultiplicativeeffectonM.Thisiswhythemonetarybase(B)isalsocalled"high−poweredmoney."</li></ul></li><li><p><strong>DeterminantsoftheMoneyMultiplier</strong>:</p><ul><li><strong>mdecreaseswhenrrincreases</strong>:<ul><li>Ahigherrrmeansbanksholdmorereservesandarewillingtolendoutasmallerfractionofdeposits,leadingtolessmoneycreationthroughthelendingprocess.</li></ul></li><li><strong>mdecreaseswhencrincreases</strong>:<ul><li>Whenthepublicholdsmorecurrencyrelativetodeposits,lessmoneyisredepositedintothebankingsystem.Banks,therefore,havefewerdepositsavailabletolend,whichreducesthemoneycreationpotential.</li></ul></li></ul></li></ul><h4id="howthefedconductsmonetarypolicy">HowtheFedConductsMonetaryPolicy</h4><p>TheFedinfluencesthemoneysupply(M)intwoprimaryways:</p><ol><li><strong>ChangingtheMonetaryBase(B)</strong></li><li><strong>ChangingtheReserve−DepositRatio(rr)</strong></li></ol><h5id="toolsforchangingthemonetarybaseddbdd">ToolsforChangingtheMonetaryBase(B)</h5><ol><li><strong>OpenMarketOperations(OMOs)</strong>:TheFed′sbuyingandsellingofgovernmentbonds.<ul><li><strong>PreferredMethod</strong>:ThisistheFed′smostfrequentandpreferredmonetarycontroltool.</li><li><strong>EffectonB</strong>:OMOsdirectlyaffectthemonetarybasebyanequalamount.<ul><li><strong>OpenMarketPurchase</strong>:TheFedbuysgovernmentsecurities(bonds)fromnonbankpublicorbanks.<ul><li>IftheFedbuysfromthepublic:Thepublicholdstheproceedsascurrencyordepositschecksinbanks.Currencyincirculationincreases,orbankreservesincrease.BothleadtoanincreaseinB.Thediagramshows:purchasinggovernmentsecurities
ightarrow nonbankpublicreceivescurrency
ightarrow holdsascurrency(Cincreases)ordepositsinbankingsystem
ightarrow reservesincrease.</li><li>IftheFedbuysfrombanks:Bankreservesincrease.Bincreases.</li></ul></li><li><strong>OpenMarketSale</strong>:TheFedsellsgovernmentbonds,whichdecreasescurrencyincirculationorbankreserves,thusdecreasingB.</li></ul></li></ul></li><li><strong>DiscountLending</strong>:TheFed′slendingofreservestobanksviathe"discountwindow."<ul><li><strong>DiscountRate</strong>:TheinterestrateatwhichbankscanborrowfromtheFed.</li><li><strong>Mechanism</strong>:Toincreasethemonetarybase,theFedcanlowerthediscountrate,encouragingbankstoborrowmorereserves.</li><li><strong>ControlLimitation</strong>:TheFedsetsthediscountrate,butbanksultimatelydecidewhethertoborrow.TheFed′scontroloverBthroughdiscountlendingislessprecisethanthroughOMOs.</li></ul></li></ol><h5id="toolsforchangingthereservedepositratioddrrdd">ToolsforChangingtheReserve−DepositRatio(rr)</h5><ol><li><strong>ReserveRequirements</strong>:Fedregulationsmandatingaminimumreserve−depositratio.<ul><li><strong>Mechanism</strong>:Byloweringtheminimumrr,theFedcanreducetherequiredreservesbanksmusthold,potentiallyallowingthemtolendmore,whichincreasesmandM.</li><li><strong>EffectivenessPost−2008</strong>:Thistoolbecamelesseffectiveafterthe2008−2009financialcrisis,asbanksbeganholdingsignificantlylargeamountsof<strong>excessreserves</strong>(reservesabovetheminimumrequiredamount).Thechartshowsadramaticincreaseinexcessreservesfromaround2008onwards.</li></ul></li><li><strong>InterestonReserves(IOR)</strong>:AnewtoolintroducedinOctober2008,wheretheFedpaysinterestonbankreservesdepositedwiththeFed.<ul><li><strong>Mechanism</strong>:Toreduceexcessreserves(andthuspotentiallylowerrrifbankschoosetolendmore),theFedcouldpayalowerinterestrateonreserves.Conversely,toincreaserr,theFedcouldincreaseIOR,incentivizingbankstoholdmorereservesratherthanlendthemout.</li></ul></li></ol><h4id="limitsofthefedscontrolonmoneysupply">LimitsoftheFed′sControlonMoneySupply</h4><p>WhiletheFedhasdirectcontroloverthemonetarybase(B)throughOMOs,itsinfluenceontheoverallmoneysupply(M = m imes B)canbedampenedbychangesinthemoneymultiplier(m).</p><ul><li><strong>FactorsMutingFed′sControl(duringcrises)</strong>:<ul><li><strong>PublicPreference(raisingcr)</strong>:Duringbankingcrises,householdsmayloseconfidenceinbanksandprefertoholdmorephysicalcash,increasingcr.Anincreaseincrdecreasesm,leadingtoafallinMevenifBisconstant.</li><li><strong>BankBehavior(raisingrr)</strong>:Similarly,banksmaybecomemorecautiousduringcrisesanddecidetoholdagreaterproportionofdepositsasreserves(beyondrequirements),increasingrr.Anincreaseinrralsodecreasesm,leadingtoafallinM.</li></ul></li><li><strong>HistoricalExamples</strong>:<ul><li><strong>TheGreatDepression(1929–1933)</strong>:<ul><li>Lossofconfidenceinbanksledtoasharpincreaseincr.</li><li>Banksbecamemorecautious,significantlyincreasingrr.</li><li>Bothfactorscausedmtofallsharply(fromover6tobelow4).</li><li>Despitea20\%increaseinBbytheFed,thelargedecreaseinmresultedinasubstantial<strong>decreaseintheM1moneysupply</strong>,whichworsenedtherecession.</li></ul></li><li><strong>TheGreatRecession(2007–2009)</strong>:<ul><li>crremainedroughlyconstant.</li><li>However,bankssignificantlyincreasedrrduetotwomainreasons:<ol><li>TheFedbeganpayinginterestonreserves.</li><li>Banksbecamemuchmorecautiousintheirlendingpractices.</li></ol></li><li>Thisledtoasharpfallinthemoneymultiplier(m)fromabout9tounder5.</li><li><strong>Fed′sResponse</strong>:TheFedmanagedtolargelyoffsetthedecreaseinmandmaintainMbysharplyincreasingthemonetarybase(B)through<strong>QuantitativeEasing(QE)</strong>,whichinvolvedlargepurchasesoflong−termgovernmentbonds.</li></ul></li></ul></li></ul><h4id="exercisesandanswers">ExercisesandAnswers</h4><h5id="exercise1">Exercise1</h5><p>Ifacentralbankwantstoincreasethemoneysupply,itcan<strong><em></strong></em>bondsinopen−marketoperationsor<strong><em></strong></em>reserverequirements.</p><ul><li>a.buy,increase</li><li>b.buy,decrease</li><li>c.sell,increase</li><li>d.sell,decrease</li></ul><p><strong>Answer</strong>:<strong>b.buy,decrease</strong></p><ul><li>Buyingbondsincreasesthemonetarybase(B).</li><li>Decreasingreserverequirementslowersrr,whichincreasesthemoneymultiplier(m).</li><li>BothactionsincreaseM = m imes B.</li></ul><h5id="exercise2">Exercise2</h5><p>Considerthefollowingdata:</p><ul><li>Currency: $100billion</li><li>Bankreserves: $200billion</li><li>Bankdeposits: $800billion</li></ul><p>A.Calculatethevaluesforthecurrency−depositratio,reserve−depositratio,themonetarybase,themoneymultiplier,andtheM1moneysupply.</p><p>B.Supposethecentralbankconductsanopenmarketpurchaseofbondsheldbybanksof $50billion.Assumingthesamecrandrrasin(A),predicttheeffectonthemonetarybaseandmoneysupply.</p><p><strong>Answers</strong>:<br/>A.C=100,R=200,D=800</p><ul><li><strong>Currency−depositratio(cr)</strong>:cr = C/D = 100/800 = 0.125</li><li><strong>Reserve−depositratio(rr)</strong>:rr = R/D = 200/800 = 0.25</li><li><strong>MonetaryBase(B)</strong>:B = C + R = 100 + 200 = $300billion</li><li><strong>InitialM1MoneySupply</strong>:M1 = C + D = 100 + 800 = $900billion</li><li><strong>MoneyMultiplier(m)</strong>:m = M1/B = 900/300 = 3<ul><li>Alternatively,usingtheformula:m = rac{cr + 1}{cr + rr} = rac{0.125 + 1}{0.125 + 0.25} = rac{1.125}{0.375} = 3</li></ul></li></ul><p>B.Anopenmarketpurchaseof $50billionfrombanksdirectlyincreasesbankreservesby $50billion.</p><ul><li>NewReserves(R'):R' = R + 50 = 200 + 50 = $250billion</li><li>Currency(C)remainsunchanged:C = $100billion</li><li>Deposits(D)areassumedunchangedforcalculatingratios,ascrandrrareassumedconstant.</li><li>NewMonetaryBase(B'):B' = C + R' = 100 + 250 = $350billion</li><li>Themoneymultiplier(m)remainsthesame(m = 3)becausecrandrrareassumedconstant.</li><li>NewM1MoneySupply(M1'):M1' = m imes B' = 3 imes 350 = $1,050billion</li></ul><h5id="exercise3">Exercise3</h5><p>HowwouldeachofthefollowingaffecttheU.S.moneysupply?</p><p>A.Banksdecidetoholdmoreexcessreserves.<br/>B.PeoplewithdrawcashfromtheirbankaccountsforChristmasshopping.<br/>C.TheFedsellsgoldtothepublic.<br/>D.TheFedreducestheinterestrateitpaysondepositsofdepositoryinstitutionsheldattheFed.<br/>E.Afinancialcrisisleadspeopletosellmanyoftheirstocksanddeposittheproceedsinbankaccounts,whicharefederallyinsured.<br/>F.Thefederalgovernmentsells $20billionofnewgovernmentbondstotheFed.Theproceedsareusedtopaygovernmentemployees.</p><p><strong>Answers</strong>:<br/>A.<strong>Banksdecidetoholdmoreexcessreserves.</strong><br/>∗Thisincreasesthereserve−depositratio(rr).<br/>∗Anincreaseinrrcausesthemoneymultiplier(m)tofall.<br/>∗Therefore,themoneysupply(M)<strong>falls</strong>.<br/>B.<strong>PeoplewithdrawcashfromtheirbankaccountsforChristmasshopping.</strong><br/>∗Thisincreasesthecurrency−depositratio(cr).<br/>∗Anincreaseincrcausesthemoneymultiplier(m)tofall.<br/>∗Therefore,themoneysupply(M)<strong>falls</strong>.<br/>C.<strong>TheFedsellsgoldtothepublic.</strong><br/>∗WhentheFedsellsassets(likegold),thepaymentreceivedfromthepubliceffectivelywithdrawsmoneyfromcirculationorbankreserves.<br/>∗Thisdecreasesthemonetarybase(B).<br/>∗Therefore,themoneysupply(M)<strong>falls</strong>.<br/>D.<strong>TheFedreducestheinterestrateitpaysondepositsofdepositoryinstitutionsheldattheFed.</strong><br/>∗Reducingtheinterestonreservesmakesholdingexcessreserveslessattractiveforbanks.<br/>∗Thisincentivizesbankstolendmore,effectivelydecreasingthereserve−depositratio(rr).<br/>∗Adecreaseinrrcausesthemoneymultiplier(m)toincrease.<br/>∗Therefore,themoneysupply(M)<strong>increases</strong>.<br/>E.<strong>Afinancialcrisisleadspeopletosellmanyoftheirstocksanddeposittheproceedsinbankaccounts,whicharefederallyinsured.</strong><br/>∗Peoplepreferbankdeposits(insured)overstocks(riskier),sotheywillmovefundsfromlessliquidassets(stocks)intomoreliquidbankdeposits.<br/>∗Thisactivityincreasesbankdeposits(D)relativetocurrency(C)(assumingthefundswerenotinitiallyincash),effectivelydecreasingthecurrency−depositratio(cr).<br/>∗Adecreaseincrcausesthemoneymultiplier(m)toincrease.<br/>∗Therefore,themoneysupply(M)<strong>increases</strong>.<br/>F.<strong>Thefederalgovernmentsells $20billionofnewgovernmentbondstotheFed.Theproceedsareusedtopaygovernmentemployees.</strong><br/>∗TheFed′spurchaseofbondsfromthegovernmentissimilartoanopenmarketpurchase,increasingthemonetarybase(B)by $20billion.<br/>∗Thegovernmentthenspendsthis $20billion,puttingitintocirculation.<br/>∗Therefore,themonetarybase(B)<strong>increases</strong>by $20billion(Mwillincreaseby $20billionmultipliedbym).</p><h5id="exercise4">Exercise4</h5><p>Supposeinaneconomy:</p><ul><li>Monetarybaseis $1,000billion.</li><li>Peopleholdathirdoftheirmoneyintheformofcurrency.</li><li>Banksholdathirdofdepositsinreserves.</li></ul><p>A.Whatisthereserve−depositratio?Whatisthecurrency−depositratio?<br/>B.Calculatethemoneymultiplierandthemoneysupply.<br/>C.Oneday,fearaboutthebankingsystemstrikesthepopulation.Peoplenowwanthalfoftheirmoneyintheformofcurrency.Ifthecentralbankdoesnothing,whatisthenewmoneymultiplierandthenewmoneysupply?<br/>D.ContinuewithC.If,inthefaceofthispanic,thecentralbankwantstoconductanopen−marketoperationtokeepthemoneysupplyatitsoriginallevel,itshould(buy/sell)governmentbondsofwhatamount?</p><p><strong>Answers</strong>:<br/>A.<strong>InitialRatios</strong>:Assuming"money"herereferstoM = C+D<br/>∗"Peopleholdathirdoftheirmoneyintheformofcurrency":C = (1/3)M.SoC = (1/3)(C+D),whichmeans(2/3)C = (1/3)D,soC/D = 1/2.Thus,<strong>cr = 0.5</strong>.<br/>∗"Banksholdathirdofdepositsinreserves":<strong>rr = R/D = 1/3 hickapprox 0.333</strong>.</p><p>B.<strong>InitialMoneyMultiplierandMoneySupply</strong>:<br/>∗B = $1,000billion.<br/>∗m = rac{cr + 1}{cr + rr} = rac{0.5 + 1}{0.5 + (1/3)} = rac{1.5}{0.5 + 0.333…} = rac{1.5}{0.833…} = 1.8<br/>∗M = m imes B = 1.8 imes $1,000billion=<strong> $1,800billion</strong>.</p><p>C.<strong>NewMoneyMultiplierandMoneySupply(withfear)</strong>:<br/>∗"Peoplenowwanthalfoftheirmoneyintheformofcurrency":NewC = (1/2)M.SoC = (1/2)(C+D),whichmeans(1/2)C = (1/2)D,sonewC/D = 1.Thus,new<strong>cr' = 1</strong>.<br/>∗rrremainsunchanged:rr = 1/3<br/>∗Newmoneymultiplier(m'):m' = rac{cr' + 1}{cr' + rr} = rac{1 + 1}{1 + (1/3)} = rac{2}{4/3} = 2 imes 3/4 = 1.5<br/>∗Ifthecentralbankdoesnothing,Bremains $1,000billion.<br/>∗Newmoneysupply(M'):M' = m' imes B = 1.5 imes $1,000billion=<strong> $1,500billion</strong>.<br/>∗<strong>Observation</strong>:Increasedcurrencyholding(highercr)lowersthemoneymultiplierandthusthemoneysupply.</p><p>D.<strong>CentralBankActiontoRestoreMoneySupply</strong>:<br/>∗Thecentralbankwantstokeepthemoneysupplyatitsoriginallevel:M^* = $1,800billion.<br/>∗Thenewmoneymultiplierism' = 1.5.<br/>∗ToachieveM^withm',thenewmonetarybase(B^)mustbe:B^* = M^* / m' = $1,800billion/1.5 = $1,200billion.<br/>∗Theoriginalmonetarybasewas $1,000billion.<br/>∗TheFedneedstoincreasethemonetarybaseby $1,200billion− $1,000billion= $200billion.<br/>∗Toincreasethemonetarybase,theFedmust<strong>buygovernmentbonds</strong>.<br/>∗<strong>Amount</strong>:TheFedneedstobuy<strong> $200$$ billion worth of government bonds.