American Legal System Notes
American Legal System
Objectives
- Distinguish the sources and types of laws in the United States.
- Describe the process of how a Bill becomes a law.
- Identify key Federal and State agencies and their roles in defining, implementing, and monitoring compliance with regulatory issues.
Why Regulate Medical Drugs and Devices?
- Potential risk to the users.
- Government needs to protect people from harming themselves through risky choices.
- Why not allow people to look for themselves?
- Market Failures.
Market Failures
- Public Goods
- Orphan drugs, vaccines.
- Externalities
- Overuse of antibiotics.
- Natural Monopolies
- Period of exclusivity, cost of new drug development.
- Information Asymmetry
- Information for educated professionals to make decisions about drug use.
Sources of U.S. Law
- Federal Government.
- State Government.
- Local Government.
Hierarchy of Legal Authority
- Increasing level of detail:
- Law.
- Regulation.
- Policy.
U.S. Constitution
- Supreme Law of the U.S.
- Any Federal or State statute or regulation that conflicts with the U.S. Constitution is invalid.
Federal Government
- Three Branches
- Executive
- Enforce Laws.
- Legislative
- Make Laws.
- Judicial
- Interprets Laws.
- Executive
- Each branch serves as a check to the powers of the other branches.
U.S. Executive Branch
- The branch of government responsible for effecting and enforcing laws.
- President, Vice President
- Departments and Independent Agencies
- Agencies also called Administrative Agencies.
- President, Vice President
Administrative Agency
- Legislature may create an Administrative Agency to implement changes in policies or to administer law when the Legislature itself can’t perform.
- Legislature yields power to Administrative Agency.
- Agency is viewed as expert in the field.
- Found in the Executive branch.
Key Federal Agencies
- Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS)
- reimbursement policy for Medicare and Medicaid
- Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
- Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act
- Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
- Federal Trade Commission Act
- Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA)
- Administer Federal Controlled Substances Act
Administrative Agency Regulation Requirements
- Regulation must:
- Be within the scope of the Agency’s Authority.
- Based on a statute that gives the Agency authority to promulgate regulation.
- Reasonable relationship to public health, safety, and welfare.
Administrative Agencies Legislative Functions
- An Agency can make regulations in a process called Notice and Comment Rulemaking.
- The process ensures that constituents whose interests are affected by the actions of the agency receive notice of any proposed regulation.
- Constituents then have an opportunity to comment on the proposed regulation.
- Agency considers all comments and may incorporate them before final promulgation.
Notice and Comment Period
The statutory time frame during which an agency publishes a proposed regulation;
- Published in Federal Register or Code of Federal Regulations.
Receives public feedback on the regulation;
After this period expires, the regulation can take effect.
Administrative Agency Judicial Function
- Hearings
- Resemble civil or criminal court proceedings
- Evidence
- Arguments
- Decision
- Resemble civil or criminal court proceedings
- Agency decisions are subject to judicial review
- Exhaustion of remedies
- Court to examine record of Administrative hearing
Federal Register (FR)
- Daily publication in which U.S. administrative agencies publish:
- Federal actions
- Proposed regulations
- Final regulations
- Governmental notices
Code of Federal Regulations (CFR)
- The annual collection of executive agency regulations published in the daily Federal Register, combined with previously issued regulations that are still in effect.
- 50 titles
- focus will be on Title 21
Overview of Administrative Law
What Is Administrative Law?
An area of law that governs the administration and regulation of government agencies at both federal and state levels
- Example: Federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
“Agency” is defined as:
- “Each authority of the Government of the United States, whether or not it is within or subject to review by another agency," with the exception of several enumerated authorities, including Congress, federal courts, and governments of territories or possessions of the United States. (Source: 5 U.S.C. § 551(1))
Many independent agencies as part of the federal government have the authority to:
- “Legislate” through rulemaking
- Example: Posting new regulations/guidances in the Federal Register and requesting public comments
- “Adjudicate” through administrative hearings
- “Execute” administrative goals
- “Legislate” through rulemaking
Administrative Procedure Act (APA) (1946)
- Congress enacted the APA governing the federal administrative agencies in 1946 to comply with the U.S. Constitution of “due process.”
- Categorizes administrative functions into formal and informal rulemaking and adjudication
- Rulemaking function: Agencies must give notice of proposed rulemaking before adopting the final rule.
- Agencies must consider all comments received and reviewed (e.g. Federal Register)
- Adjudicatory functions: Involves the agency’s Administrative Law Judge who is independent from the agency officials
- Administrative Law Judge adjudicate claims or disputes involving the agency.
- Rulemaking function: Agencies must give notice of proposed rulemaking before adopting the final rule.
Administrative Procedure Act (APA) (1946) 5 United States Code (5 U.S.C.) – Government Organization and Employees
- General Provisions (5 U.S.C. §§ 500-504)
- Administrative Procedure (5 U.S.C. §§ 551-559)
- Negotiated Rulemaking Procedure (5 U.S.C. §§ 561- 570a)
- Alternative Means of Dispute Resolution in the Administrative Process (5 U.S.C. §§ 571-584)
- Administrative Conference of the United States (5 U.S.C. §§ 591-596)
3 Levels of Judicial Review of Agency Actions
- Courts apply an extremely deferential standard of review, in which the courts defer to agency interpretations of such statutes unless they are unreasonable. (Chevron case)
- Courts defer to the agency interpretations of its own ambiguous regulations. (Auer case). The courts have that the agency's interpretation of its own regulations are binding unless it is plainly erroneous or inconsistent with the regulation. (Chevron case)
- Courts do not give a binding deference to the agency's interpretation, but give varying amount of deference according to the agency's expertise in the particular matter. (Skidmore case)
Regulatory Intelligence
What is Regulatory Intelligence?
- Per PPD: “In general regulatory intelligence is the monitoring, gathering and analyzing of publicly available and experience based regulatory information to develop a strategy for time- and cost-efficient drug development. Analysis of data to create actionable regulatory information to create advantage.”
- Per the Regulatory Intelligence Network Group: “The act of gathering and analyzing publicly available regulatory information. This includes communicating the implications of that information, and monitoring the current regulatory environment for opportunities to shape future regulations, guidance, policy, and legislation.”
Regulatory Intelligence Basics
What is Regulatory Information?
- "The act of gathering and analyzing publicly available regulatory information. This includes communicating the implications of that information, and monitoring the current regulatory environment for opportunities to shape future regulations, guidance, policy, and legislation"
- Definition as per the DIA's Regulatory Intelligence Network Group (RING) - a special interest area community (SIAC)
- Basic building blocks of intelligence, the raw information
- Can be oral, written, published, unpublished, etc.
U.S. Legislative Branch
- Article 1 Section (§) 1 of the US Constitution provides that all Legislative powers of the Federal Government are vested in Congress.
- Congress
- Composed of:
- House of Representatives (435 members)
- Senate (100 members)
- Composed of:
How do Bills Become a Law?
- Legislative Process
- Bills originate by lobbying groups, citizens, government, or President
- Bills need a Sponsor
- Sponsor must be Senator or Representative
- Sponsor introduces Bill in Congress
- Presented to the Bill Committee with jurisdiction over the Subject
- In Committee- public hearings, investigations, work with Sponsor of Bill
- Prior to the Bill proceeding to a vote, the Bill needs the consent of a majority of the Committee.
- If the Committee votes in favor.
- A report detailing the purpose, reasons for approving the Bill, and any changes in existing laws that the Bill would cause is generated.
- Bill is then placed on the Calendar.
- Debate
- After passage of the Bill in one chamber the Bill goes to other chamber’s committee.
- If the Committee votes in favor.
- If the House and Senate version is different.
- Conference committee then rectifies the differences
- After the same Bill is passed in both chambers
- Bill is signed by the President of the Senate and Speaker of the House.
- The Bill is then presented to the President of the U.S.
- Bill becomes a law when the President signs or if the President fails to return the Bill with in 10 days to Congress.
- If the President Disapproves:
- Veto, President to provide reasons
- Congress can override a Veto with vote
- Veto, President to provide reasons
U.S. Judicial Branch
- Article III of the Constitution Establishes the Judicial Branch.
- Courts make laws through judicial opinion.
- Rules of law are binding on lower courts with in the same jurisdiction and are persuasive in other jurisdictions.
- Common Law
Judicial Process
- Federal Court System
- Article 3 of the US Constitution
- Authorizes the Supreme Court and authorizes Congress to establish additional federal courts as necessary.
- District Court = Trial Court
- 12 Districts
- Jurisdiction over US Constitution or questions of federal law, ambassadors, consuls, admiralty or maritime, cases with US as a Party, States vs. States, diversity of citizens
- Article 3 of the US Constitution
- Court of Appeals
- Hear appeals from the lower court
- Review administrative agency decisions
- US Supreme Court
- 9 Justices
- Lifetime appointment
- Court decides on the cases it wants to review
- Other courts
- Tax, Custom and Patent and Trademark
Stare decisis
- To abide by decided cases
- Provides for continuity of decisions
- Expedite judicial decision making
- Not inflexible principle
- Court may vary from precedent if:
- Factual distinctions
- changing times or circumstances
- Duty to Warn
- Court may vary from precedent if:
10th Amendment of the US Constitution
- States have power to legislate in all areas except those prohibited or given to Congress by the U.S. Constitution.
- Generally, States can pass laws to protect the health, safety and welfare of the public.
State Government
- Modeled after the Federal System
- Executive
- Legislative
- Judicial
State Court Systems
- Similar to the Federal System
- In Massachusetts the highest court is the Supreme Judicial Court (SJC)
- Appellate Courts
- Trials Courts
- Other Courts
- Probate, Family, Juvenile, Traffic and Small Claims Court
Key State Agencies (Massachusetts)
- Department of Medical Assistance (DMA)
- Medicaid policy and reimbursement
- Department of Public Health (DPH)
- Board of Registration in Pharmacy (BOP)
- Pharmacy Practice Acts
- Board of Registration in Pharmacy (BOP)
Federal or State Law
- State authority to regulate in any area Congress has regulated as long as there is no conflict between State and Federal law.
U.S. Constitution: “Supremacy Clause”
- Supremacy Clause (Article VI, clause 2): “This Constituion, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the Supreme law of the land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.”
Two (2) Types of Federal Preemption
Express preemption
- Arises when a federal statute specifically provides that it preempts state law
- "If a federal law contains an express pre-emption clause, it does not immediately end the inquiry because the question of the substance and scope of Congress' displacement of state law still remains." (Atria Group, Inc. v. Good, 555 U.S. 70 (2008); Decided December 15, 2008)
Implied preemption
- Arises when the federal statute or regulation provides no room for the states to supplement it or where state law stands as an obstacle to the accomplishment and execution of the full purpose and objectives of Congress
Relevant Court Cases on Preemption for the Pharmaceuticals and Medical Devices
Riegel v. Medtronic, Inc. (Decided February 20, 2008)
- Preemption of claim involving Class III medical devices receiving FDA premarket approval
Wyeth v. Levine (Decided March 4, 2009)
- Preemption of claims for inadequate warning following FDA approval of a drug label
Warner-Lambert Co. v. Kent (Decided March 3, 2008)
- Preemption of state tort reform exceptions for fraud-on-the-FDA
Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp. v. Albrecht (Argument Jan 7, 2019; decision pending)
- A state-law failure-to-warn claim is pre-empted when the Food and Drug Administration rejected the drug manufacturer's proposal to warn about the risk after being provided with the relevant scientific data, or whether such a case must go to a jury for conjecture as to why the FDA rejected the proposed warning