The Jacksonian Era: Politics, Conflict, and the Second Generation
The Transition of the Revolutionary Generation
- The era marks the end of the revolutionary generation, which included figures such as Washington, Jefferson, and Madison.
- The election of 1824 signifies the rise of the "second generation" of American leaders.
- Key figures of this new generation include:
- John Quincy Adams.
- Andrew Jackson.
- William H. Crawford: Described as an "also ran" for the presidency.
- Martin Van Buren: Referred to as Jackson's "right hand."
- Henry Clay.
- John C. Calhoun.
- Daniel Webster: Identified as the last of this specific generation.
- This generation will dominate U.S. politics for approximately 25 to 30 years, leading the country toward the Civil War.
- The deaths of Henry Clay and John C. Calhoun occurred at nearly the same time, coinciding with the Compromise of 1850.
- This period eventually gives way to the Lincoln-Douglas generation.
The Election of 1824 and the Rise of Jacksonian Politics
- The election of 1824 is significant due to its lack of a clear majority.
- Current standing in 1824:
- There were essentially five candidates, but four main contenders.
- Andrew Jackson had the most popular and electoral votes but did not have a majority.
- Because no candidate secured a majority, extensive mudslinging ensued.
- Jackson eventually wins (in 1828) and implements the Spoils System.
- Definition of the Spoils System: The practice of giving government jobs to one’s friends and supporters.
- Historical Evolution: In the late 1800s, this practice became known as "patronage."
- Rationale for the Spoils System:
- Presidents want to be surrounded by people they trust.
- It serves as a way to reward political supporters (e.g., appointing a major fundraiser as an ambassador to Japan, even if they do not speak the language).
- Comparison to the "Ohio Gang": Similar to President Warren G. Harding bringing his friends from Ohio to D.C., though not all of Harding's associates held official posts.
Andrew Jackson as "Old Hickory"
- Jackson’s nickname was "Old Hickory."
- Political Cartoons:
- Frequently appear on the AP exam.
- Generally critical of Jackson.
- Portray him as acting without Congressional authority.
- Use metaphors like "wasting hands with the purse" to critique his fiscal or executive actions.
The Peggy Eaton Affair and Cabinet Discord
- The Peggy Eaton affair caused a significant rift between President Jackson and Vice President John C. Calhoun.
- Background on Rachel Jackson:
- Jackson's wife, Rachel, died shortly after he came into office (around the time of his inauguration).
- Rumors had persisted for years that she were married to Jackson before her divorce from her first husband was finalized.
- Jackson maintained the divorce was legal; others whispered doubts, which deeply angered Jackson.
- Role of the First Lady:
- With Rachel Jackson's death, there was no First Lady in D.C.
- The job of the First Lady included hosting White House dinners and supporting charitable causes.
- Floride Calhoun (wife of John C. Calhoun) became the "standard bearer" of D.C. society.
- The Conflict:
- Peggy Eaton was the wife of a cabinet member (John Eaton).
- D.C. society, led by Mrs. Calhoun, refused to accept or socialize with Peggy Eaton.
- Jackson, sensitive about social ostracization due to his late wife's experience, demanded Peggy be accepted.
- Calhoun refused to comply.
- Outcome: This social rift eventually led to Calhoun's resignation and exacerbated the future fight over Nullification.
The Tariff of Abominations
- This was the highest tariff in U.S. history up to that time.
- Legislative History:
- Passed on 05/19/1828.
- Passed before Jackson took office as an electoral tactic by John Quincy Adams' supporters.
- The goal was to split southern support away from Jackson to aid Adams' re-election bid in November 1828.
- Jackson’s Enforcement Policy:
- Jackson believed the tariff was "too high and stupid."
- However, he viewed it as federal law and insisted on enforcing it regardless of personal opinion.
- Historical Parallels for Federal Law Enforcement:
- George Washington: Enforcing federal law during the Whiskey Rebellion.
- Dwight D. Eisenhower: Enforcing civil rights and integration for the Little Rock Nine despite being "late to civil rights."
Indian Removal and Legal Sovereignty
- Popularity: The Indian Removal Act was popular among the general American voting public.
- Relocation Geography:
- Native Americans were moved to "Indian Territory," which is modern-day Oklahoma.
- Under T. Jefferson, some tribes had previously been given territory in Missouri.
- Significant Court Cases:
- Cherokee Nation v. Georgia: Established that the Cherokee were a "sovereign nation."
- Worcester v. Georgia: Focused on the Indian Removal Act. The court ruled the Cherokee were a sovereign nation with a right to their property.
- Jackson’s Response to Chief Justice Marshall: Jackson essentially said, "Marshall… you can enforce your ruling," effectively ignoring the Supreme Court's decision.
- Second Seminole War: This conflict resulted in the U.S. gaining control of Florida through occupation and eventual treaty.
The Trail of Tears
- There were two primary routes used to forcedly relocate tribes to Indian territory:
- The "Blue Route": Relocation by water (the better route).
- The "Red Route": Relocation by land (the worst route).
- Note: A "yellow route" did not exist because of the mountains.
- Hardships of the Red Route:
- Forced to walk through approximately five different states.
- No established roads (referenced as "no I-80").
- Required traversing through mountain ranges.
The Bank War and the Panic of 1837
- The Bank War:
- Outcome: Jackson won the political battle against the National Bank.
- Consequence: America lost economically as the bank's destruction led to a financial panic.
- Specie Circular: An executive order by Jackson that significantly impacted the economy.
- Economic Competence: The speaker suggests Jackson understood as little about economics as Thomas Jefferson did.
- Timeline of the Panic of 1837:
- Jackson's term ended in 1836, so he did not deal with the fallout.
- Management of the panic fell to Martin Van Buren, effectively destroying his presidency.
The Presidency of Martin Van Buren and the Amistad
- Van Buren's term was defined by the Panic of 1837.
- The Amistad Case:
- Involved a slave ship landing in the United States.
- It was a major issue that further divided the country along sectional lines.
Questions & Discussion
- Question: Is the practice of the Spoils System similar to what happened with the "Ohio Gang" under another president?
- Response: It is a little different. President Harding brought the "Ohio Gang" to D.C., and while many were not assigned to official government posts, the practice of surrounding oneself with friends/associates reflects some similarities with the Spoils System/patronage.
- Question: Can you repeat the question regarding the slave ship?
- Response: The ship was the Amistad. It is something students should be aware of as it was a major event that divided the country and is relevant for upcoming studies.