Civil procedure rules

THE LAWSUIT FLOW

Rule 3 — An action begins when the plaintiff files the complaint.

Rule 4 — Plaintiff serves the defendant with the summons + complaint.

Rule 12(a) — Defendant generally has 21 days to respond.

Defendant responds with an Answer or a Rule 12 motion.

RULE 4 — SERVICE

Rule 4(c): Summons must be served with a copy of the complaint. Plaintiff is responsible for service.

Rule 4(e): An individual may be served by (1) state-law service, (2) personal delivery, (3) leaving summons + complaint at dwelling/usual abode with someone of suitable age and discretion who resides there, or (4) delivery to an authorized agent.

Rule 4(m): Defendant must generally be served within 90 days after the complaint is filed. If good cause exists, the court must extend the time.

RULE 7 — PLEADINGS VS. MOTIONS

Rule 7(a): Allowed pleadings include the complaint, answers to complaints/counterclaims/crossclaims/third-party complaints, third-party complaint, and a court-ordered reply to an answer.

Rule 7(b): A motion is a request for a court order and must state the grounds with particularity and the relief sought.

EXAM: Pleading = claims/defenses. Motion = asks the court to do something.

RULE 8(a) — COMPLAINT

J-C-R:

1. Jurisdiction — short and plain statement of the grounds for the court's jurisdiction.

2. Claim — short and plain statement showing the pleader is entitled to relief.

3. Relief — demand for the relief sought.

EXAM: The complaint does not need every piece of evidence. Under Twombly/Iqbal, it must contain enough well-pleaded factual matter to make the claim plausible.

RULE 8(b) — ANSWER

Defendant must state defenses in short and plain terms and admit or deny the allegations.

Three responses: ADMIT / DENY / LACK OF KNOWLEDGE.

Lack of knowledge sufficient to form a belief = treated as a denial.

Failure to deny an allegation generally means it is admitted, except an allegation about the amount of damages is not admitted merely because it was not denied.

Partial denial: admit the true part and deny the rest.

RULE 8(c) — AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES

Defendant must affirmatively state affirmative defenses.

Common examples: statute of limitations, res judicata, waiver, estoppel, release, payment, fraud, duress, accord and satisfaction, statute of frauds.

EXAM: If it is an affirmative defense, raise it in the answer or risk waiver.

Kanaan: In the case you studied, affirmative defenses were judged under a fair-notice standard rather than Twombly/Iqbal plausibility.

RULE 8(d)-(e) — FORM OF PLEADINGS

Rule 8(d): Allegations must be simple, concise, and direct. No technical form is required.

Alternative or hypothetical claims/defenses are allowed.

Inconsistent claims/defenses are allowed.

Rule 8(e): Pleadings are construed to do justice.

TWOMBLY + IQBAL — RULE 12(b)(6)

Twombly: A complaint must plead enough factual matter to make entitlement to relief plausible, not merely conceivable.

Iqbal: Separate factual allegations from conclusions. Well-pleaded facts are assumed true; conclusory statements are not entitled to the assumption of truth.

EXAM TEST: If the well-pleaded facts, assumed true, do not plausibly establish entitlement to relief → Rule 12(b)(6) dismissal.

CONLEY — KNOW THE HISTORY

Conley: old liberal pleading approach — fair notice / 'no set of facts.'

EXAM: Do not use Conley's 'no set of facts' test as the current Rule 8 standard. Current standard = Twombly/Iqbal plausibility.

RULE 9 — SPECIAL PLEADING

Rule 9(b): Fraud or mistake must be pleaded with particularity.

Malice, intent, knowledge, and other conditions of mind may be alleged generally.

Rule 9(c): Conditions precedent may generally be alleged to have occurred; a denial that a condition precedent occurred must be stated with particularity.

RULE 10 — FORM

Caption: court name, title, file number, and Rule 7(a) designation.

Claims/defenses are stated in numbered paragraphs, each limited as far as practicable to a single set of circumstances.

A written instrument attached as an exhibit is part of the pleading for all purposes.

RULE 11 — SIGNATURE + SANCTIONS

Every pleading, written motion, and other paper must be signed by an attorney of record or the unrepresented party.

By presenting the paper, the signer certifies after a reasonable inquiry that:

1. Purpose — not for an improper purpose.

2. Law — legal contentions are warranted by existing law or a nonfrivolous argument for changing it.

3. Facts — factual contentions have evidentiary support (or are specifically identified as likely to gain support after discovery).

4. Denials — denials are warranted by evidence or reasonably based on belief/lack of information.

Rule 11 safe harbor: A sanctions motion is served first and generally cannot be filed if the challenged paper is withdrawn/corrected within 21 days.

RULE 12(a) — TIME TO RESPOND

Ordinary defendant: 21 days after service of summons + complaint.

Timely waiver of service: generally 60 days after the waiver request was sent; 90 days if sent outside the United States.

RULE 12(b) — THE 7 MOTIONS

1. Lack of SUBJECT-MATTER JURISDICTION.

2. Lack of PERSONAL JURISDICTION.

3. IMPROPER VENUE.

4. INSUFFICIENT PROCESS.

5. INSUFFICIENT SERVICE OF PROCESS.

6. FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM UPON WHICH RELIEF CAN BE GRANTED.

7. FAILURE TO JOIN A PARTY UNDER RULE 19.

MEMORY: Subject → Personal → Venue → Process → Service → Claim → Joinder.

RULE 12 — WAIVER

2–5 = WAIVABLE: personal jurisdiction, venue, process, service.

1 = NEVER WAIVED: subject-matter jurisdiction can be raised at any time; if the court lacks it, the court must dismiss.

6–7 = NOT WAIVED like 2–5: failure to state a claim and Rule 19 joinder can be raised later, including under Rule 12(c) or at trial.

RULE 12(c)-(f)

12(c): After pleadings close, either party may seek judgment on the pleadings, early enough not to delay trial.

12(d): If the court considers matters outside the pleadings on a 12(b)(6) or 12(c) motion, the motion is treated as Rule 56 summary judgment unless the material is excluded.

12(e): More definite statement when a pleading is so vague or ambiguous that the party cannot reasonably prepare a response.

12(f): Court may strike an insufficient defense or redundant, immaterial, impertinent, or scandalous matter.

EXAM ATTACK SHEET

When you see a complaint → Rule 8(a) + Twombly/Iqbal.

When you see service → Rule 4.

When you see defendant's response → Rule 8(b)/(c) + Rule 12.

When you see an affirmative defense → Rule 8(c) + Kanaan.

When you see fraud/mistake → Rule 9(b).

When you see sanctions/frivolous filing → Rule 11.

When you see a motion to dismiss → identify which 12(b) subsection.

When you see waiver → immediately ask: Is it 2–5? If yes, likely waived. Is it 1? Never waived.

When you see 12(b)(6) → Twombly/Iqbal plausibility.

When you see outside material on 12(b)(6) → Rule 12(d) → Rule 56.

ONE-MINUTE MEMORIZATION VERSION

3 = FILE.

4 = SERVE.

7 = PLEADINGS/MOTIONS.

8(a) = J-C-R.

8(b) = ADMIT / DENY / DON'T KNOW.

8(c) = AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES.

8(d) = SIMPLE + ALTERNATIVE + INCONSISTENT.

9(b) = FRAUD PARTICULARITY.

10 = FORM.

11 = PURPOSE / LAW / FACTS / DENIALS + 21-DAY SAFE HARBOR.

12(a) = 21 DAYS.

12(b) = 7 DEFENSES.

12(h) = 2–5 WAIVE; 1 NEVER; 6–7 LATER.

Twombly = PLAUSIBLE.

Iqbal = FACTS TRUE, CONCLUSIONS NOT.

Conley = OLD FAIR-NOTICE/NO-SET-OF-FACTS.

Kanaan = AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES → FAIR NOTICE.