The VW Emissions Scandal

Diesel Deception: Volkswagen's Emission Scandal and its Impact

Volkswagen's Diesel Deception

  • Volkswagen (VW), a leading German motor giant, was found to be deceiving emissions tests with a "clever scam."

  • VW programmed their cars' onboard computers with a "defeat device."

    • In the lab, cars appeared clean, but on real roads, pollution levels were up to 40 times the legal limit.

  • In July 2015, VW became the world's biggest carmaker, advertising their cars as "squeaky clean", which was false.

  • Michael Horn, the boss of VW's US business, admitted to lying for years.

  • 11,000,00011,000,000 cars from the VW Group (including Audi's, SEAT's, and Skoda's) had the cheating software, including 1,200,0001,200,000 in the UK.

The Impact on Consumers

  • Consumers who bought VW cars, like Mark and Claire Lithgo, felt "duped" and angry.

  • The "blue motion technology" was a factor in their decision to purchase a Volkswagen Passat.

  • They wanted a car that was reliable, safe, and clean, and VW emphasized the environmental credentials of the vehicle.

How the Defeat Device Works

  • Modern cars are controlled by computers (ECU), which control everything from headlights to the engine's pollution output.

  • The defeat device is software within the car's onboard computer.

  • The car's computer can recognize when it is being tested and reduce pollution output.

  • During high-speed driving, the computer switches out of test mode, leading to higher emissions.

Car Testing and Regulations

  • EU rules and regulations govern car testing.

  • The testing procedure is highly controlled and predictable.

  • Cars must stand indoors for at least six hours to cool to room temperature for a cold start.

  • The test involves driving a specific cycle for twenty minutes and twenty seconds.

  • VW's onboard computer can recognize lab conditions and switch to compliant nitrogen dioxide levels.

The Experiment

  • An experiment was conducted to demonstrate how VW's onboard computer can cheat the European emissions test.

  • A VW Passat Blue Motion was tested, and its emissions were measured.

  • The car passed the emissions test when the computer was plugged into the systems.

  • When the car was driven at high speed and then retested with a hot engine, it failed spectacularly, emitting two and a half times more poisonous gases.

Air Pollution and Health

  • Nitrogen dioxide (NO2) levels remain stubbornly high despite regulations.

  • Diesel vehicles emit more pollutants than they should.

  • The decision to promote diesel cars was made to cut greenhouse gas CO2 emissions, but it led to increased NO2 emissions.

  • Ben Barrett from King's College London conducted an experiment measuring diesel pollution in London.

The London Experiment

  • The experiment involved monitoring people's heart rates in a quiet park and on Oxford Street, a polluted road.

  • Pollution more than doubled, and heart rates climbed on Oxford Street.

  • The research changed perceptions, making pollution a health issue.

  • Asthmatics experienced lung inflammation and decreased lung capacity.

  • Healthy individuals did not get the full health benefit of exercise on polluted streets.

Impact on Children and Vulnerable Populations

  • Pollution affects the young, the old, and the sick the most.

  • Sophie Hyde, a 16-year-old with cystic fibrosis, finds it difficult to breathe in polluted environments.

  • Professor Andrew Bush stated that pollution exposure during pregnancy affects a child's lung function.

  • Pollution can harm one in ten children in big cities, causing lasting damage.

Testing Other Cars

  • Of the 60 newest cars tested, only four were as clean on real roads as in the lab.

  • A Vauxhall Zafira was tested and failed the euro 6 emissions standard, emitting twice the limit of NOx gases.

  • At higher speeds, emissions went off the scale.

  • A hot engine test resulted in even worse emissions, exceeding three and a half times the euro 6 limit.

Ultrafine Particles

  • Diesel engines produce billions of ultrafine particles with every acceleration.

  • These particles can penetrate deep into the lungs and even into cells, affecting the bloodstream and causing clotting.

  • Walking along a busy road can result in 30,000,000,000 particles entering the lungs per hour.

Consequences and Compensation

  • VW promises to fix all its cars but struggles to rebuild trust.

  • Customers want compensation for the loss of value in their cars.

  • VW faces consumer fraud actions, shareholder actions, and actions from those affected by emissions.

  • The cost of repairing 11,000,00011,000,000 cars could be 11,000,000,00011,000,000,000 or more.

  • VW shareholders are claiming €40,000,000,00040,000,000,000 in damages.

Need for Legislation

  • The laws and tests designed to keep diesel cars clean are failing.

  • Legislation is needed to protect children's lungs.

  • Air quality is significantly better in less polluted areas.