Competitive Rivalry and Competitive Dynamics

Competitive Rivalry and Competitive Dynamics

Learning Objectives

  • 5-1 Define competitors, competitive rivalry, competitive behavior, and competitive dynamics.

  • 5-2 Describe market commonality and resource similarity as the building blocks of a competitor analysis.

  • 5-3 Explain awareness, motivation, and ability as drivers of competitive behavior.

  • 5-4 Describe how strategic actions and tactical actions drive competitive rivalry between firms.

  • 5-5 Discuss factors affecting the likelihood a firm will take actions to attack its competitors.

  • 5-6 Explain factors affecting the likelihood a firm will respond to actions its competitors take.

  • 5-7 Explain competitive dynamics in slow-cycle, fast-cycle, and standard-cycle markets.

Industry Case Study: Kroger

  • Kroger emphasizes the importance of online ordering and product stocking to enhance profitability in 2020 and beyond.

  • Intense competition from rivals including Aldi, Walmart, and Safeway affects Kroger's strategic emphasis.

  • Notably, Amazon's acquisition of Whole Foods for approximately $13.7 billion in 2017 signals a shift in competition due to Amazon's growing online capabilities.

  • Strategic Actions: Significant market-based actions that affect competition.

    • Amazon's acquisition of Whole Foods prompts competitive responses from Kroger and others.

    • Kroger’s strategy might include reducing physical storefronts in favor of bolstering e-commerce.

  • CEO Insights: Investments in online capabilities are critical for surviving in a new competitive landscape dominated by e-commerce.

5-1 Understanding Competitors

  • Competitors: Firms operating in the same market, offering similar products, targeting similar customers.

  • Competitive Behavior: Set of actions and responses a company engages in while competing.

    • Competitors interact in pursuit of above-average returns within a structured competitive landscape.

  • Competitive Rivalry: Continuous competitive actions and responses between firms seeking advantageous positions in the market.

    • In high-competitive industries like groceries, firms react to one another's strategic movements.

  • The effectiveness of a firm’s competitive strategy is intrinsically linked to how well it understands its rivalry with competitors.

5-2 Competitor Analysis

5-2a Market Commonality
  • Market Commonality: Extent of overlapping markets between competing firms.

    • Example: Coca-Cola and PepsiCo compete in soft drinks and bottled water, indicating high market commonality.

5-2b Resource Similarity
  • Resource Similarity: Comparison of tangible and intangible resources against a competitor.

    • Firms with similar resources (ex: financial capital, technology) are likely to deploy similar strategies in competition.

5-3 Drivers of Competitive Behavior

  • Awareness: Firms must recognize their interdependence in competitive environments; greater awareness leads to better understanding of actions.

  • Motivation: The perceived benefits and risks of taking action influence a firm’s incentive to act.

  • Ability: Resource availability affects a firm's capacity to take competitive actions.

Example: Coca-Cola vs. PepsiCo
  • Coca-Cola launched new flavors aimed at millennials; PepsiCo responded with innovations in flavored sparkling water, showcasing both competitors' abilities and motivations driven by market awareness.

5-4 Strategic and Tactical Actions

  • Strategic Actions: Major market maneuvers requiring significant resources, difficult to reverse (e.g., product launches, market entry).

  • Tactical Actions: Minor adjustments using fewer resources and are more easily reversible (e.g., pricing adjustments).

  • Companies balance strategic and tactical actions to navigate competitive dynamics effectively.

5-5 Likelihood of Attack

  • First-Mover Advantages: Firms that are first to enter a market can secure loyal customers, shape consumer preferences, and command better market positions longer.

    • Example: Amazon as a first mover in the online retail space.

  • Organizational Size: Small firms often initiate more actions quickly due to their agility, while larger firms take a broader quantity of actions over time.

5-6 Likelihood of Response

  • The firm's response is dependent on:

    • Type of Action: Strategic actions elicit fewer responses compared to tactical ones.

    • Actor's Reputation: A company with a strong reputation garners quicker responses from competitors.

    • Market Dependence: Firms highly reliant on certain markets are more likely to respond to threats in those markets.

5-7 Competitive Dynamics

5-7a Slow-Cycle Markets
  • Characterized by competitors lacking the ability to imitate advantages easily, which helps maintain market positions for extended periods.

    • Example: Swiss watchmakers benefitting from exclusivity until disruptive technologies emerge.

5-7b Fast-Cycle Markets
  • Rapid imitation of advantages occurs, making sustained competitive advantage hard to achieve. Firms rush to innovate continuously.

  • Example: Technology firms competing to dominate new product segments and rapidly executing innovations.

5-7c Standard-Cycle Markets
  • Moderate imitation of advantages exists; firms strive to maintain advantages while competing for market share in highly competitive channels.

Summary

  • Competitors: Firms in the same sector with similar products.

  • Competitive Rivalry: The interplay of actions/responses that shape the market dynamics.

  • Strategic vs. Tactical Actions: Differentiated primarily by resource commitment and reversibility.

  • Competitor Analysis: The cornerstone of understanding and predicting market actions and responses—based an understanding of market commonality and resource similarity.

  • Innovation’s Role: Critical across all types of competition to sustain or improve market positions.