Health Literacy, Digital Health Information & Genetic Counseling

Introduction & Context

  • Webinar supported by Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), but content reflects presenters’ views.

  • Hosted by FORCE (Facing Our Risk of Cancer Empowered).

  • Speakers included:

    • Breast cancer survivor & founder of FORCE

    • Marlia (health communication researcher)

    • Sameer (genetic counselor)


2. Core Concept: What is Health Literacy?

Definition (CDC)

Health literacy = ability to:

  • Find

  • Understand

  • Use health information & services

👉 Key emphasis: “Use”

  • Includes:

    • Accessing care

    • Navigating systems

    • Following treatments

    • Getting referrals

💡 Important Insight:
Health literacy is directly tied to health equity


3. Types of Health Literacy

A. Personal Health Literacy

  • Individual ability to understand health information

⚠ Problem:

  • Labeling patients as “low health literacy” can:

    • Be stigmatizing

    • Oversimplify the issue


B. Organizational Health Literacy

  • How well healthcare systems help patients understand info

💡 Shift in perspective:

  • Problem is not just the patient

  • System must communicate better


C. Systemic Health Literacy

  • Broader system-level factors:

    • Policies

    • Funding

    • Technology

    • Leadership

👉 Health literacy = shared responsibility


D. Digital Health Literacy

  • Ability to:

    • Search

    • Evaluate

    • Apply online health information

⚠ Unique challenges:

  • Overload of information

  • Misinformation

  • Complex navigation


4. Medical Jargon & Patient Understanding

Key Findings from Research

  • Jargon is a major barrier in:

    • Genetic services

    • Cancer prevention

    • Clinical trials

Patient Understanding Study (~1700 participants)

Patients struggled with terms like:

  • “Germline”

  • “Somatic”

  • “Pathogenic variant”

✔ More understood:

  • “Inherited mutation”

  • “Acquired mutation”

💡 Insight:

  • Patients preferred “mutation” over “pathogenic variant”

👉 Lesson:
Patient-centered language > professional terminology


5. Traps of Online Health Information

Major Issues

1. Contradictory Information
  • Same study → completely different headlines

2. Information Overload
  • Millions of results → impossible to filter

3. Exaggeration
  • Media uses:

    • Clickbait

    • Fear-based language

4. Inaccuracy
  • Basic science → misreported as clinical advice

5. Lack of Expert Review
  • Social media spreads unchecked info

6. Missing Context
  • Research misinterpreted for public

7. Paywalls & Jargon
  • Reliable info often inaccessible

8. Confirmation Bias
  • People believe repeated or familiar info


6. Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Health

Benefits

  • Quick summaries

  • Easy access

Major Risks

1. Missing Context
  • No personalization unless prompted

2. Inconsistency
  • Same question → different answers

3. Bias
  • Reflects biased training data

4. Lack of Transparency
  • Sources unclear

5. Privacy Risks
  • Not protected by HIPAA

6. No True Empathy
  • Cannot replace human care

7. Hallucinations
  • AI can fabricate:

    • Citations

    • Facts

8. Sycophancy
  • Gives answers users want to hear


Example Problem

Same question → different answers:

  • Colonoscopy frequency:

    • 1–3 years

    • 3–5 years

    • Average risk

👉 Extremely confusing for patients


New Concern: “Zero-Click” Information

  • AI summarizes info without:

    • Sources

    • Context

  • Leads to:

    • Reduced website traffic (30–40%)

    • Less access to support resources


7. Factors Affecting Health Literacy

A. Social Determinants (Drivers) of Health

5 Domains:

  1. Economic stability

  2. Education

  3. Healthcare access

  4. Social/community context

  5. Environment


B. Economic Factors

Barriers:

  • No paid leave

  • No childcare

  • High costs

  • Transportation issues

⚠ Biases:

  • “Noncompliant”

  • “Not interested”

  • “Drug-seeking”

👉 Reality:

  • Structural barriers, not personal failure


C. Education Factors

Not just level, but:

  • Type of education

  • Critical thinking skills

  • Tech exposure

💡 Key insight:
Even highly educated people fall for misinformation due to confirmation bias


D. Healthcare Access

Important elements:

  • Primary care access

  • Insurance coverage

  • Specialist availability

  • Telehealth access

Example:

  • Medicaid expansion → ↓ cancer mortality


E. Social & Community Context

Influences:

  • Family beliefs

  • Religion

  • Cultural norms

  • Support groups

  • Trust/mistrust in healthcare

⚠ Marginalized groups:

  • Face discrimination → avoid care


F. Environmental Factors

Barriers:

  • Rural vs urban differences

  • Food deserts

  • Internet access

  • Safety

  • Transportation


8. Role of Genetic Counselors

Key responsibilities:

  • Use plain language

  • Ask about barriers

  • Show empathy

  • Recognize biases

  • Advocate for system change

  • Connect patients to resources

💡 Core principle:
👉 “Meet patients where they are”


9. Tools & Resources for Patients

A. SPOT the BOAST Tool

Helps evaluate online info:

BOAST:

  • Biased

  • Overblown

  • Amateur

  • Sales-driven

  • Taken out of context


B. X-Ray Program (FORCE)

Purpose:

  • Evaluate research articles for patients

Includes:

  • Plain language summary

  • Clinical relevance score

  • Strength of evidence

  • Media accuracy rating

💡 Focus:
“What does this mean for me right now?”


10. AI Best Practices

For Providers & Patients:

  • Use specific prompts

  • Always fact-check

  • Use multiple sources

  • Add trusted sources in searches

  • Keep human oversight


11. Key Takeaways

  • Health literacy = shared responsibility

  • Digital health info is complex & risky

  • AI is powerful but unreliable alone

  • Social factors deeply shape health outcomes

  • Genetic counselors are critical bridges

  • Patients need:

    • Clear language

    • Trusted guidance

    • Contextualized information