IFRS 16 Leases: Comprehensive Study Guide for Lessees

Introduction and Overview of IFRS 16 Leases

  • A lease transaction involves two primary parties:

    • Lessor: The party that grants the right to use an asset to another party.

    • Lessee: The party that receives the right to use the asset.

  • Under IFRS 16, for second-year accounting purposes, the focus is exclusively on the lessee's point of view (referencing GG Chapter 16).

  • The lessee is required to recognize a lease by recognizing two specific items on the Statement of Financial Position:

    • Right of Use (ROU) Asset

    • Lease Liability

Scope of IFRS 16

  • IFRS 16 applies to all lease arrangements except for the following specific exclusions:

    • Exploration of non-regenerative resources (e.g., minerals, oil, natural gas).

    • Biological assets within the scope of IAS 41.

    • Service concession arrangements within the scope of IFRIC 12.

    • License for intellectual property within the scope of IFRS 15.

    • Rights under a licensing agreement as part of intangibles within the scope of IAS 38.

Identifying a Lease

  • Definition: A contract, or a part of a contract, is or contains a lease if it conveys the right to use an identified asset for a period of time in exchange for consideration.

  • Criteria for identifying a lease:

    • There must be an identified asset.

    • The lessee must have the right to control the use of that asset.

  • Contract Inception: This is defined as the earlier of:

    • The date of a lease agreement.

    • The date of commitment by the parties to the principal terms and conditions of the lease.

Asset Identification

  • Explicit or Implicit Identification: An asset is identified if it is explicitly stipulated in the contract or implicitly specified at the time the asset is made available for use by the customer.

  • Portions of Assets: A portion of an asset is an identified asset if:

    • It is physically distinct (e.g., a specific floor of a building); OR

    • It reflects substantially all the capacity of the asset (even if not physically distinct).

  • Substantive Right of Substitution: An asset is not identified if the supplier has a substantive right to substitute the asset throughout the period of use. A substitution right is substantive only if the supplier:

    1. Has the practical ability to substitute alternative assets throughout the period of use; AND

    2. Would benefit economically from the exercise of its right to substitute the asset.

  • Default Assumption: If it is difficult to determine whether a substitution right is substantive, the entity shall assume it is not substantive.

Right to Control the Use of an Identified Asset

  • An entity controls the use of an identified asset if, throughout the period of use, it has both of the following:

    1. The right to obtain substantially all of the economic benefits from the use of the identified asset.

    2. The right to direct the use of the identified asset.

Economic Benefits from Use

  • Benefits include direct and indirect benefits, including primary and secondary outputs.

  • Consider only the total benefits possible within the context of the scope of the contracted right of use.

  • The requirement to refund part of the benefits to the lessor (e.g., percentage of revenue) is ignored when deciding if the lessee has the right to "substantially all" benefits.

  • Consider the gross benefits received by the customer.

  • Any amounts paid to the supplier are considered part of the lease payment, not a reduction in benefits received.

Right to Direct the Use

  • The customer has the right to direct the use if:

    • The customer has the right to decide how and for what purpose the asset is used throughout the period of use; OR

    • The relevant decisions about how and for what purpose the asset is used are predetermined, and:

      • The customer has the right to operate the asset (or direct others to operate it) without the supplier having the right to change those operating instructions; OR

      • The customer designed the asset in a way that predetermines how and for what purpose the asset will be used.

Protective Rights and Operational Decisions

  • Protective Rights: These are rights designed to protect the supplier's interest in the underlying asset (e.g., restrictions on where a ship can go). These define the scope of use but do not prevent the customer from having the right to direct use.

  • Operations and Maintenance: Decisions regarding the operations and maintenance of an asset generally do not affect who has the right to direct "how and for what purpose" an asset is used. The right to operate is only considered if the "how and for what purpose" is already predetermined.

Examples of Identifying a Lease

Example 1: Specialized Plant (Aye Ltd and Bee Ltd)

  • Scenario: Bee Ltd manufactures unique engine components for Aye Ltd over 55 years. Bee designs and installs a specialized plant used exclusively for these components. The plant cannot be used for other purposes and must be dismantled afterward.

  • Analysis:

    • The plant is identified implicitly because it was built for the sole purpose of producing Aye's unique components.

    • Bee does not have a substantive right to substitute because the plant is specialized and they would likely not benefit financially from substitution.

  • Conclusion: The specialized plant is an identified asset.

Example 2: Shopping Center Stand (Andy and Bigboy)

  • Scenario: Andy enters a 33-year contract for 16 m216\,\text{m}^2 in a shopping center. Bigboy can move the stand to various suitable areas within the center. Moving costs are minimal.

  • Analysis:

    • Bigboy has the practical ability to substitute the space because variety exists.

    • Bigboy benefits economically from moving the stand to ensure maximum profitability of the center.

  • Conclusion: The substitution right is substantive; therefore, the asset is NOT identified, and no lease exists.

Example 3: Pipeline Capacity (Ally and Bruiser)

  • Scenario: Ally uses Bruiser's pipeline to receive oil. The quantity delivered represents 20%20\% of the pipeline's daily capacity.

  • Analysis:

    • The 20%20\% portion is not physically distinct.

    • The 20%20\% portion does not represent substantially all the capacity of the pipeline.

  • Conclusion: The asset is NOT identified.

Example 4: Wind Farm Benefits (Tee Ltd and Vee Ltd)

  • Scenario: Tee buys the entire supply of green energy from Vee's wind farm. Vee receives tax credits for construction. Tee receives renewable energy credits for usage.

  • Analysis:

    • Benefits of usage: Electricity (primary) and Renewable energy credits (by-product). Tee receives 100%100\% of these.

    • Benefits of ownership: Tax credits for construction. Vee receives these.

  • Conclusion: Since Tee obtains substantially all economic benefits from the use of the asset, Tee should recognize the ROU asset.

Example 5: Revenue Sharing (Jay and Lessor)

  • Scenario: Jay pays R1 000R1\,000 per month plus 10%10\% of revenue generated. Jay retains 90%90\% of revenue.

  • Conclusion: Jay still has the right to obtain substantially all economic benefits. The 10%10\% payment is part of the lease consideration.

Example 6: Cargo Transport (Eff Ltd and Gee Ltd)

  • Scenario: Gee transports cargo for Eff via ship. The route, cargo, and dates are predetermined in the contract. Gee operates and maintains the ship.

  • Analysis: Eff cannot decide how or for what purpose the ship is used (predetermined). Eff does not operate or design the ship.

  • Conclusion: Eff does not have the right to direct use. No lease exists.

Example 7: Nuclear Power Plant (Em and Aitch)

  • Scenario: Em acquires power from Aitch's plant. Aitch operates it, but Em designed the plant specifically.

  • Analysis: "How and for what purpose" is predetermined by the design. Since Em designed it, Em has the right to direct use.

  • Conclusion: The contract constitutes a lease.

Example 8: Passenger Train (Jay and Elle)

  • Scenario: Jay uses Elle's train on a specific route. Jay decides timing, operators, and passenger count (up to 1 0001\,000 passengers/1 200 km1\,200\,\text{km} per day). Elle maintains the train and can substitute carriages for repairs.

  • Analysis: Jay directs how/for what purpose (when, density). Restrictions on passengers/km are protective rights. Maintenance doesn't affect control.

  • Conclusion: Jay controls the use; the contract constitutes a lease.

Separating Lease Components

  • If a contract contains lease and non-lease components (e.g., lease of a plant plus maintenance services), they must be accounted for separately.

  • Criteria for a separate lease component:

    1. The lessee can benefit from the use of the asset on its own (or with other available resources).

    2. The asset is not highly dependent on or highly interrelated with other assets in the contract.

  • Allocation of consideration:

    • Allocate based on the relative stand-alone price of lease components and the aggregate stand-alone price of non-lease components.

Example 9: Plant and Maintenance Allocation

  • Contract Total: R12 000R12\,000 for the year.

  • Components:

    • Plant (Lease): Stand-alone price = R10 000R10\,000.

    • Maintenance (Non-lease): Stand-alone price = R5 000R5\,000.

    • Insurance: R2 000R2\,000. (Note: Insurance is not a component as it benefits the lessor).

  • Calculation:

    • Total Stand-alone Price = R10 000+R5 000=R15 000R10\,000 + R5\,000 = R15\,000.

    • Allocation to Plant = 12 000×10 00015 000=R8 00012\,000 \times \frac{10\,000}{15\,000} = R8\,000.

    • Allocation to Maintenance = 12 000×5 00015 000=R4 00012\,000 \times \frac{5\,000}{15\,000} = R4\,000.

Combining Contracts

  • Contracts entered into at or near the same time with the same counterparty are treated as a single contract if:

    1. The assets meet the description of a single lease component together.

    2. Consideration for one contract depends on the price/performance of the other.

    3. Contracts are negotiated as a package and can only be understood together.

Lease Term



  • Commencement Date: The date the lessor makes the underlying asset available for use by the lessee.

  • Components of Lease Term:

    • The non-cancellable period of the lease.

    • Periods covered by an option to extend if the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise it.

    • Periods covered by an option to terminate if the lessee is reasonably certain not to exercise it.

  • Reassessment: The term must be reassessed if a significant event or change in circumstances occurs within the lessee's control that affects the reasonable certainty of options.

Example 13: Extension Certainty

  • Scenario: 33-year non-cancellable lease + 22-year extension option. Extension rates are above market. Significant installation costs paid by lessee. Plant needed for 1010 years.

  • Conclusion: Lease term is 55 years. Although rates are high, the significant installation cost and long-term need for the plant make extension reasonably certain.

Lease Payments

  • Definition: Payments made by a lessee to a lessor relating to the right to use the underlying asset during the lease term.

  • Components include:

    • Fixed payments (including in-substance fixed payments) less any lease incentives.

    • Variable lease payments that depend on an index or rate (e.g., CPI).

    • Exercise price of a purchase option (if reasonably certain to exercise).

    • Penalties for terminating the lease (if the lease term reflects termination).

    • Amounts expected to be payable under residual value guarantees.

  • Exclusions: Payments for non-lease components (unless the lessee elects to combine them).

Recognition and Measurement

Initial Measurement

  • Lease Liability: The present value (PV) of the lease payments that are not paid at the commencement date.

  • Discount Rate: Use the interest rate implicit in the lease. If not easily determinable, use the lessee's incremental borrowing rate.

  • ROU Asset Cost:

    1. Amount of initial measurement of the lease liability.

    2. Plus: Any lease payments made at or before the commencement date (Prepaid lease payments).

    3. Plus: Any initial direct costs incurred by the lessee.

    4. Plus: An estimate of costs for dismantling/restoring the asset (PV of estimated future costs).

    5. Less: Any lease incentives received.

Example 15: Initial Recognition Calculation

  • Lease details: 44 years. 55 payments of R10 000R10\,000. First payment in advance (Jan 1), next four in arrears (Dec 31). Discount rate 10%10\%.

  • Lease Liability calculation (PV of payments still payable at commencement):

    • 10 000×11.11=9 09110\,000 \times \frac{1}{1.1^1} = 9\,091

    • 10 000×11.12=8 26510\,000 \times \frac{1}{1.1^2} = 8\,265

    • 10 000×11.13=7 51310\,000 \times \frac{1}{1.1^3} = 7\,513

    • 10 000×11.14=6 83010\,000 \times \frac{1}{1.1^4} = 6\,830

    • Total PV of Liability = R31 699R31\,699.

  • ROU Asset calculation:

    • 31 69931\,699 (Liability) + 10 00010\,000 (Advance payment) = R41 699R41\,699.

Subsequent Measurement

  • Lease Liability: Measured using the amortized cost method. Amortization schedules show balance, interest (at the discount rate), payments, and closing balance.

  • ROU Asset: Measured using the cost model (unless PPE revaluation or IP fair value models apply). It is subjected to:

    • Depreciation

    • Impairment testing (IAS 36)

Depreciation of ROU Assets

  • If ownership transfers at the end of the lease or the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise a purchase option:

    • Depreciate over the useful life (UL) of the asset.

  • If ownership does NOT transfer:

    • Depreciate over the earlier of: The useful life of the ROU asset OR the end of the lease term.

Example 18: Depreciation Periods

  • Scenario: Cost R10 000R10\,000, UL 1010 years, Lease term 55 years.

  • 1. Ownership transfers: Depreciate over 1010 years (R1 000 p.a.R1\,000\,\text{p.a.}).

  • 2. No transfer/purchase option: Depreciate over 55 years (R2 000 p.a.R2\,000\,\text{p.a.}).

  • 3. Purchase option reasonably certain: Depreciate over 1010 years (R1 000 p.a.R1\,000\,\text{p.a.}).

Impairment and Taxation

Example 19: Impairment of ROU Asset

  • Cost: R10 000R10\,000. Term: 55 years (R2 000 p.a.R2\,000\,\text{p.a.} depreciation).

  • At 31 Dec 20X2: Carrying amount (CA) = R6 000R6\,000 (10 000−4 00010\,000 - 4\,000).

  • Recoverable Amount (RA): R3 000R3\,000.

  • Impairment Loss: 6 000−3 000=R3 0006\,000 - 3\,000 = R3\,000

  • Subsequent Depreciation (20X3): 3 000 (new CA)/3 (remaining years)=R1 0003\,000 \text{ (new CA)} / 3 \text{ (remaining years)} = R1\,000.

Taxation (Basics)

  • Right of Use Asset: Tax Base (TB) is usually zero because the lessee doesn't get wear-and-tear deductions (the lessor typically does).

  • Lease Liability: Tax Base is usually zero because the carrying amount is offset by future tax deductions (the full lease payment is often deductible).

  • Example state:

    • ROU Asset: CA 100100, TB 00, Temporary Difference (TD) (100)(100), Deferred Tax (DT) (30)(30).

    • Lease Liability: CA (100)(100), TB 00, TD 100100, DT 3030.

Presentation and Disclosure

Statement of Financial Position

  • Assets: Non-current Assets -> Right of use assets.

  • Liabilities:

    • Non-current liabilities -> Non-current portion of lease liability.

    • Current liabilities -> Current portion of lease liability.

Disclosure Requirements

  • Profit and Loss: Depreciation charge, interest expense on lease liabilities, variable lease payments not included in the liability, and rent income from sub-leasing.

  • Notes:

    • Detailed schedule of ROU assets (additions, impairments).

    • Maturity analysis of future lease payments (contractual undiscounted cash flows).

    • Total cash outflows for leases.

    • Qualitative information (nature of leasing activities, options, etc.).