Chapter 1 of Drugs and Society

Chapter One: Drug Controversies and Demonization

The Appeal of Drugs

  • Variety of States: Drugs can provide states of relaxation, ecstatic happiness, negation of suffering, transformed perceptions, or alertness (Walton, 2002).

Ubiquity of Drug Use

  • Statistics from SAMHSA (2018):

    • 30.5 million Americans aged 12+ used illegal drugs in the past month (11.2% of this age group).

    • 140.6 million current alcohol users and 48.7 million current cigarette smokers.

    • 55% of the US population took at least one prescription medicine in 2016.

    • 4.5 billion prescriptions were filled in the US (2016).

    • US medicine spending reached $450 billion (2016).

  • Global Perspective:

    • UNODC (2018) reported 275 million users of illegal drugs worldwide (5.6% of population aged 15–64).

    • Revenue from illicit drug trade estimated between $426 billion and $652 billion (Tharoor, 2017).

Drug Use as a Human Appetite

  • Commentators argue that intoxication may represent a basic human appetite, questioning sobriety as a norm (Weil, 1986).


Animal Behavior and Drug Use

  • Examples of non-human drug use:

    • Elephants enjoy fermented beverages (rice beer).

    • Howler monkeys consume overripe palm fruit.

    • Flies use alcohol scents for procreation (Bilger, 2009).

Harm versus Benefit of Drugs

  • Legal drugs like tobacco and alcohol are associated with significant harm:

    • Nearly 6 million deaths per year linked to tobacco (CDC, 2017).

    • 88,000 alcohol-related deaths annually in the US (NIAAA, 2017).

    • 17,000 deaths from prescription opioids (NIDA, 2019).

Legal vs. Illegal Drugs

  • Question arises: Why are legal substances with high harm accepted while certain less harmful drugs (e.g., marijuana) remain illegal?

    • Because people tend to demonize certain drugs for money and power

  • Highlighted mass incarceration for drug offenses in the US:

    • 435,000 drug offense incarcerations in the US, versus 574,469 across 28 EU nations (Wagner & Sawyer, 2018).


Demonizing Drug Use

The Social Construction of Drug Epidemics

  • Widespread use of psychoactive substances necessitates a narrative around addiction and crime (O'Grady, 2010).

  • Government and media create heroes and villains through the lens of drug use.

  • Drug addiction often scapegoated as a cause for broader social issues.

Tactics of Demonization

  • Alleged correlations drawn without empirical evidence:

    • Nixon's claim that heroin users were responsible for $2 billion in property crimes is questionable against the actual property crime total.

  • Claims of drugs inducing bizarre or violent behavior (termed "voodoo pharmacology" Sullum, 2003a).

  • Racial and societal prejudices amplified by attributing drug use to minorities and foreign traffickers (Musto, 1999).


Specific Case Studies of Drug Epidemics

Glue-Sniffing Epidemic (1950s-60s)

  • Emergence of glue-sniffing largely attributed to media panic following a few arrests.

  • Claims of bizarre behaviors and violent acts associated with glue were sensationalized by media reports.

  • Investigations later revealed many deaths associated with glue were misattributed to actual glue use.

Marijuana Use and Its Demonization

  • Historical perception of marijuana as a drug for minorities fueling violence and crime.

  • Propaganda campaigns in the 1930s led to exaggerated fears of marijuana users (e.g., "Reefer Madness").

  • Claims of marijuana leading to violent crimes and sexual deviance dominated early narratives.


Construction of Recent Drug Epidemics

Crack Cocaine (1980s)

  • Media campaigns framed crack as a national crisis linked to social issues in the 1980s (Brownstein, 1996).

  • Contrasts between crack and powder cocaine were exaggerated to frame crack as more dangerous.

Ecstasy (MDMA)

  • Initially explored for therapeutic benefits, later demonized as it became popular in youth culture during the late 1990s.

  • Media panic resulted from alleged increases in ecstasy users causing violent crime.

Opioid Epidemic

  • Statistically, opioid overdose deaths became the leading cause of death among Americans under 50 by 2017.

    • Significant evident rise in prescription opioid use correlating with synthetic opioid issues like fentanyl.

  • Vulnerability and systemic issues in opioid prescription practices initiated the crisis.


Conclusion

  • The chapter reflects the historical and current perceptions of drug use as socially constructed epidemics, influenced heavily by government and media narratives.

  • Drugs, legal and illegal, invoke societal reactions that oscillate between moral panic and public health considerations.