19th Century Architecture

Stairwell Design by Mister Schiffle

  • Mister Schiffle was a notable draftsman who produced a significant drawing of a stairwell published in his collected works around 1840.

  • The published print illustrates:

    • The upper floor of the stair hall, which is more open compared to the lower floors.

    • A screen of columns separating the hall from the outside.

    • The staircase leading to a landing, from which a corridor extends, populated by well-dressed early nineteenth-century Germans observing museum exhibits.

  • This perspective reveals the intended use of the staircase.

  • Modern modifications include a wall of glazing which, while preserving some of the design, diminishes its original effect.

Room with a Dome

  • The central room of the building is topped by a dome, encapsulated in a white box set back from the main facade, and rises above the roofline of the museum.

  • A painting shows the dome’s appearance, revealing:

    • A two-story space with Corinthian columns on the first floor.

    • A second floor that is devoid of columns.

    • A hemispherical dome with coffers features an opening at its apex, which is glazed to prevent weather interference in Berlin's cold and rainy climate.

Comparison to the Roman Pantheon

  • The hemispherical dome with an ocular opening resembles the Roman Pantheon, which also incorporates:

    • Corinthian order columns on the first story.

    • A second floor with minimal columns.

    • A dome featuring coffers and an open oculus.

  • In contrast, the Pantheon's oculus is directly exposed to the elements, unlike the glazed dome in Berlin.

  • The design by Schenkel reflects an architectural eclecticism:

    • The exterior remains Greek, while the interior showcases Roman elements.

    • This fusion signifies Schenkel's versatility in design styles while acknowledging historical influences.

Schenkel’s Later Architectural Developments

  • In the 1830s, Schenkel expanded his architectural repertoire beyond ancient Greek styles, including:

    • A church designed in Berlin with three distinct proposals in various architectural styles, of which the Gothic design was ultimately chosen for construction.

Gothic Architecture Revival

  • The Gothic revival is epitomized by the Houses of Parliament in London, located on the banks of the Thames River in Westminster.

  • Historical Context of Westminster:

    • Derived from Westminster Palace, historically utilized by the English monarchy but reassigned to Parliament due to diminished royal use.

    • A significant fire in 1834 led to the construction of a new Parliament building, following an architectural competition.

Architectural Competition Requirements

  • Architects were instructed to design in either Gothic or Elizabethan styles only, excluding classical architecture.

  • Reasons for the restriction include:

    • The close proximity of Westminster Abbey, a notable Gothic structure, influencing the desired stylistic approach.

    • Preservation of the remaining parts of Westminster Palace, harmonizing new construction with existing Gothic architecture.

    • A cultural revival of Gothic architecture in response to its historical significance and royal ties to the Middle Ages.

Historical Misconceptions of Gothic Origins

  • Throughout the late 18th century, various European countries attempted to claim the origins of Gothic architecture, often with incorrect assertions.

  • Notable figures, such as the German poet Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, erroneously credited Germanic roots to Gothic architecture through essays like 'Von Neutsche Mauthwitz'.

  • Actual invention of Gothic architecture is traced to Northern France and spread to England post-1066 with the Norman conquest.

National Identity through Architecture

  • The design of the new Parliament building aimed to evoke English identity and connection to medieval traditions in governance.

Westminster Hall

  • A remnant of the old Westminster Palace, known for its large size and ceremonial importance.

  • Features:

    • A hammer beam ceiling, representative of late Gothic construction techniques, built in 1394.

Charles Barry and A.W.N. Pugin

  • Charles Barry was an architect with a neoclassical background, involved in the competition for the new Palace of Westminster.

  • Barry engaged A.W.N. Pugin, a Gothic architecture specialist, to enhance his design.

  • Their collaboration resulted in a successful design that combined elements of both architectural styles:

    • Barry structured the building’s plan and sections, while Pugin handled its elevations.

Architectural Design of the Houses of Parliament

  • The building displays a symmetrical layout influenced by both Gothic and classical design principles:

    • Two houses of Parliament (House of Lords and House of Commons) connected by a central hallway.

    • The architecture reflects traditional Gothic elements while also incorporating classic organizational techniques.

Layout and Structural Features

  • The layout includes:

    • A central octagonal hall serving as a junction for the two legislative chambers.

    • An irregular axis to align with Westminster Hall’s existing structure.

    • Several towers, with the Victoria Tower serving as the official entrance for royal visits, and the Clock Tower containing "Big Ben".

Elevation and Roof Details

  • The architectural style draws from the perpendicular Gothic tradition, reflected in:

    • The vertical and horizontal lines of the design, as seen in the windows and façades of the building.

  • Details such as pointed arches, crockets, and crowns, along with unique Gothic enhancements, signify Fuget's creative contributions.

  • Heights of towers: Victoria Tower at 323 feet and Clock Tower at 315 feet.

Senate Chamber Interiors

  • The House of Lords features rich design with intricate stained glass and a grand hammer beam ceiling, enhancing its ceremonial atmosphere.

  • The House of Commons, in contrast, is simpler and reflects post-war reconstruction efforts after being damaged during the Blitz in 1940.

Pugin’s Perspective on Architectural Integrity

  • Pugin expressed dissatisfaction with the Houses of Parliament, feeling it was not truly Gothic:

    • Predominantly classical in structure, criticized for lacking authentic Gothic characteristics.

    • The architectural community did not share Pugin’s sentiments, as the building gained public acclaim.

Pugin’s Advocacy for Gothic Architecture

  • Pugin published works advocating for the superiority of Gothic architecture, contributing to architectural discourse in the 19th century.

  • His polemical book "Contrasts" argues the decline of modern taste by comparing contemporary buildings unfavorably against Gothic designs from the 14th and 15th centuries.

  • Pugin utilized sketches to illustrate the harmony and aesthetic appeal of Gothic architecture compared to modern equivalents, emphasizing a nostalgic view of Gothic purity.