Study Notes: Hieronymus Frank on the Monastic Forgeries of Gregory and Boniface

Historical Context and the Boehmer Thesis

  • Heinrich Boehmer's Assertion: In his foundational work, Die Fälschungen Erzbischof Lanfranks von Canterbury, Boehmer argued that Archbishop Lanfranc of Canterbury (10701070-10891089) was responsible for forging ten papal privileges and three monastic canons to support the interests of Canterbury and its cathedral monastery.

  • Scope of Study: Hieronymus Frank, OSB, focuses on two of these monastic canons attributed to Pope Gregory the Great and Pope Boniface. These canons were long recognized as forgeries (Jaffé-Loewenfeld Nr. 951951 and 19511951).

  • Previous Scholarly Refutations: Scholars such as Macdonald (19261926), Brooke (19311931), and Holtzmann (19301930) had already attempted to distance Lanfranc from the ten papal privileges. Hieronymus Frank seeks to extend this "rehabilitation" to the monastic canons.

  • Manuscript Trinity College Cambridge 405405: This manuscript contains the church law collection spread by Lanfranc. Boehmer claimed these canons were inserted here as Lanfranc's handiwork around 10721072. However, later research suggests these could have been added after Lanfranc's death.

Evidence for Pre-10721072 Origins in Europe

  • Chronological Discrepancy: Frank argues that if these canons existed outside of England and prior to 10721072, Lanfranc could not be their author.

  • The Monte Cassino Evidence: A manuscript from Monte Cassino (Cod. Casinensis 213213 or 230230), dated to approximately the mid-11th11\text{th} century (10501050), contains a version of the decretum Gregorii. This version already adapts the old Gregorian canon to the Cluniac monastic rite.

  • French Manuscript Evidence: MS 3232 from Chälons-sur-Marne, originating from the monastery of St. Pierre, contains both the Gregory and Boniface canons. Paleographical analysis by scholars like Seckel and Levison places this hand in the 11th11\text{th} century, likely toward the end, but representing a tradition that predates Lanfranc’s tenure in England.

  • Witness of Petrus Damiani: In 10581058, Petrus Damiani cited the Canon of Boniface verbatim in his Apologeticus monachorum adversus canonicos. This proves the forgery was in circulation in Italy at least 1414 years before the date Boehmer assigned to Lanfranc’s activity.

Liturgical Analysis of the Monastic Consecration Rite

  • The Decretum Gregorii: This forged text outlines the ritual for the consecration of a monk. It reflects a specific medieval interpretation called the "Cluniac type."

  • The Number of Prayers: Whereas the older Canon of Theodore or early Gregorian texts specified 33 prayers, the forged decretum mandates 44 prayers (symbolizing the four Gospels).

  • Symbolism of the Hood (Capitium): The rite involves the monk’s head being covered for 33 days, as opposed to the 77 days found in earlier traditions. On the third day, the abbot removes the hood, symbolizing the removal of the "tristitia" (sadness) of old sin and the resurrection with Christ.

  • Lanfranc's Consuetudines: Lanfranc's own writings on the benedictio novitii (Chapter 1515) match the Cluniac ritual of 44 prayers. Frank concludes that Lanfranc was quoting an existing forged canon rather than creating it himself.

The Conflict Over Pastoral Care (Cura Animarum)

  • The Theological Claim: The central purpose of these forgeries was to defend the right of monk-priests to perform pastoral duties, such as preaching, baptizing, and administering penance.

  • Monastic "Second Baptism": The text argues that the monastic profession is like a second baptism, cleansing the individual of all prior sins. Therefore, a monk-priest supposedly has greater authority or "power to loose and bind" (potestatemligandiatquesolvendipotestatem ligandi atque solvendi) than a secular priest who may still be mired in the world.

  • Apostolic Life: The forgeries link the monastic life to the Vita Apostolica and the communal living described in the Acts of the Apostles, specifically referencing the community having "one heart and one soul" in Acts 4:324:32.

  • The Nicaean Reference: The forged texts frequently invoke the authority of the 318318 Fathers of the Council of Nicaea to legitimize the monastic right to the priesthood and soul-care.

Opposing Forgeries and the Canon Law Struggle

  • The Pseudo-Nicene and Pseudo-Eugenian Canons: At the same time the monastic forgeries were circulating, opposing forgeries were created to exclude monks from pastoral care. These claimed that monks must remain in their cloisters like fish in water and should have no power over penance or burial of the laity.

  • Anselm of Lucca and the Polycarpus: These "anti-monastic" forgeries appeared in later recensions of Anselm of Lucca’s collection and in the Polycarpus of Cardinal Gregory (10401040-11061106).

  • The Role of Ivo of Chartres: In his Decretum and Panormia (approx. 10941094), Ivo of Chartres included the Canon of Boniface but omitted the decretum Gregorii. Frank notes that Ivo may have disapproved of the term "consecratio" applied to monastic profession, preferring a more restrained view of the rite.

Final Academic Conclusions

  • Italian Origin: Hieronymus Frank concludes that both forgeries likely originated in a single workshop in Italy during the mid-11th11\text{th} century, possibly under Cluniac influence.

  • Lanfranc's Innocence: Lanfranc is cleared of the charge of forgery; he was merely a user of existing canonical and liturgical texts that had already migrated from Italy and France to England.

  • Evolution of the Text: The study reveals that the decretum Gregorii was likely composed in two parts: a liturgical instruction on monk consecration and a legal defense of the monk-priest’s status, which were eventually fused into the definitive version found in the Chälons manuscript.

Would you like a summary of the next section of the research concerning the internal manuscript variations found in the Trinity College collection?