W1, L2

History and Customary Legal Framework of Maori Land Ownership

Introduction and Context of Maori Land Ownership

  • Speaker's Condition and Caveats: The lecturer noted a lack of sleep but clarified the condition is not contagious, though it impacts their energy level.

  • Recap of Pre-Settlement Ownership:

    • Land was originally "customary land" held under Maori customary title.

    • Ownership was collective; everyone held rights and obligations toward the land.

    • Distinct boundaries existed and continue to be acknowledged today.

  • The Nature of Communal Ownership:

    • Despite being communal, there were clear notions of individual use-rights and theft in pre-settlement society.

    • The "Garden Example": A person might say, "It's my garden. Don't touch my garden." While the owner has an obligation to assist others in need, others cannot simply take from the garden without permission.

Traditional Rights and the Concept of Take

  • Definition of Take (T−a−k−eT-a-k-e): The word translates literally to "right" or "claim."

  • The Four Primary Take (Formalized by the Native Land Court): During the 19th19^{th} century, Native Land Court judges required order regarding land claims, leading to the formalization of these four:

    1. Take Tupuna: An ancestral claim based on heritage.

    2. Take Kite: A claim by way of discovery.

    3. Take Tuku: A claim by means of a gift.

    4. Take Raupatu: A claim by means of conquest.

  • Additional Take (Contextual Detail):

    • Takehoko (H−o−k−oH-o-k-o): A claim through trade or purchase.

    • Example: An ancestor named Urihiya purchased rights to a river from another chief using two Mereponem (greenstone clubs) and several cloaks.

The Principle of Ahika (The Lit Fire)

  • Definition of Ahika:

    • AhiAhi means fire; KaKa means to be lit.

    • Ahika Roa: A "long-burning fire," symbolizing continuous occupation and use of the land.

    • Traditional Right: If your fire is continuous (continuous occupation), your right to the land remains. If the fire goes out (abandonment), the right is extinguished.

  • Losing Rights Through Abandonment:

    1. Rights are generally lost if land is abandoned for more than a generation or two (1−21-2 generations).

    2. Example of the Spring: An ancestor purchased rights to a spring near Kaikoura but decided it was not useful and left. Within six generations, under customary rights, the claim was considered lost.

  • Case Study: The Muttonbird Islands (Titi Islands):

    • Located at the bottom of the South Island.

    • The birds (Sooty Shearwater) are preserved in fat and are a traditional food source.

    • Right to the islands is maintained via AhikaAhika.

    • The speaker's great-grandfather went "birding," but subsequent generations (grandfather, mother, and the speaker) did not. Consequently, the speaker cannot legally go back to bird on those islands because the "fire went out."

    • Rekindling the Fire: To restore these rights, one must accompany active relations birding for a significant period—likely 55, 77, or even 1010 years—before rights are restored within custom.

  • Maintaining Connection and Oral Tradition:

    • Rights are often maintained via oral tradition rather than paper titles.

    • Familiarity and lineage: In tribal areas (e.g., South or Wairarapa), people identify others by their grandparents. For instance, being recognized as "John's grandson" or a descendant of the last person to live there (e.g., a great-grandmother named Ngatuere).

    • Level of Familiarity: AhikaAhika does not require 24/724/7 tending of a literal fire; it involves understanding your right and maintaining a relationship/familiarity with the people who do live there and "stoke the fire" constantly.

  • Ahimataotao (M−a−t−a−o−t−a−oM-a-t-a-o-t-a-o):

    • Translates to a "frozen" or "cold fire."

    • This signifies a right that has been definitively extinguished and is nearly impossible to reignite (like trying to light wet wood).

Durability of Different Claims

  • Take Tupuna (Ancestral): Very hard to lose, especially if descending from a primary ancestor of that place.

  • Take Kite (Discovery): Combined with ancestral rights, making it extremely difficult to lose.

  • Take Tuku (Gift): Lost relatively easily because there is often no ancestral tie.

    • Common reasons for TaketukuTaketuku: Wedding gifts or compensation (e.g., compensating for stolen kumara by giving up bird-snaring grounds).

  • Take Raupatu (Conquest):

    • This claim can be lost quickly if AhikaAhika is not maintained.

    • Customary law requires the conqueror to reside on the land indefinitely.

    • Historical Example (1820s1820s): The Ngati Toa tribe defeated the speaker's people in Kaikoura and Kaiapoi but then left. Later in the 19th19^{th} century, Ngati Toa tried to sell the land. The speaker's ancestors argued that while Ngati Toa had conquered them, they had failed to maintain AhikaAhika, thus losing their claim under customary law.

Pre-Treaty and Post-Treaty Land Issues

  • Dodgy Land Deals:

    • Tribes often used land sales to settle old grudges. For example, a person might sell land in Timaru to the New Zealand Company for a low price (e.g., \text{#}5) just to spite enemies living there.

    • Settlers and land-buying agents often did not care if the seller had a legitimate customary right.

  • Treaty of Waitangi (1840):

    1. Article 1: Maori version grants KawanatangaKawanatanga (governorship); English version grants Sovereignty.

    2. Article 2: Protects TeTinoRangatiratangaTe Tino Rangatiratanga (Maori rights to lands, fisheries, and taonga). It established the Crown's Exclusive Right of Preemption.

      • Preemption: The Crown has the sole right to purchase land. This was theoretically to stop dodgy deals, but practically allowed the Crown to set a monopoly price.

    3. Article 3: Grants Maori the same rights and privileges as British subjects in England.

      • The speaker notes that Article 3 does not mean "equal citizenship" in the sense that everyone is the same under one law; such an interpretation would contradict the protection of preexisting customary rights in Article 2.

Mechanisms of Land Acquisition

  • Economics of Colonization:

    • Enforcing sovereignty requires land ownership. Ownership allows for law-making, taxation, and borrowing money.

    • For the first 15−2015-20 years, the Crown was relatively weak and poor, partly because settlers were a minority until the mid-1850s1850s.

  • New Zealand Settlement Act 1863:

    • Created by Sir George Grey.

    • Allowed the Governor to deem a district (e.g., Canterbury) as being in "rebellion."

    • Rebels' land was confiscated. Though the law allowed for compensation, the speaker is unaware of it ever being paid.

    • Effect: Explicitly extinguished customary or legal claims by Maori.

  • Native Lands Act 1865:

    • Established the Native Land Court.

    • Purpose: Transition land from customary title to Crown title.

    • The 10 Owners Rule: No more than 1010 individuals could be listed as owners on a block of land. This automatically alienated the remaining community members (sometimes 99.9%99.9{\%} of the actual traditional owners).

  • Exploitation in the Court:

    • Hearings were expensive; participants were charged just to state their name and claim.

    • Unpaid legal fees often resulted in the land being taken by the court.

    • Grievances and Service: A single disgruntled individual could initiate a hearing. Notice of hearings was often poor (e.g., nailing a notice to a tree rather than direct service), leading to "Uncle" scenarios where one person and nine friends could secure title without the rest of the family knowing.

South Island and Ngai Tahu Context

  • Land Buying Agents: Henry Tacey Kemp and Walter Mantel were key figures. Between 18441844 and 18641864, the Crown acquired 85%85{\%} of the South Island landmass.

  • Coercion and False Promises:

    • Musket Threats: The Crown threatened that if Ngai Tahu did not sell, the Crown would buy the land from their enemies (Ngati Toa).

    • Financial Failure: Land was sold on the promise of future installments that were never paid.

    • Reserve Promises: The Crown promised to set aside 10%10{\%} of land as reserves and build schools and hospitals. In reality, reserves were often less than 0.5%0.5{\%}, and the largest was only about 2%2{\%}.

  • South Island Landless Native Act 1906:

    • A gesture to address the lack of reserves.

    • Execution was flawed: land was often assigned in areas where people did not live.

    • Example: Perihira (Priscilla) from Christchurch was given land on Stewart Island. The land was so steep it was only suitable for "goats" and was never legally vested in her because the government failed to follow through.

Questions & Discussion

  • Question regarding "Right of First Refusal":

    • Response: The speaker clarifies that the Right of Preemption is distinct from a modern Right of First Refusal. Under the Treaty's preemption, the Crown was the only entity that could buy land, effectively making the land "Crown land" once purchased from Maori.

  • Exam Information:

    • The speaker's section is worth 2525 marks.

    • The exam will consist of 22 or 33 questions, involving at least one problem question (applying the Maori Land Act and case law) and one essay question. Students may only have to complete one, depending on final question size.

  • Logistics: The lecturer will be in court next Thursday at 9:00AM9:00 AM for a case involving the Foreshore and Seabed and may be slightly late to class.