You Just Don't Understand: Women and Men in Conversation
Social Interaction in Everyday Life: Men and Women in Conversation
The Communication Paradox: Public vs. Private Speaking
Initial Observation: A man attending a women's group discussion dominated the conversation with lengthy comments. Yet, when the observation was made that women often complain their husbands don't talk enough, he claimed his wife was "the talker in our family," stating he usually has "nothing to say" at home.
Similar Paradox: Another woman described her husband as "the life of the party" when out, but quiet at home.
This highlights a foundational paradox: societal stereotypes about who talks more often contradict real-life observations, especially when differentiating between public and private settings.
Stereotypes, Reality, and Historical Context of Women's Talk
Societal Stereotype: The common stereotype is that women talk too much.
Proverbs cited by Jennifer Coates:
"A woman's tongue wags like a lamb's tail."
"Foxes are all tail and women are all tongue."
"The North Sea will sooner be found wanting in water than a woman be at a loss for a word."
Historical Punishments (Colonial America, per Connie Eble): Women talking "too much" or "in the wrong way" faced physical punishments like ducking stools, stocks with shaming signs, gagging, and silence enforced by a cleft stick applied to the tongue.
Modern Stereotypes: Though institutionalized corporal punishments are gone, modern stereotypes remain similar, often manifesting as informal, psychological pressures.
Empirical Reality (Research Findings): Contrary to popular belief, studies consistently show that men talk more in various public and mixed-gender settings.
University Faculty Meetings (Barbara and Gene Eakins):
Tape-recorded and studied seven university faculty meetings.
Men spoke more often and for longer periods without exception for duration.
Men's turns ranged from to seconds.
Women's turns ranged from to seconds.
Significantly, women's longest turns were still shorter than men's shortest turns.
Public Lectures and Talk Shows:
When a public lecture allows questions or a talk show opens phone lines, the first voice heard is almost always a man's.
Men tend to talk longer when asking questions or offering comments.
Academic Conferences (Marjorie Swacker):
Women were highly visible as speakers, presenting percent of papers and comprising percent of audiences.
However, women contributed only percent of the questions asked.
The average duration of women's questions was seconds, less than half of men's at seconds.
This discrepancy is attributed to men prefacing questions with statements, asking multiple questions, and following up answers.
Author's Own Lectures: Deborah Tannen observed this pattern herself, even in lectures on topics directly relevant to women. Men almost invariably ask the first, more numerous, and longer questions, leading women to perceive men as talking too much.
Rapport-Talk and Report-Talk: Core Distinctions
Reconciling Contradictions: The seemingly contradictory evidence about who talks more is reconciled by distinguishing between "public speaking" and "private speaking," and more specifically, "report-talk" and "rapport-talk."
Public vs. Private Speaking:
More men feel comfortable with "public speaking."
More women feel comfortable with "private speaking."
Rapport-Talk (Predominantly Women's Style):
Purpose: Primarily a language of conversation aimed at establishing connections and negotiating relationships.
Characteristics: Emphasizes displaying similarities and matching experiences.
Development: From childhood, girls are socialized to criticize peers who try to stand out or appear superior.
Context: Closest connections are felt at home or in similar intimate settings with one or a few close, comfortable individuals (private speaking).
Adaptability: Even public situations can be approached with a rapport-talk orientation.
Report-Talk (Predominantly Men's Style):
Purpose: Primarily a means to preserve independence and negotiate/maintain status within a hierarchical social order.
Characteristics: Achieved by exhibiting knowledge and skill, and by holding center stage through verbal performances like storytelling, joking, or imparting information.
Development: From childhood, boys learn to use talking as a way to gain and hold attention.
Context: More comfortable speaking in larger groups of less familiar people (broadly, public speaking).
Adaptability: Even private situations can be approached with a report-talk orientation, more like giving a report than establishing rapport.
Private Speaking: The Wordy Woman and the Mute Man
Source of the "Women Talk a Lot" Stereotype:
Dale Spender's View: Many people instinctively believe women, like children, should be seen, not heard, making any amount of talk from them seem excessive. Studies support this, showing that if women and men talk equally in a group, people perceive women as having talked more.
Tannen's Explanation: Men perceive women as talking a lot because they hear women talking in situations where men typically do not: on the telephone, in social settings discussing topics men don't find inherently interesting, or alone at home (i.e., in private speaking).
The "American Icon" of Home Life: This cultural image features a silent man and a talkative woman, stemming from their differing conversational goals and habits.
Women's Most Frequent Complaints:
"He doesn't talk to me."
"He doesn't listen to me."
Ann Landers Letter Example: A woman frustrated that her husband is silent at home ("Rough," "It's a jungle out there") but becomes "the gabbiest guy in the crowd" and a "spellbinder" when guests are present or they are visiting others. This pattern persisted for years.
Misconception: Ann Landers suggested the husband might be tired. Tannen counters that working women also come home tired but are still eager to share daily events and feelings.
Widespread Observation: Studies, advice columns, and media (movies, plays) confirm the disappointment women feel regarding men's silence at home. The common sentiment is, "He seems to have everything to say to everyone else, and nothing to say to me."
Film Example (Divorce American Style): A scene where Debbie Reynolds' character claims a lack of communication while Dick Van Dyke's character protests he tells her everything. Both feel wronged by the other's perception.
The Root of the Problem: People often blame individuals, groups, or the relationship for communication breakdowns. However, the true problem lies in differing conversational styles. Attempting to solve the problem through more talk can worsen it if the different ways of talking are the initial cause.
**