Rachels Ch. 9-10
Kant - Categorical Imperative
Humans are rational and autonomous
Human beings and their desires are the most important thing
Categorical imperative - something you MUST follow out of moral obligation; moral law is binding
Crash Course on Kantism
Thought religion and morality should be kept apart by using reason
Look to religion for morality = open to interpretation/variable
Thought morals were a constant
Hypothetical imperatives - about prudence, not morality
e.g. study for a test to get an A
Categorical imperatives - commands you must follow, regardless of desires; derived from pure reason
Understood via formulations
Universalizability principle
General rule that stands behind particular actions
If you do it, everyone should do it
Contradiction: bad actions are not universalizable
A moral act should be universalized (everyone should do it all the time)
Because of one’s actions, something bad happened, so one is responsible
You should not use humans for mere means (humans are our own ends, humans exist for themselves)
We deserve not to be used for mere means
Absolute moral worth: we shouldn’t be manipulated or impeded to autonomously make decisions
Focus on intent
Humans should follow rationality
Utilitarianism - Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill
Act Utilitarianism - greatest good for greatest number of people
Rule Utilitarianism - we ought to live by rules that are likely to lead to ^
Refrain from behaving in situations that result in good for the short term, more so the majority of all time
Focus on result
Retributivists
Kant does not believe in rehabilitation
Punishment does not fix people