Rachels Ch. 9-10

Kant - Categorical Imperative

  • Humans are rational and autonomous

  • Human beings and their desires are the most important thing

  • Categorical imperative - something you MUST follow out of moral obligation; moral law is binding

Crash Course on Kantism

  • Thought religion and morality should be kept apart by using reason

  • Look to religion for morality = open to interpretation/variable

  • Thought morals were a constant

  • Hypothetical imperatives - about prudence, not morality

    • e.g. study for a test to get an A

  • Categorical imperatives - commands you must follow, regardless of desires; derived from pure reason

    • Understood via formulations

    • Universalizability principle

      • General rule that stands behind particular actions

      • If you do it, everyone should do it

      • Contradiction: bad actions are not universalizable

      • A moral act should be universalized (everyone should do it all the time)

      • Because of one’s actions, something bad happened, so one is responsible

    • You should not use humans for mere means (humans are our own ends, humans exist for themselves)

      • We deserve not to be used for mere means

      • Absolute moral worth: we shouldn’t be manipulated or impeded to autonomously make decisions

  • Focus on intent

  • Humans should follow rationality

Utilitarianism - Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill

  • Act Utilitarianism - greatest good for greatest number of people

  • Rule Utilitarianism - we ought to live by rules that are likely to lead to ^

    • Refrain from behaving in situations that result in good for the short term, more so the majority of all time

  • Focus on result

Retributivists

  • Kant does not believe in rehabilitation

    • Punishment does not fix people