Summary of Planter Aristocracy and Its Impact

The Planter "Aristocracy"

  • Pre-Civil War South characterized as an oligarchy, not a democracy.

  • Dominated by a planter aristocracy; 1,733 families owned over one hundred slaves each in 1850.

  • Plantation system produced significant political and social leaders; referred to as "cottonocracy."

  • Wealth concentrated among planter aristocrats leading to educational advantages for their children.

  • Prominent figures like John C. Calhoun and Jefferson Davis benefited from elite education.

  • Majority of front-rank statesmen before 1860 were from Virginia, viewed as more honorable compared to the "dollar-grubbing" North.

  • Aristocracy created a wider gap between rich and poor, undermining public education.

  • Southern elites admired Sir Walter Scott, seeking to emulate a feudal society despite their capitalistic activities.

  • Mark Twain criticized Scott for inspiring southerners to defend a failing social structure, labeling it as a "sham civilization."

The Cotton Empire

  • Plantation life influenced the roles and experiences of southern women.

  • Plantation mistresses managed large staffs of female slaves responsible for household chores.

  • Relationships between mistresses and slaves varied from close to abusive, with some slaves feeling pride in their roles as "members" of the household.