Review of Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover Era (1917-1929)

Overview of Post-World War I America

  • Time Period: 1917 - 1920

  • Context: Period marked by war, strikes, recession, and race riots

Warren G. Harding and Election of 1920

  • Senator Harding's Understanding of Public Sentiment: Recognized the public's desire for peace and tranquility.

  • May 1920 Speech: Harding spoke to a Boston audience, termed his style “bloviating.”

    • Quote: "America’s present need is not heroics, but healing; not nostrums, but normalcy… not experiment, but equipoise."

  • Penrose's Warning: Pennsylvania Senator Boies Penrose warned Republicans to keep Harding from making speeches;

    • Quote: "If he goes out on a tour, somebody’s sure to ask him questions, and Warren’s just the sort of … fool that’ll try to answer them.”

  • Nomination: Harding nominated as the Republican candidate later in 1920.

  • Campaigning Strategy: Campaigned from his porch, promising a return to “normalcy.”

  • Election Result: Won over 60% of the vote.

    • Concept of Normalcy: Focus on domestic prosperity over international affairs present during Wilson’s presidency.

  • Inaugural Address: First president utilizing amplification technology for his speech; emphasized the need for less government involvement in business.

  • Public Perception: Harding's approach was immediately understandable to the public.

Economic Policies of Warren G. Harding

Tax Cuts and Federal Spending Reduction
  • Background: Pre-politics, Harding owned a newspaper; his campaign manager Harry Daugherty stated, "He looks like a president."

  • Characterization: Known as a man of limited talents but popular due to his affable manner and commitment to free enterprise.

  • Free Enterprise: Economic system characterized by private ownership of property.

  • Fiscal Policy Initiatives:

    • Repealed wartime tax increases and cut federal spending.

    • Harding's budget director, Charles Dawes, increased efficiency, saving over a billion tax dollars annually from a budget totaling less than $5 billion.

    • Resulting surplus was allocated toward national debt.

    • Positive Economic Indicators: Prices dropped, and unemployment fell from nearly 12% to just above 2% by 1923.

Teapot Dome Scandal
  • Friendship & Trust: Harding appointed friends to significant government posts; known as the "Ohio Gang."

  • Corruption:

    • Harry Daugherty accepted bribes; Albert Fall leased oil reserves unlawfully, bribed with $360,000.

  • Fall's Resignation: Came after the scandal became public, leading to widespread distrust in national governance.

  • Harding's Defense: Stated, "If Albert Fall isn't an honest man, I am not fit to be president of the United States."

Calvin Coolidge’s Presidency (1923 - 1929)

Ascension
  • Oath of Office: Coolidge was sworn in on August 3, 1923, at his family's Vermont farm.

  • Personality: Known as "Silent Cal," reflecting New England’s values of integrity and hard work.

  • Business Philosophy: Believed in promoting business as a worthy calling.

    • Key Quote: “The man who builds a factory builds a temple.”

  • Electoral Victory: Coolidge won the 1924 election easily, endorsed business-friendly policies.

Economic Actions
  • Tax Reductions: Worked with Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon to cut various taxes.

    • Types of Taxes Cut: Corporate, income, inheritance.

  • Budget Cuts: Noted for slashing the White House budget and reducing operational costs.

  • Public Expectation: Many assumed Coolidge would run in 1928, but he surprised everyone by declining to seek reelection.

Herbert Hoover’s Presidency (1929 - 1933)

Background and Philosophy
  • Personal Background: Born in 1874 in Iowa, orphaned young, became a millionaire engineer.

  • Public Service: Known for his leadership role in World War I feeding programs and later appointed Secretary of Commerce by Harding.

  • Economic Philosophy: Promoted "associationalism"—collaboration among industry leaders to enhance efficiency.

  • Campaign Promise: "End Poverty as We Know It."

Economic Context
  • 1928 Presidential Campaign: Hoover declared a near end to poverty, leveraging past economic policies' successes.

  • Isolationist Attitudes: Despite wartime experiences, Hoover recognized the interdependence of international trade.

Foreign Policy Stance

Isolationism and Europe
  • Harding's Statement: "We seek no part in directing the destinies of the Old World."

  • League of Nations: Despite previous support, Harding’s administration ignored the League, and mail remained unopened.

  • World Court Participation: Supported U.S. membership to try to resolve international disputes; however, U.S. membership was complicated by Senate reservations.

Naval Disarmament and Treaties
  • Washington Naval Conference (1921): Harding proposed scrapping U.S. warships, leading to agreements on reducing naval capacities with other countries.

  • Kellogg-Briand Pact (1928): Aimed to outlaw war, signed by 62 nations. However, allowed for defensive wars, leading to skepticism.

Economic Expansion of the 1920s

The Dawes Plan
  • Addressing War Debts: Created a circular loan process where the U.S. loans money to Germany, enabling reparations to be paid to Great Britain and France, subsequently repaying U.S. loans.

Domestic Policies
  • Latin America: Troop reductions in countries like Nicaragua and the Dominican Republic; Hoover emphasized nonintervention.

Economic Growth Indicators
  • GNP Growth: Between 1921 - 1929, the GNP rose by 40%.

  • Manufacturing Output: By 1929, the U.S. produced 40% of global manufactured goods.

Transformation of Industries
  • Automobile Industry: Mass production revolutionized, significantly lowering costs and prices; Henry Ford’s innovative model cut production times and raised worker wages.

  • Airplane Industry: Flourished post-WWI with construction and commercial prospects expanding.

  • New Products: Plastics and synthetics transformed various industries; radio production exploded, reaching high sales figures.

Business Consolidation
  • Increased Size and Efficiency: Antitrust laws were largely ignored during the Republican Era; businesses grew significantly.

  • Key Companies: By 1929, Ford, General Motors, and Chrysler controlled 90% of the auto market.

  • Community Impact: Consolidation led to declines in small businesses, leading to an anti-chain store movement.

Speculative Ventures
  • Ponzi Schemes and Florida Land Boom: Many Americans fell victim to risky investments and speculative schemes seeking quick profits.

  • Stock Market Influence: Ownership shifted to the middle class; stock market participation increased significantly, raising stock values drastically.

Unequal Prosperity
  • Economic Disparities: While the economy boomed, many groups, particularly farmers and marginalized ethnic groups, struggled, reflecting systemic inequality in prosperity distribution.

  • Labor Conditions: Unskilled laborers were exploited, with job loss and wage discrimination prevalent.