CI Week 2 - Investigative Notes, Crime Scene Photography, and Scene Sketching

Overview and Objectives of Criminal Investigation Documentation

  • Scope and Coverage:

    • Covers key foundational concepts regarding investigative note-taking, crime scene photography, video documentation, and scene sketching.

    • Encompasses approximately 40 to 42 core slides detailing criminal investigation methodologies.

  • Core Learning Objectives:

    • Explain why investigative notes are a crucial component of a criminal investigation.

    • Identify the specific characteristics that define effective investigative notes.

    • Summarize the primary purposes served by crime scene photography.

    • Describe the minimum photographic equipment investigators should possess and be capable of operating.

    • Understand what items and areas must be photographed at a crime scene and the precise sequence in which photos should be taken.

    • Identify various specialized types of photography utilized within criminal investigations.

    • Explain the specific legal criteria photographs must satisfy to be admissible in a court of law.

    • List the sequential steps involved in creating a rough crime scene sketch.

    • Describe the legal and practical requirements for a sketch or scale drawing to be admissible in court.

Principles and Characteristics of Investigative Notes

  • Definition and Core Purpose:

    • Investigative notes are a permanent written record of the facts of a case, maintained to further the investigation, assist in writing formal reports, and aid in case prosecution.

    • Notes provide an accurate timeline of actions taken and observations made, saving substantial time during formal report preparation by eliminating reliance on pure memory recall.

    • Notes serve as a critical reference tool to refresh memory and aid in accurate recall when an investigator testifies under oath in court.

  • Retention and File Management Rules:

    • Notes must never be thrown away or discarded once created.

    • Every original note, notebook page, or recorded document must become an official part of the permanent case file.

    • Discarding or losing notes severely undermines officer credibility in legal proceedings if defense counsel requests original notes and they cannot be produced.

  • Essential Characteristics of Effective Notes:

    • Complete: Captures all necessary, pertinent facts without leaving crucial gaps.

    • Factual: Contains exclusively truthful information; untruthful or speculative statements must never be recorded.

    • Accurate: Precise in every recorded detail.

    • Specific: Detailed enough to satisfy its intended investigative and legal purpose.

    • Legible and Clear: Readable by the investigator and others who may review the case file.

    • Chronological Order: Documented in the exact sequential order in which events, interviews, or observations occurred.

    • Well-Organized: Contains appropriate detail with explicit contextual indicators (e.g., explicitly labeling entries like "phone call out to [Name] on [Date]" or "phone call in from [Name]" using directional arrows).

Modern Note-Taking Methods and Best Practices

  • Timing of Note-Taking:

    • Record information immediately whenever possible while actively performing investigative tasks.

    • Exercise operational discretion to temporarily delay writing notes when safety or circumstances demand it (e.g., while actively driving or handling a volatile situation).

  • Content Requirements:

    • Must capture standard investigative elements: who, what, when, where, why, and how.

    • Focus on selecting key facts and pertinent information to keep notes functional and useful.

    • Standardized abbreviations are acceptable, provided the overall document remains coherent and organized.

  • Organizational Strategies and Separation Rules:

    • Case Separation Rule: Never combine or record notes from two separate cases, or notes from interviews with two different individuals, on the exact same sheet of paper.

    • Notebook System: Carrying a small, wallet-sized pocket notebook in a front pocket allows immediate documentation. Start a new page for each distinct case with the case number and brief description. Storing filled notebooks systematically in a desk ensures long-term preservation.

    • Complex Investigations: Utilizing legal pads to maintain running records during complex cases helps track multiple interview reports and serves as a visual reminder to complete formal police reports.

  • Impact of Digital Recordings on Written Notes:

    • Modern technology (body-worn cameras, squad car video, and digital audio recorders) provides extensive recorded evidence to verify events and details.

    • While digital media complements written documentation, written notes retain value for quick reference (e.g., verifying exact start times without scrubbing through hours of video footage).

    • Audio Recording Alternative: Investigators may choose to replace handwritten notes during interviews by dictating all administrative context (case number, date, time, physical location, and present parties) directly into the start of an audio recording. If no written notes are created during the process, no physical notes exist to be requested or questioned in court. There is no legal requirement mandating that written notes must be taken.

Functions, Advantages, and Disadvantages of Crime Scene Photography and Video

  • Primary Function:

    • Photographs and video recordings reproduce the crime scene in detail, serving as the definitive method to visually communicate and retell the physical story of the scene to prosecutors, defense attorneys, witnesses, judges, and juries.

    • Because a physical crime scene cannot be packaged and brought into a courtroom, photography captures the environment before scene processing alters it.

  • Advantages of Scene Photography:

    • Photos can be captured immediately upon arrival by initial responding officers, securing pristine scene conditions before medical personnel or additional responders enter.

    • Accurately depicts overall conditions and spatial relationships.

    • Digital images are easily stored, permanently archived, simple to reproduce, and resistant to loss when properly backed up.

  • Disadvantages of Scene Photography:

    • Extreme detail in photographs may distract reviewers with non-essential background elements.

    • Small nuances or discrete physical evidence can easily be missed or lost in wide photos.

    • Two-dimensional photographic prints obscure true three-dimensional depth and spatial distances.

  • Video Documentation Capabilities and Drawbacks:

    • Advantages: Provides multi-dimensional spatial representation, making relative distances easier to perceive; captures integrated audio alongside visual motion (e.g., body-worn or squad car video systems).

    • Disadvantages: Susceptible to shaky camera movement, poor focus, over-zooming (which destroys contextual awareness), and unintentional audio capture of off-hand remarks made by officers.

Photographic Equipment, Terminology, and Policy Considerations

  • Camera Equipment Types:

    • Digital Point-and-Shoot Cameras: Simple operation, standard shutter controls, basic zoom, and minimal manual adjustments.

    • DSLR (Digital Single-Lens Reflex) Cameras: Advanced control capabilities suited for complex conditions; features long-exposure settings for night photography, tripod compatibility for wide-angle perspectives, and high-resolution optical magnification for detail analysis (e.g., latent fingerprint capture).

    • Cell Phone Cameras (e.g., Smartphones):

    • Extremely portable and accessible.

    • Subject to image-processing algorithms that automatically prioritize facial features while smoothing out fine background details, creating limitations for forensic applications.

    • Video Recording Devices: Body-worn cameras, squad car cameras, and specialized high-definition video tools for complete scene walkthroughs.

  • Selection Factors and Department Policy:

    • Equipment selection is governed by investigator skill, available time, departmental budgets, local requirements, and personal preference.

    • Departments must establish clear written policies governing digital media management, specifying whether photos are archived on secure server drives, written to optical storage discs (CD/DVD), or preserved through redundant dual-storage protocols.

  • Essential Digital Photography Terminology:

    • Resolution: The overall clarity and detail contained within an image.

    • Pixel: The smallest individual picture element composing a digital image.

    • Megapixels: One million pixels; a measure of image sensor resolution.

    • Pixels Per Inch (PPI): A measurement of pixel density in digital displays and prints.

Crime Scene Photography Sequence and Methodologies

  • Core Methodological Principle:

    • Plan all photographic sequences to minimize physical disturbance to the scene, utilizing systematic overlapping shots to achieve full coverage.

  • Three-Step Photographic Sequence:

    1. Long-Range / Overall Photographs:

    • Captured first upon entering the scene.

    • Documents the broad environment, locality, and overall structure prior to any alteration.

    • Taken from top-to-bottom and left-to-right (mirroring the reading of a book).

    • Standard procedure: Stand in corners (e.g., opposite corners of a room like Benson Hall, Room 312) and take 4 to 6 wide-angle photos per perspective to document the general setting without focusing on specific targets.

    1. Medium-Range Photographs:

    • Focuses on specific areas of interest within the broader scene.

    • Establishes the exact spatial relationship between specific items of evidence and the surrounding environment (e.g., capturing a diploma frame mounted on a specific wall).

    1. Close-Range / Close-Up Photographs:

    • Documents specific physical evidence in high detail before item removal or processing (e.g., detailed ridge structure of a latent fingerprint on the glass of a diploma frame).

    • Connecting overall, medium, and close-range photos establishes a clear, unbroken visual trail linking microscopic evidence directly to its exact location in the scene.

  • Common Photography Errors and Mitigation:

    • Overconfidence: Assuming modern cameras are entirely automated; failure to practice with equipment leads to severe errors in non-controlled outdoor environments (e.g., heavy rain, snow, or pitch darkness).

    • Perspective Distortion: Failing to capture objects at eye level or failing to show items in proper relative size and physical position.

    • Lack of Systematics: Disorganized shooting patterns reduce photographic utility. Utilizing a standardized checklist ensures no critical areas (e.g., individual bedrooms or entry points) are omitted.

Special Photography Applications and Legal Admissibility Rules

  • Specialized Investigative Applications:

    • Surveillance Photography: Captures subject interactions, tracks movements, and establishes criminal association from a distance.

    • Aerial Photography: Documents large-scale outdoor scenes from aircraft (e.g., National Guard or Border Patrol flights) using specialized gyroscopic stabilization lenses to counteract aircraft vibration.

    • Night Photography: Utilizes specialized flash techniques or long-exposure settings to render dark environments fully visible.

    • Digital Enhancement (Photoshop):

    • Permitted solely for legitimate image enhancement, such as brightening dark scenes, removing heavy shadows, or adjusting contrast.

    • Strict Prohibition: Digital alteration or manipulation of evidence (e.g., digitally adding non-existent contraband into a photo) is illegal and completely unacceptable.

    • Person Photography: Documenting individuals involved in critical incidents (e.g., in officer-involved shootings, photographing officers top-to-bottom, front, sides, back, along with full duty equipment and weapons).

    • Photo Lineups: Used for witness identification procedures.

  • Legal Criteria for Admissibility in Court:

    • Materiality and Relevancy: Photos must directly relate to the case facts and satisfy standard evidentiary rules of relevance.

    • Competency: Photos must accurately represent what they purport to depict.

    • Authentication Rule: A photograph must be authenticated by a witness with personal knowledge of the scene who testifies under oath that the image is a "true and accurate depiction" of what was observed. The photographer is not legally required to authenticate the photo; any qualified witness with direct scene knowledge can provide authentication.

    • File Integrity and Chain of Custody:

    • Original, unedited image files must be preserved in the case file.

    • Maintain sequential digital file numbers (e.g., DSC_001, DSC_002, DSC_003). Never delete bad or accidental photographs (e.g., an accidental shot of an investigator's feet). Gaps in sequential numbering allow defense counsel to claim that missing files contained exculpatory evidence. Retain accidental shots in the file sequence and explain their nature in testimony.

Crime Scene Sketches, Plotting Techniques, and Legal Standards

  • Role of Manual Sketches in Modern Practice:

    • Advanced 3D scanning, laser measurement tools, and digital mapping technology have largely reduced reliance on hand-drawn sketches, though basic sketching remains a foundational skill.

  • Rough Sketch Rules and Steps:

    • Retention Rule: Original rough sketches must never be thrown away or destroyed; they are official case records.

    • Five Steps in Making a Rough Sketch:

    1. Observing and measuring the physical boundaries and item locations.

    2. Plotting exact distances.

    3. Recording detailed notes and observations directly on or alongside the sketch.

    4. Identifying the specific scene details (case number, location, date, time, creator).

    5. Reassessing and cross-checking the completed sketch against the actual physical scene.

  • Object Plotting Techniques:

    • Object plotting relies on foundational geometric principles using coordinate systems.

    • Measurements fix evidence positions along perpendicular horizontal XX and vertical YY axes relative to fixed, immovable baseline points within the scene.

  • Legal Admissibility Requirements for Sketches:

    • To be admissible in court, a rough sketch or finished scale drawing must be drawn or personally witnessed by an investigator.

    • Must be authenticated in court through testimony confirming that it accurately and truly portrays the physical scene.