Week 6: Block 2 Intro and External analysis - the macro environment

Block 2 External and internal analysis

Overview

Strategic analysis examines the relationship between an organisation and the conditions in which it operates. External analysis considers wider environmental forces and industry competition. Internal analysis examines the organisation’s resources, competences and capabilities, including how its activities combine to create value.

These perspectives must be connected. An external opportunity is useful only if an organisation can develop or obtain the capabilities needed to exploit it. Equally, existing capabilities may lose value when technology, regulation or customer expectations change. Strategic analysis therefore helps managers understand their organisation’s position and assess feasible strategic choices.

Structure of Block 2

Week 6 examines the macro environment. Weeks 7 and 8 analyse industries and competitive forces. Weeks 9 and 10 identify and assess resources and capabilities. Week 11 connects capabilities and organisational activities to strategy, including how activities form a value chain that delivers products and services.

Week 6 External analysis: the macro environment

1 What is the external environment?

The external environment comprises factors outside an organisation that may influence its strategy, operations and performance. Strategic analysis distinguishes three levels.

The macro environment consists of broad developments such as economic conditions, technological innovation and political change. These may affect several industries, although their consequences vary between organisations.

The meso environment is the industry-level environment. It includes competitors, suppliers and other actors whose relationships shape competition within an industry.

The organisational level concerns internal characteristics, including resources, capabilities and processes. It is not part of the external environment, but must be analysed alongside it.

These levels distinguish connected influences. Broadband adoption is a macro technological development; competition between streaming services occurs at the industry level; and a company’s ability to develop a streaming platform concerns its internal capabilities. Separating the levels makes analysis more systematic without implying that they operate independently.

1.1 Why is it important to study the external environment?

A strategy depends on the conditions in which it operates. Environmental change can alter demand, costs, competitive relationships and the viability of a business model. A previously successful strategy may therefore become inappropriate.

The Blockbuster and Netflix example illustrates this. Physical video rental became less attractive as technology and alternative services developed. Netflix also faced the declining relevance of its original DVD delivery model, but adapted towards streaming and original content. The strategic issue was both recognising environmental change and developing an effective response.

Anticipation can be more effective than reacting after conditions deteriorate. A retailer expecting weaker consumer spending can reduce stock purchases before unsold inventory accumulates. External analysis therefore informs immediate operational decisions as well as long-term direction.

Competitive relationships also require interpretation. Rival supermarkets compete for customers, whereas better applications and games can increase demand for smartphones. These are complements, products or services that increase the usefulness or attractiveness of another offering. Competition among complement providers can benefit the organisation whose products they support.

A complete strategic analysis connects macro developments, industry relationships and internal capabilities. It helps explain the organisation’s position relative to competitors and identifies opportunities and threats requiring attention.

1.2 Trends in the macro environment

A trend is a developing pattern of change rather than an isolated event. Macro trends extend beyond one organisation, but their strategic importance depends on the organisation’s activities and customers.

The Starling Bank interviews identify three connected trends. Social media encourages expectations of immediate information and responses. Smartphones enable access to services across locations and times. Consumers increasingly expect choice and control over the providers they use.

Starling’s real-time balances, transaction notifications and continuous customer support respond to these developments. Immediate information also helps customers monitor spending, connecting convenience with a practical financial benefit.

Greater consumer choice supports the unbundling of financial services, where customers obtain different products from different providers. This challenges the traditional model in which a current account attracts customers who are subsequently sold loans, mortgages and other services. Starling’s stated response in the interviews is to concentrate on its current account while allowing access to complementary offerings.

Distinguish the external trend from the organisational response. Widespread smartphone use is a macro development; providing mobile banking is a strategic choice made in response.

2 The STEEPLE framework

STEEPLE groups macro-environmental influences into seven categories. It provides a systematic way to identify developments outside an organisation’s immediate control and assess their implications. Related versions include PEST, STEP and PESTLE, but STEEPLE explicitly includes ethical factors.

S – sociological factors

Sociological factors concern population characteristics, lifestyles and social values. They include age profiles, ethnic diversity, health consciousness and expectations about convenience, ownership and service.

Growing interest in healthy and organic food can influence agriculture, manufacturing and retailing. In banking, expectations of immediate access and greater choice affect service design. In transport, commuting patterns and attitudes towards ownership influence demand for private vehicles and shared mobility.

T – technological factors

Technological factors include innovation, technological change, awareness and adoption. They extend beyond information technology to scientific advances, production methods and new ways of conducting business.

Artificial intelligence, robotics and autonomous vehicles can change how work is performed and what organisations offer. Analysis must consider the pace of change because products and capabilities may become less valuable as alternatives emerge.

E – economic factors

Economic factors include economic growth, exchange rates, interest rates, disposable income and unemployment. They affect demand, financing costs and the costs of labour, materials and other inputs.

Exchange-rate movements can change export competitiveness and import costs. Their consequences depend on where revenue is earned and costs are incurred, so the same movement can benefit one organisation and disadvantage another.

E – environmental factors

Environmental factors concern the natural environment, including resource shortages, pollution, natural disasters and pressure to improve environmental performance. They also encompass sustainability policies and standards.

Concern about plastic pollution, for example, affects packaging decisions and expectations of producers and retailers. Environmental pressures can increase costs or threaten supply while encouraging innovation.

P – political factors

Political factors concern government priorities, political stability, taxation policy, trade relationships, corruption and opportunities to influence policymaking.

Government support for particular technologies or restrictions on market access can create opportunities and threats. Lobbying demonstrates that organisations may seek to shape policy rather than merely respond to it.

L – legal factors

Legal factors concern specific laws and enforceable requirements affecting an organisation. Relevant areas include employment, intellectual property, taxation and international trade.

Intellectual property protection influences whether organisations can retain the benefits of innovation. Differences between legal systems therefore matter when selecting markets, partners and investment locations.

Political and legal factors overlap. Political analysis examines policy direction and decision-making, while legal analysis examines the requirements and protections that result.

E – ethical factors

Ethical factors concern expectations of fairness, responsibility, accountability and appropriate treatment of stakeholders. These expectations may extend beyond legal requirements.

Customer data illustrates this distinction. Organisations face expectations of transparency, appropriate use and protection against misuse. Ethical failures can undermine trust even where the issue cannot be reduced to legal compliance alone.

Relationships among the STEEPLE factors

The categories are connected rather than independent. Smartphone technology supports immediate communication, while changing social expectations encourage faster service. Environmental concerns can influence political priorities, generate legislation and stimulate technological investment.

An issue may therefore fit several categories. The analytical purpose is to explain influences and consequences, rather than force each development into one exclusive category.

2.1 Performing a STEEPLE analysis

STEEPLE develops from environmental-scanning approaches associated with Aguilar and Fahey and Narayanan. Its application follows five connected stages.

First, define the macro environment of interest by specifying the business, industry and geographical context. A diversified organisation may need separate analyses for different activities because the relevant influences differ.

Second, scan for ongoing and emerging change. Search broadly for developments that could affect the chosen context.

Third, monitor particular trends and patterns. Following developments over time helps distinguish sustained changes from isolated events.

Fourth, forecast possible future directions. Assess how developments might evolve while recognising that forecasts depend on assumptions.

Fifth, assess strategic implications. Explain how changes could affect demand, costs, resources, operations and competitive position.

The analysis should then inform strategic choice. Identifying a trend is insufficient unless its significance and possible consequences are explained.

The automotive teaching example shows how evidence can be organised across the seven categories. Its findings represent the historical report’s scenarios and expectations rather than current forecasts.

Sociological influences include more frequent and longer commutes, interest in environmentally preferable transport, and growing acceptance of car sharing and transport applications. These developments can change how people access mobility and whether they value ownership.

Technological influences include electric propulsion, artificial intelligence and vehicle connectivity. Car2Car communication enables vehicles to exchange information, while Car2X communication connects vehicles with wider systems, such as infrastructure. Together, these developments support connected and autonomous mobility.

Economic influences include differences between demand for private vehicles in rural areas and shared vehicles in urban areas. The teaching slide anticipates reductions in vehicle inventories in Europe and the United States, with an initial increase followed by a reduction in China. It also identifies potential growth in sales associated with shared and autonomous vehicles. These claims concern different measures: the stock of vehicles in use is distinct from the flow of new vehicle sales, so their relationship requires examination.

Environmental influences include pressure to reduce transport emissions and the potential contribution of electrification. Environmental benefits must be assessed rather than assumed solely from a change in technology.

Political influences include support for electric vehicles and car sharing, alongside policies controlling vehicle sales to manage congestion. Legal influences include gaps in legislation governing autonomous vehicles, which can slow adoption. Ethical influences concern the consequences and responsibilities associated with autonomous systems, including how safety decisions affect different people.

A note on using reports

Reports contain secondary data, information originally collected for purposes other than the present analysis. Their professional presentation does not guarantee that they provide an adequate basis for strategic decisions.

Assess relevance to the organisation, industry and geographical setting. Assess sufficiency, since one report may omit important factors. Assess recency, because conditions may have changed since publication.

Also assess accuracy and perspective. Authors may rely on incomplete evidence, overlook emerging developments or reflect organisational interests. A scenario explores what could happen under particular assumptions; it does not establish what will happen.

A good analysis separates reported evidence, forecasts and the analyst’s interpretation. Where evidence is missing, identify the limitation rather than inventing information to fill every category.

2.2 Reflecting on the STEEPLE factors

Macro-environmental factors form a changing network of influences. Environmental concerns may encourage emissions regulation, stimulating investment in electric vehicles. Technological improvements may then affect costs and customer acceptance, further changing demand.

Relationships can also constrain change. Shared mobility may be technically feasible but less attractive where journeys are dispersed, public infrastructure is limited or customers strongly value ownership. Technological availability does not guarantee uniform adoption.

The direction of influence may be difficult to isolate. Social demand can encourage innovation, while innovation changes expectations and behaviour. Analysis should therefore explain how factors reinforce or counteract one another.

What are the challenges of applying the STEEPLE framework?

STEEPLE can generate more information than can be communicated clearly. Seven categories, multiple trends and connections between them require selection and prioritisation.

The framework does not indicate which factors matter most. Their significance depends on the organisation and context, so importance must be justified rather than inferred from the number of examples listed.

STEEPLE also tends to present a snapshot. Conditions and relationships continue changing, requiring monitoring and revision. The supplied slide format helps organise evidence but cannot by itself explain every interaction.

An effective presentation identifies the most consequential developments and their implications. Completing every box is less important than producing a relevant, supported analysis.

3 The VUCA framework

VUCA distinguishes four challenges in the macro environment: volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity. The term originated in military thinking and was subsequently applied to strategic management.

STEEPLE identifies the types of external influence. VUCA examines the nature of the challenge they create and suggests possible responses. The same technological development could involve fluctuating conditions, information gaps, difficult interdependencies or unclear cause-and-effect relationships.

Following Bennett and Lemoine, the principal responses are agility, information, restructuring and experimentation. Their usefulness depends on correctly identifying the problem; they are not interchangeable solutions.

3.1 Volatility

Volatility involves frequent, unpredictable change in a situation whose basic characteristics are understood. Managers may understand the market but be unable to predict the timing or magnitude of fluctuations.

Commodity prices illustrate volatility. Weather, exchange rates and market conditions can produce rapid changes in fuel, agricultural or component prices.

The suggested response is agility, the ability to respond quickly. This may require resource slack, resources held available for use when conditions change, together with arrangements enabling rapid access to them.

Stockpiling important inputs when prices are favourable can reduce exposure to later increases. Long-term contracts can stabilise supply costs, while flexible production allows output to adjust to demand. These responses involve costs and commitments, so protection must be balanced against the resources required.

3.2 Uncertainty

Uncertainty arises when cause-and-effect relationships are broadly understood but knowledge about an event’s occurrence, scale or implications is insufficient.

A political change or health crisis may be expected to disrupt activity, but its effect on demand, investment or supply may remain unclear. The problem is insufficient knowledge about the consequences.

The response is to obtain and interpret information, data organised so that it helps explain a situation. More data is useful only if it reduces relevant gaps in understanding.

Universities considering overseas campuses illustrate this approach. Due diligence, systematic investigation of circumstances and risks, can examine political conditions, site safety and potential student demand before major commitments are made.

Information quality matters. An infodemic involves the harmful spread of false information, making it harder to interpret events and anticipate behaviour. Reliable sources and critical assessment are therefore necessary parts of the response.

3.3 Complexity

Complexity arises from numerous interconnected elements, rules and relationships. Information may be available, but interpreting and coordinating it is difficult.

Complexity does not require rapid change. A relatively stable environment can involve extensive legislation, accreditation requirements and interdependent institutions.

Foreign-market entry illustrates this challenge. Organisations must understand formal institutions, such as laws and regulations, alongside informal institutions, such as social norms and business relationships.

The suggested response is restructuring, changing organisational arrangements and processes to manage these interdependencies. This can involve specialist teams, local expertise, partnerships or joint ventures.

The material’s historical examples of foreign automotive firms partnering with Chinese businesses show how organisational arrangements can provide local knowledge and help manage institutional requirements. Their regulatory context should not be treated as a permanent rule applying to all periods.

3.4 Ambiguity

Ambiguity concerns situations where the rules and cause-and-effect relationships are unclear. There may be little precedent for predicting outcomes or identifying a successful approach.

This differs from uncertainty. Under uncertainty, managers broadly understand the relationship but lack information about its consequences. Under ambiguity, the relationship itself is insufficiently understood.

Starship Technologies’ robotic delivery service illustrates ambiguity. A new delivery method raises questions about customer acceptance, interactions with pedestrians, competitor behaviour and the future organisation of the market.

The suggested response is experimentation. Organisations test ideas, observe outcomes, refine approaches and discontinue ineffective options. This creates knowledge that may not be available from existing research.

A pilot allows learning before full implementation. Its purpose is to discover which arrangements work, for whom and under what conditions, rather than simply demonstrate that a technology functions.

3.5 Responding to the VUCA challenges

Each response addresses a different problem. Agility helps organisations cope with fluctuations. Information reduces relevant gaps in knowledge. Restructuring helps manage interdependencies. Experimentation clarifies unfamiliar relationships.

The activity examples make these distinctions concrete. Unpredictable microchip prices create volatility, suggesting stock buffers or long-term contracts. A consulting company entering Mumbai faces complexity in local rules and relationships, suggesting dedicated staff and structured collaboration with local partners.

A cashmere buyer considering suppliers in Kashmir faces uncertainty about the effects of political instability and earthquakes. Research into infrastructure, experienced suppliers and local advice can improve preparation.

An animal rescue organisation considering unfamiliar cloud systems faces ambiguity about how they will support its work. A pilot in one shelter can reveal necessary changes to training and processes before wider adoption.

The VUCA templates separate challenges from responses. A strong analysis states the specific difficulty, explains why it fits a category and identifies how the proposed response addresses it. Merely labelling an issue “uncertain” or recommending “flexibility” provides little analytical value.

3.6 VUCA challenges and possible responses for car makers

Volatility affects component prices, labour costs and vehicle sales. Changing preferences and greater use of shared vehicles may alter demand. Long-term supplier contracts can stabilise input costs, while adaptable production allows manufacturers to change output volumes. Stocks of critical components and protection against price fluctuations can provide additional resilience.

The shared-mobility scenario in the video illustrates how more intensive vehicle use could reduce the total fleet needed to support travel. It is an extreme scenario used to explore consequences, not a prediction that the existing fleet will necessarily fall to the stated level.

Uncertainty concerns the development of rules for autonomous vehicles and shared mobility. Regulators in Europe, the United States and China may adopt different requirements, affecting market opportunities. Manufacturers can monitor policy proposals and preparatory documents, while lobbying may provide some influence over decisions.

Complexity increases as vehicles integrate technologies from multiple providers. Autonomous driving combines sensors, communication systems and artificial intelligence, while connected services introduce further dependencies. Collaboration with specialist technology firms can provide capabilities that manufacturers lack. Relocating engineers and designers to work alongside partners illustrates restructuring to support coordination.

Ambiguity concerns how electrification and autonomous driving will develop into viable market offerings. Different combinations of technology, regulation and customer behaviour may produce different outcomes. Experimental programmes can test innovations and stakeholder reactions, helping manufacturers refine their offerings before broader deployment.

Challenges in applying the VUCA framework

VUCA can encourage analysts to search for all four challenges even when some are not significant. Their relevance and intensity vary between industries, organisations and locations. Classification must follow the evidence.

The material suggests that the framework may be especially useful in some emerging-market settings. However, the presence of a challenge must be established rather than assumed from the type of economy.

VUCA also emphasises adaptation to external conditions, whereas organisations may help shape those conditions. Innovation, lobbying and new business models can alter the environment faced by other organisations. Apple’s introduction of the iPhone illustrates how organisational action can change an industry.

An organisation may therefore respond to VUCA while also creating volatility, complexity or ambiguity for others. Its ability to do so depends partly on its resources and capabilities.

4 The macro environment of Starling Bank

The Starling case combines STEEPLE’s identification of external influences with VUCA’s analysis of challenges and responses. The interviews describe the circumstances and expectations at the time of recording.

Sociological, technological and political or regulatory developments reinforce one another. Customers expect immediate and convenient services. Smartphones, faster networks and improved processing make these possible. Policies encouraging new entrants and easier switching help customers act on dissatisfaction with existing providers.

The seven-day switching service described in the interview reduces the practical inconvenience of moving accounts by transferring balances and payment arrangements. This creates opportunities for challenger banks, while increasing pressure on established providers to retain customers.

Technology also expands the availability and processing of data. Machine learning uses algorithms to identify patterns, supporting fraud detection, customer enquiries and spending insights. Improved fraud detection can reduce both losses and the unnecessary blocking of legitimate transactions.

These developments create different VUCA challenges. Rapid changes in economic conditions can require operational responsiveness and financial buffers. Uncertainty about future losses calls for relevant information and scenario analysis. Complexity arises from coordinating regulation, customer services, payment systems and technology. Ambiguity concerns which unfamiliar applications will work effectively for customers.

Starling’s managers describe stress testing, examining how adverse scenarios could affect the bank, alongside capital planning to determine the resources needed to absorb unexpected losses. These processes connect analysis with preparation. They improve resilience without predicting exactly which scenario will occur.

Experiments can help establish where machine learning and automated customer support improve service. A system may answer routine enquiries quickly but provide an unsuitable experience when a customer needs judgement or personal support. Organisational coordination and specialist expertise are needed to integrate these technologies across the bank.

Ethical expectations concern transparency, responsible conduct and accountability to customers and employees. Data-intensive services make these expectations particularly relevant because technological capability does not by itself establish appropriate use.

Environmental expectations also influence operations. The interviews present paperless services and cloud infrastructure as part of Starling’s response. These are organisational practices rather than proof of overall environmental performance; moving computing off-site does not eliminate its resource use.

In applying the frameworks, the most important task is to justify priorities. For Starling, the interaction between customer expectations, enabling technology and regulatory developments helps explain the opportunity for mobile banking. The corresponding responses must then be linked to specific challenges through monitoring, financial preparation, organisational coordination and experimentation.


Summary Notes

Strategic analysis

The macro environment comprises broad external forces affecting organisations.
The meso environment comprises industry actors and competitive relationships.
Internal analysis examines organisational resources, capabilities and activities.
Effective strategy connects external opportunities and threats with internal capabilities.
Environmental change can make successful strategies obsolete.
Anticipation enables preparation before changes fully affect performance.
Complementary products increase another offering’s usefulness and demand.

STEEPLE factors

STEEPLE classifies seven types of macro-environmental influence.
Sociological factors concern demographics, lifestyles, values and customer expectations.
Technological factors concern innovation, adoption and the pace of change.
Economic factors include growth, income, unemployment, interest rates and exchange rates.
Environmental factors concern natural resources, pollution, climate and environmental protection.
Political factors concern government priorities, stability, trade policy and policymaking influence.
Legal factors concern enforceable requirements and protections.
Ethical factors concern responsible conduct and accountability beyond legal compliance.

Applying STEEPLE

Define the business, industry and geographical context before selecting relevant influences.
Scan for change, monitor trends, forecast developments and assess strategic implications.
Explain how each significant development affects demand, costs, operations or competitive position.
The same development can create opportunities for some organisations and threats for others.
Factors interact, so classification must be followed by explanation of their relationships.
Environmental concerns can influence regulation, stimulate innovation and reshape demand.
STEEPLE does not rank factors, so priorities require evidence and contextual judgement.
Its snapshot requires updating as conditions and relationships change.
Analysis informs strategic choices rather than ending with a list of trends.

Evaluating evidence

Secondary data was collected for a purpose other than the present analysis.
Assess evidence for relevance, sufficiency, recency and accuracy.
Reports may contain bias, omissions and assumptions.
Scenarios explore conditional possibilities rather than predict certain outcomes.
Separate reported evidence, forecasts and your interpretation.

VUCA and responses

VUCA distinguishes volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity.
STEEPLE identifies external influences, while VUCA diagnoses the challenges they create.

Volatility involves frequent, unpredictable change in an understood situation.
Agility enables rapid adaptation through flexible operations and accessible resources.
Resource slack provides reserves or spare capacity for changing conditions.
Stock buffers and long-term contracts reduce exposure to supply-price fluctuations.

Uncertainty involves understood causal relationships but insufficient knowledge of an event’s consequences.
Collecting and interpreting reliable information reduces relevant knowledge gaps.
Due diligence investigates circumstances and risks before major commitments.
An infodemic spreads harmful misinformation, increasing the importance of source evaluation.

Complexity involves numerous interdependent elements and does not require rapid change.
Formal institutions comprise laws and rules, while informal institutions comprise norms and relationships.
Restructuring adapts teams, processes and partnerships to manage interdependencies.

Ambiguity involves unclear causal relationships and unfamiliar rules.
Experimentation generates knowledge by testing approaches and evaluating outcomes.
Pilots enable refinement before wider implementation.

Automotive application

Shared mobility can alter ownership demand, vehicle utilisation and replacement patterns.
Vehicle inventories measure the fleet in use, while sales measure new vehicles purchased.
Car2Car connects vehicles, while Car2X connects vehicles with wider systems.
Electrification and autonomous driving depend jointly on technology, regulation and customer acceptance.
Component-price volatility supports supplier contracts and adaptable production.
Regulatory uncertainty supports policy monitoring and lobbying.
Technological complexity supports specialist partnerships and coordinated development.
Ambiguous mobility models support trials of innovations and stakeholder responses.

Limits of VUCA

The four challenges vary in relevance and intensity across contexts.
Responses must address the diagnosed problem rather than follow labels mechanically.
Organisations can shape their environments through innovation and political influence.
One organisation’s strategy can create VUCA challenges for others.

Starling Bank application

Immediate-service expectations, smartphone adoption and easier switching jointly support mobile banking.
Unbundling allows customers to obtain financial products from different providers.
Real-time balances and notifications combine convenience with spending control.
Machine learning identifies patterns supporting fraud detection, customer assistance and financial insights.
Testing establishes whether unfamiliar technologies improve customer outcomes.
Stress testing examines adverse scenarios, while capital planning prepares financial buffers.
Data-intensive banking connects innovation with privacy, transparency and accountability.
Paperless services and cloud infrastructure alone do not prove lower overall environmental impact.