Practical Skills Notes
Practical Skills
1. Variables
- Independent Variable (IV): The factor you change in an experiment. Limit to only one IV.
- Example: Light color.
- Dependent Variable (DV): The factor that changes because of the independent variable. This change must be measurable.
- Example: Plant height (as a measure of growth).
- Controlled Variable (CV): Factors kept constant to improve the validity of the experiment.
- Examples: Species of plant, age of plant, initial height, amount of sunlight, volume of water, etc.
- Control: A setup for comparison to demonstrate that the change happens because of the independent variable
- Example: A plant without any light at all
2. Graphs
- SP LaTuK is an acronym to remember the components of a good graph
- S = Scale/Size: The graph should be linear and greater than half a page in size.
- P = Points: Accurately plotted data points.
- L = Line: Drawn with a ruler, dot-to-dot, and not extending beyond the first or last point.
- A = Axes: Independent variable (IV) on the x-axis, dependent variable (DV) on the y-axis.
- T = Title: Specific enough to describe experiment, going beyond just axis labels.
- U = Units: Indicated in brackets on the axes (or using the word "in").
- K = Key: Include a key if necessary.
- Notes: A key and/or title may be unnecessary sometimes. Brackets for units can sometimes be replaced with the word "in".
3. Accuracy and Reliability
- Accuracy: Results are close to the true value; achieved by using good equipment.
- Example: A weighing scale that measures to more decimal places.
- Example: measuring the rate of photosynthesis by using an inverted cylinder to measure the VOLUME of oxygen produced rather than the number of bubbles produced per minute.
- Reliability: Consistent results are obtained when repeating an experiment; improved by repeating the experiment at least 3 times and calculating a mean.
4. Experimental Design
- Two Options:
- CORMMS
- Variables, control, and repeats.
- Technique: Use SCRAP, then write out the experimental design in full sentences.
a) Option 1: CORMMS
- CORMMS Breakdown:
- C = CHANGE: What is being changed in the investigation (Independent Variable).
- O = ORGANISM: A control related to the organism being used (if relevant).
- R = REPEAT: Repeats must be carried out for reliable results.
- M1 = MEASUREMENT 1: How the dependent variable is measured.
- M2 = MEASUREMENT 2: What time scale is used (dependent variable).
- S1 and S2 = SAME: What is controlled in the investigation (Controlled Variables).
- Example Question:
- Investigate the effect of cold water and hot water on a plant.
- Answer Template:
- IV: cold water and hot water / range of temperatures/eq
- Organism: same species/size/ age of plant
- Repeats: repeats / average
- Measurement 1: mass/length / number of leaves / ruler/eq
- Measurement 2: ref to time;
- 3x CVs: same light / carbon dioxide/water/mineral conc./pH/eq
- Mark Allocation: 6 marks total.
b) Option 2: Variables, Control, and Repeats
- Similar to CORMMS but structured differently.
5. Command Words
- Describe: State what you see and use data if it's a graph or table.
- Explain: Give a scientific reason why or how.
- Compare: Give both similarities and differences and make direct comparisons (within the same sentence).
- Suggest: Use your scientific knowledge and apply it to new situations.
- Evaluate: Similar to compare (give both pros and cons) but ALSO include a conclusion.
Example: CORMS in Practice
- Scenario: Ripening bananas investigation (Ethene gas).
- Outline: Put green bananas into bags – some with a ripe tomato (source of ethene). Record time for the bananas to turn yellow.
- Student Response Breakdown (CORMS):
- O: Use bananas from the same bunch (same variety, size, color).
- C: Put bananas into identical transparent polybags. Five bags with one banana, five with one banana and one tomato. Seal the bags.
- R: Observe 5 sets of bags for reliability.
- S: Keep bags in a dark cupboard with the same temperature.
- M: Check bags twice a day, record date, time, and color of each banana. Use a photograph of a ripe banana to check the final yellow color. Record the time, in hours, for each banana to become yellow and compare the results.
- Mark Scheme Breakdown:
- (1) C - bananas in container with and without tomato
- (2) O-same variety of banana / same stage of ripeness / same colour at start
- (3) R-repeats with several bananas / several batches bananas/
- (4) M1-measure colour of banana (e. g. match on colour scale)
- (5) M2-time stated to reach this colour
- (6) S1 same container around same number of bananas + tomato
- (7) S2 same temperature/same light / same humidity / same other variable
- Total = 6 Marks
General Advice for Experimental Design (CORMS) Questions
- Write down 'CORMS' to start as a checklist.
- Planning the method in outline helps before writing in more detail.
- Marks are awarded for written text, not necessarily for correct CORMS labels.
- C (Change/Comparison/Control): Independent variable; presence (or not) of ethene.
- O (Organism): Same species or variety; bananas from the same batch and starting at the same ripeness stage.
- R (Replication/Repeats): Several results are obtained.
- M1 + M2 (Measurements): Dependent variable
- M1: An "end-point" on the color scale to represent ripeness stage.
- M2: A timescale (how long it takes to reach the chosen color).
- S1 + S2 (Same/Controlled Variables): Quantity used (same volume, same mass) or other variables (same temperature, same humidity).
Example Question and Template for Smoking and Breathing Rate Experiment
Design an experiment to investigate the effect of smoking on breathing rate during exercise (6 marks).
C
- IV: Smoking Status (Smoker vs. Non-Smoker)
- What will you change in this investigation?
- What is the independent variable?
O
- Which organism will be involved in the investigation and what will you keep the same about it?
R
- How will you make sure the experiment is reliable?
- How often will you repeat the experiment?
- Or how many different organisms will you use so you can do several experiments at the same time?
M1 and M2
- DV: Breathing Rate.
- How will you measure the dependent variable?
- What equipment will you use to measure it?
- How long will you wait before you will take your results?
S M1 and M2
- What about the environment needs to be kept constant?
- What are your environmental control variables
Minimum 4x CVs: - Organism (x2)
- Experiment (x2)
- Control (if there is one):
- Repeats + mean