Modern Architecture Summary

The Modern Movement: Origins, Scope, & Time Frame

  • Modernism: A period (circa 1890-1970s) and a state of mind.
  • Origins: Contested among historians (Gothic Revival, French Enlightenment, Italian Renaissance).
  • End: Debated (1968 student demos, 1972 Pruitt-Igoe demolition); some see it continuing today.
  • Subdivisions:
    • Pre-war/Early Modernism (1890-1914)
    • Classic/Heroic Modernism (1918-1939)
    • Post-war Modernism (1945-1968)
  • Scope:
    • Early: Dispersed (England, Europe, North America).
    • Inter-war: Consolidated in Europe.
    • Post-war: Migrates to North America; develops in South America, Asia, India, Australia.

Context for Modernism

  • Enlightenment: Freedom to use intellect; ideals of liberty, equality, tolerance.
  • New Forms of Knowledge:
    • Rationalism: Knowledge based on reason.
    • Empiricism: Knowledge derived from experience.
    • Idealism: Society shaped by ideas.
  • Aesthetic Categories: Valued picturesque and sublime in addition to the beautiful.
  • Aesthetic Experience:
    • Picturesque: Qualities of roughness, irregularity, and variety, often found in landscapes.
    • Sublime: Feelings of awe and terror evoked by immense or powerful experiences.
  • Theoretical Problems: Meaning and morality in architecture.
  • Spirit of the Age (Zeitgeist): Shared state of mind.
  • Progress of History: Predetermined chain of events toward an enlightened future.
  • Rise of Capitalism, Industrialisation, and Cities
  • New Technologies: Iron and Ferro-concrete.
  • New Building Types: Museums, libraries, hospitals, train stations. New functional problems emerge.

Early & Classic Modernism: Common Factors

  • Disillusionment with 19th C architecture.
  • Desire to break with past styles.
  • Desire to find new forms and ways of living.
  • Abstraction: Independent treatment of form, structure, and spatial organization.
  • Appreciation of Form: Removal of ornament leads to valuing form.
  • Architectural Space: Shift from conceptual necessity to experiential.
  • Material Technology: Artistic tied to utilitarian progress.
  • Function: Separating function from status; function generates form.
  • Utopia & \"The International Style\": Universal application of Enlightenment ideals.

Early & Classic Modernism: Different Groups

  • (Constructional) Realism: Otto Wagner. Form determined by construction method.
  • (Structural) Rationalism: Giuseppe Terragni. Spatial organisation follows structural grid.
  • Functionalism: Walter Gropius. Spatial organisation follows the building's use.
  • Constructivism: Building form as an assemblage of constructional systems.
  • Organic Architecture: Frank Lloyd Wright. Spatial organisation integrated with unique structural solution.
  • Expressionism: Spatial organisation follows expressive structure.

Post-war Modernism: Divergent Factors

  • Progress and/or Retreat: Public skepticism increases.
  • Abstraction, Identity, and Monumentality: Interest in identity and monumentality emerges.
  • Space vs. \"Place\" and \"Placemaking\": Emphasis on location-specific design.
  • Advanced Technologies vs. Traditional Materials: Experimentation in both.
  • Design Flexibility and Social Systems: Focus on adaptability of design.
  • Critical Regionalism: Synthesis of universal civilization & local culture.

Post-war Modernism: Different Groups

  • French Primitivism: Le Corbusier. Return to nature, vernacular forms and raw materials.
  • German Expressionism: Hans Scharoun. Form expresses psychological states.
  • Dutch Structuralism: Aldo van Eyck. Architecture as a network integrated with the urban fabric.
  • Italian Craftsmanship: Carlo Scarpa. Layering materials, connecting modernity and tradition.
  • English New Brutalism: Peter & Alison Smithson. Clear structural diagram.
  • English Futurism (‘Archigram’): Incorporation of pop culture, new technology, and neo-futurist imagery.
  • Structural Rationalism & Corporate Modernism: Mies van der Rohe & SOM.
  • Abstract Expressionism: Louis Kahn. Combines rationalism with spacial types, differentiates between 'served' and 'servant' spaces.
  • (Structural) Expressionism: Structure expressed and use of shell structures.

Significance

  • Modern architecture helps understand space, form, and surface.
  • Provides a precedent for understanding the interaction between space, structure, and program.
  • Framework for making judgments about architecture.
  • Reminds that architects engage with culture, society, politics, and subjectivity.