Environmental Etiology of Schizophrenia

Environmental Etiology of Schizophrenia

Role of Environmental Factors in Schizophrenia Etiology

  • Estimated that approximately 65% of the risk of developing schizophrenia is attributed to genetic factors (including both unique and shared genetics).

  • This implies that around 35% of the risk is associated with environmental factors.

Latent Vulnerability Model (McCrory and Viding 2015; Devel & Psychopathology)

  • Latent characteristics: traits or qualities that require specific conditions or situations to manifest.

  • A true marker of latent vulnerability must possess a predictive value in indicating a heightened risk for future psychiatric disorders.
      - Latent Characteristics include:
        - Cognitive: e.g., reward processing
        - Emotion: e.g., fear responses
        - Environmental risk factors play a significant role in the manifestation of these latent characteristics.

Environmental Adversity

  • The complexity of environmental adversity is acknowledged:
      - Problem: Many studies yield inconsistent results.
      - Best evidence arises from: meta-analyses and population-based studies.
      - Meta-analysis: a statistical process in which data from numerous independent studies on the same subject are examined to ascertain overall trends.
      - Results can indicate:
        - Positive Effect
        - Negative Effect
        - No Effect

Environmental Factors Implicated in Schizophrenia Risk

  • A diverse range of environmental elements are implicated in schizophrenia risk:
      - Maternal Immune Activation
      - Childhood Trauma
      - Substance Use
      - Urbanicity
      - There exists some evidence for obstetric complications, notably involving fetal growth restriction, prematurity, hypoxia/asphyxia, or placental dysfunction; however, the effect is minor.

Maternal Immune Activation

  • The link between prenatal infection and subsequent schizophrenia is regarded as one of the most consistently replicated discoveries.

  • It is not restricted to a single pathogen; any pathogen leading to maternal immune activation (MIA) during pregnancy is relevant.
      - Common Pathway:
        - Maternal infection leads to an immune response (release of cytokines), which alters fetal brain development.
      - MIA disrupts:
        - Neuronal migration
        - Synaptic pruning
        - Development of the dopaminergic system

  • In animal models, immune activation alone may induce behavioral abnormalities, dopamine dysregulation, and cortical changes simulating schizophrenia manifestations.

Childhood Trauma

  • Adversity during critical periods of brain development impacts developmental pathways:
      - Prolonged exposure to glucocorticoids is neurotoxic.
        - Chronic elevation of glucocorticoids reduces the number of neurons within the relevant pathways.
        - Disrupts efficiency of the negative feedback loop, resulting in an ineffective stress response.

  • High rates of psychiatric issues are observed in adults with a history of childhood trauma (CT), indicating CT as a potent risk factor for various health problems (as supported by the Kaiser-Permanente ACES Study).

Dose-Response Relationship (DeRosse et al., 2014)

  • Examines the relationship between childhood trauma and the psychosis spectrum in subjects including controls and schizophrenia patients.

  • Control group: N=261

  • Schizophrenia group: N=325

Meta-Analysis - Childhood Trauma

  • Conducted by Varese et al. (2012); gathered data from various studies:
      - Included 18 case-control studies (totaling 2048 psychotic patients and 1856 non-psychiatric controls).
      - Included 10 prospective and quasi-prospective studies (totaling 41,803 individuals).
      - Included 8 population-based cross-sectional studies (Total sample size = 535,546).

  • Estimated Population Attributable Risk (PAR) for childhood trauma at approximately 33% (Confidence Interval: 16%–47%).

  • Interpretation: Between 16% and 47% of individuals currently diagnosed with schizophrenia would not have the disorder had they not experienced trauma during childhood.

  • Emotional abuse is reported to have the most substantial impact in relation to psychosis.

Substance Abuse (Nielsen et al., Psychological Medicine 2013)

  • Among the entire population of Denmark (over 3 million people), there are 204,505 individuals diagnosed with substance abuse and 21,305 diagnosed with schizophrenia.

  • Proportion of substance abusers diagnosed with schizophrenia is highlighted, along with the relationship between substance abuse and the onset of schizophrenia.

The Impact of Cannabis

  • Cannabis-Psychosis Persistence Model:
      - Person A: Normal developmental expression of subthreshold psychotic experiences, mild and transient.
      - Person B: Similar expression but experiences longer persistence due to additional environmental exposure (cannabis use).
      - Person C: Prolonged persistence leading to transition to clinical psychotic disorder attributed to repeated cannabis use.

  • Relevant considerations:
      - Self-medication potential?
      - Cannabis comprises over 200 psychoactive compounds, thus termed a “dirty” drug.
      - Genetic risk factors for both cannabis abuse and schizophrenia may overlap.

Urbanicity (Sundquist et al., British Journal 2004)

  • A study on the total population of Sweden (over 4.4 million individuals) indicates a correlation between population density and the incidence of psychosis.

Interactions of Environmental Risks with Biology

  • Environmental risks interact with various biological aspects including:
      - Brain Development:
        - Grey matter organization
        - Neurogenesis
        - Axonal growth
        - Myelination
        - Synaptogenesis
        - Synaptic pruning
        - Neuro-endocrine regulation
      - Neurocognition:
        - Sustained attention
        - Selective attention
        - Working memory
        - Language (receptive and productive)
        - Private speech
        - Inner speech
        - Analogical reasoning
        - Meta-cognition
      - Affective Development:
        - Basic and complex emotions
        - Emotional regulation
        - Reward experience
      - Social Cognition:
        - Emotion recognition
        - Attachment
        - Self-concept and identity
        - Theory of mind

Gene x Environment Interaction (GxE)

  • GxE interactions may present as environmental factors impacting DNA methylation, resulting in changes in gene expression through epimutations.

  • Epigenetics studies how behavior and environment can induce cellular changes affecting gene functionalities (altered gene expression and developmental changes).

  • Epigenetic modifications are reversible and do not alter the DNA sequence; however, they can modify how genes are interpreted by the body.

  • This topic raises connections to Lamarckian evolution, where acquired characteristics might be passed on.

Epigenetic Changes and Environmental Exposures

  • Preconception Factors:
      - Famine
      - Exposure to viral infections
      - Pregnancy complications
      - Maternal depression

  • Developmental Exposures:
      - Trauma
      - Substance use
      - Urbanicity
      - Other factors.

Conclusions

  • It is unequivocally established that schizophrenia is a neurodevelopmental disorder resulting from an aberrant developmental trajectory.

  • While some knowledge exists concerning the affected cells and circuits, a comprehensive understanding may be decades away.

  • Causal factors are likely a combination of genetic, environmental, and their interaction.

  • It is crucial to acknowledge that psychotic disorders are heterogeneous, suggesting that the underlying causes are likely to be diverse as well, encompassing the Schizophrenias.