Appeal Rules dated08.06.2026

Core Components of Suspension and Disciplinary Proceedings

The disciplinary rules governing government servants are structured around foundational concepts that every employee and administrator must grasp. The four primary pillars regarding the rule of suspension include:

  1. Suspension and Authority: Understanding the specific authority empowered to place a government employee under suspension.

  2. Grounds of Suspension: The specific legal and administrative circumstances under which a government servant can be officially suspended.

  3. Revocation of Suspension Orders: The process and conditions under which a suspension order is cancelled or lifted.

  4. Deemed Suspension: A technical term referring to a situation where an employee is considered suspended by operation of law (e.g., if detained in custody for more than 4848 hours), even if a formal order has not yet been issued.

  5. Appeal to Suspension Order: The right of the employee to challenge the suspension through a higher authority.

Promotion Procedure for Suspended Employees: The Sealed Cover

A critical question in service law is whether a government employee currently under suspension can be considered for promotion. The answer is Yes, but the procedure is distinct and structured to protect both the administration and the employee's rights.

  • The Sealed Cover Procedure: This is the specific mechanism adopted for the promotion of suspended employees.

  • Execution: The findings of the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) regarding the employee's fitness for promotion are placed in a "sealed cover."

  • Outcome: This cover remains unopened while proceedings are active. It is opened only when all disciplinary proceedings have concluded and the employee has been either exonerated (cleared of charges) or acquitted by a court of law.

The Two Tiers of Disciplinary Proceedings: Minor and Major Penalties

Disciplinary proceedings are categorized into two distinct types based on the severity of the alleged misconduct and the potential punishment.

Minor Penalty Proceedings
  1. Action Initiation: Upon receipt of a complaint, the disciplinary authority takes note and directly calls the employee to "show cause." In these proceedings, this is termed a representation.

  2. Assessment: The authority considers the representation to determine guilt. If the employee pleads guilty, a minor penalty is imposed.

  3. Inquiry Requirements: While generally simplified, an inquiry becomes mandatory in minor proceedings if the proposed penalty involves a cumulative effect or a non-cumulative effect that exceeds a duration of 33 years.

  4. Types: There are typically 55 types of minor penalties (e.g., Censure).

Major Penalty Proceedings
  1. Mandatory Inquiry: The defining characteristic of major penalty proceedings is that a formal inquiry is mandatory.

  2. Types: There are 55 types of major penalties.

  3. Validity: Any claim that a major penalty can be imposed without an inquiry is false.

Administrative Framework and Constitutional Origins

  • Rule Count: This set of rules contains exactly 3131 rules.

  • Historical Context: These rules (The 20192019 Rules) replaced and substituted the older "Regular Discipline and Appeal Rules of 20112011."

  • Constitutional Authority: These rules are framed and formulated under the Proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India.

  • Legal Nature: These rules are substantive in nature, rather than purely procedural.

Orders Not Subject to Appeal (Rule 18)

Under Rule 18, certain orders are strictly non-appealable within the departmental framework:

  1. Orders Made by the Governor:

    • The Governor acts as the final administrative authority and the highest disciplinary authority in the state.

    • Since there is no authority above the Governor in the state hierarchy, departmental appeals are exhausted once an order reaches this level.

    • However, these orders are not immune to legal challenges; they can be challenged in a High Court or before the Governor via Judicial Review.

  2. Interlocutory Orders:

    • These are temporary, provisional, or procedural decisions made during active litigation to facilitate the progress of a case (e.g., refusing to call a specific witness deemed irrelevant, adjourning a hearing, or decisions on photocopying documents).

    • They are "steps in aid of final disposal" and are procedural, not substantive.

    • Granting appeals for these would result in "subjudice" delays, indefinitely stalling the disciplinary process.

  3. Orders Passed by Inquiry Authority under Rule 10: Orders issued during the course of an inquiry (e.g., directing a servant to appear within 1010 days) are not appealable.

Grounds for Judicial Review

Since certain orders (like the Governor's) are not departmentally appealable, limited judicial review is available in the High Court on the following grounds:

  • Mala Fide: Orders made with bad intent, personal bias, or malice.

  • Extraneous/Irrelevant Grounds: Decisions based on factors completely outside the scope of the case.

  • Violation of Natural Justice: Specifically, the failure to provide a "reasonable opportunity of being heard."

  • Perverse Findings: Orders that are contrary to the evidence provided or based on no evidence at all.

Appealable Orders (Rule 19)

According to Rule 19, an employee has the right to appeal the following:

  • Orders of suspension or deemed suspension made under Rule 6.

  • Orders imposing any penalty (minor or major) specified in Rule 7 (unless passed by the Governor).

  • Orders enhancing an existing penalty.

  • Orders that adversely affect pay, allowances, pension, or service conditions.

  • Orders determining subsistence allowance amounts during suspension.

  • Orders determining the "period spent on duty" regarding pay and allowances following dismissal, removal, or retirement.

Appellate Authority Hierarchy and Scheduling (Rule 20)

An appeal is preferred to the authority specified in the Schedule or empowered by a general/special order of the Governor.

  • Group A and Group B Employees: Appeal lies with the Appointing Authority (senior to the Disciplinary Authority) or the Governor.

  • Group C and Group D Employees: Appeal lies with the authority to which the original deciding authority is immediately subordinate.

  • Specific Examples:

    • For the Meghalaya Civil Services, the appellate authority is the Governor.

    • For others, it may be the Chief Secretary.

Limitation Periods and Procedure for Appeals (Rule 21-25)

  • Limitation Period (Rule 21): An appeal must be submitted within 4545 days from the date the appellant receives a copy of the order.

  • Condonation of Delay: The appellate authority may entertain an appeal after 4545 days if "sufficient cause" for the delay (e.g., illness) is demonstrated.

  • Submission Details: The appeal must be in the employee's own name, addressed to the correct authority, and a copy must be forwarded to the original disciplinary authority.

  • Prohibition of Improper Language: The appeal must contain material arguments and facts but must not contain disrespectful or improper language.

Consideration and Disposal of Appeals by the Authority

  • Reviewing Suspension: The authority considers if the suspension is justified and can either confirm or revoke the order.

  • Reviewing Penalties: The authority checks for procedural compliance with the Constitution, whether findings are warranted by evidence, and if the penalty is excessive, adequate, or inadequate.

  • MPSC Consultation: The Meghalaya Public Service Commission (MPSC) is consulted if necessary. The employee must be given an opportunity to represent against the advice provided by the MPSC.

  • Disposal Timeline (Rule 23): Appeals must be disposed of expeditiously, specifically within 33 months from the date of receipt.

  • No Personal Hearing (Rule 23(4)): Unlike court cases, it is not mandatory to hear the officer in person during disciplinary appeal proceedings.

Power of Revision (Rule 26)

Revision is a supervisory power vested in the Governor, Head of Department, or specified authority.

  • Scope: The revising authority can call for records, revise orders, and confirm, reduce, enhance, or set aside penalties.

  • Commencement: Revision proceedings usually commence only after the expiry of the 4545-day appeal period (if no appeal was filed) or after an appeal has been disposed of.

  • Notice Requirement: If the revising authority proposes to enhance a penalty, a representation must be allowed, and an inquiry must be held if a major penalty is proposed where none was held before.

Power of Review (Rule 27)

Review is a power held primarily by the Governor.

  • Basis: A review is conducted if "new material or evidence" comes to light that was not available at the time of the original order and has the effect of changing the nature of the case.

  • Sumoto Power: The Governor can initiate a review at any time, either on his own motion (Sumoto) or upon request.

  • Natural Justice: The employee must still be given the opportunity to make a representation before a review order is finalized.

Comprehensive Comparison: Appeal, Revision, and Review

Feature

Appeal

Revision

Review

Nature of Right

Substantive statutory right of the employee.

Discretionary supervisory power of a higher authority.

Exceptional remedy based on specific circumstances.

Scope

Complete re-examination of facts and law.

Limited to legality, propriety, and procedural regularity.

Limited to discovering new evidence or correcting obvious errors.

Initiator

The aggrieved employee.

The employee or Sumoto by a higher authority.

Normally the employee; occasionally Sumoto by the authority.

Deadline

Within 4545 days of receipt.

After appeal period ends or appeal is disposed.

Any time (Governor's power).

Questions & Discussion

Q: Can a Governor's order be appealed?
A: No departmental appeal lies against the Governor because he is the final administrative authority. However, legal remedies exist through judicial review in the High Court.

Q: What is the timeline for disposing of an appeal?
A: Within 33 months from the date the appellate authority receives the application.

Q: Is an inquiry mandatory for major penalties?
A: Yes, inquiry is a mandatory requirement for major penalties, even at the appeal or revision stage if an enhancement to a major penalty is proposed and no inquiry was initially conducted.

Q: What are memorials and mercy petitions?
A: Since no appeal lies against the Governor, an employee can submit a memorial or mercy petition to the Governor praying for the remission of a penalty or a pardon.

Q: Can a Governor's order be appealed?
A: No departmental appeal lies against the Governor because he is the final administrative authority. However, legal remedies exist through judicial review in the High Court.
Q: What is the timeline for disposing of an appeal?
A: Within 33 months from the date the appellate authority receives the application.
Q: Is an inquiry mandatory for major penalties?
A: Yes, inquiry is a mandatory requirement for major penalties, even at the appeal or revision stage if an enhancement to a major penalty is proposed and no inquiry was initially conducted.
Q: What are memorials and mercy petitions?
A: Since no appeal lies against the Governor, an employee can submit a memorial or mercy petition to the Governor praying for the remission of a penalty or a pardon.