Situation Judgement Appropriateness
Question 1
Joanna is a third-year medical student who is very excited to start her clinical practice. She loves immersing herself in practical tasks as opposed to lecture based learning. It is the first week of her training in the hospital and she has been shadowing a consultant called Dr Dakin. Dr Dakin has a very relaxed approach to his job, and has told Joanna that he wants her to have a good first impression of the profession. As a result of this, Dr Dakin has not been allocating tasks to Joanna and tells her to go and relax in the cafeteria several times a day. Joanna is very disappointed because she feels like she has not learnt much at all, and hasn't had the opportunity to engage herself in clinical practice as much as she would have liked to.
a) How appropriate is posting a letter to the medical school telling them how she feels ?
Appropriate, but not ideal - as it takes time for the letter to be delivered and responded and therefore delaying the correction of this situation
b) How appropriate is refuse to go to the cafeteria the next time Dr Dakin tells her to.
A very inappropriate thing to do - highlights lack of respect towards your senior and cannot solve the issue that Dr Dakin is not giving any learning opportunities to Joanna
c) Ask Dr Dakin if there is a reason why he is stopper her from taking learning opportunities
Appropriate, but not ideal - as Dr Dakin told Joanna already he doesn’t want her to have a bad impression of the profession
Question 2
Shimi is a medical student preparing to sit an exam later that afternoon. Her exam cohort is waiting in a separate room while another cohort from her year completes the exam, in order to ensure the two groups do not interact before Shimi's cohort sit it. After the first cohort finishes the exam, Shimi receives a text message from a friend, John, who was in the first cohort, offering to share screenshots of some of the exam questions.
a) How appropriate is asking her classmates after the exam if they have received the screen shots
Inappropriate, but not awful - it fails to refuse acceptance of the exam questions and does not highlight the unethical nature of John’s offer. This response is not awful as it shows the possibility of further engagement
Question 3
Emily, a medical student completing a hospital placement, is working closely with a consultant, Dr Hussain. Dr Hussain, who is responsible for evaluating Emily's progress at the end of her placement, has a large following on social media where he discusses public health and issues related to wellbeing. Emily follows Dr Hussain on social media and is notified of his latest post. Upon checking her phone, Emily discovers that the post consists of a sponsored advertisement for a health supplement and includes some misleading information on an important health topic.
a) How appropriate is publicly commenting on the post highlighting the misinformation
A very inappropriate thing to do - as this involves publicly challenging a supervisor who has significant power over Emily’s academic progress and career prospects.
b) How appropriate is flagging the post as untrustworthy to social media platform
Appropriate but not ideal- solves this issue without direct confronting with her supervisor,
however it doesn’t address the potential of Dr Hussain’s learning from his mistake and correct it
Question 4
Jay is a foundation year doctor working in a busy Emergency Department. Philip presents to Jay with a severe wound. Philip tells Jay that he was stabbed with a knife, but he doesn't want anyone to know. Philip tells Jay he only told him in case that information affected his treatment options, and he trusts that Jay will keep the information confidential.
a) How appropriate is speaking to the police, without telling Philip that he is reporting the incident
Appropriate, but not ideal - police should know but confidentiality requested has to be broken and trust is broken down
b) How appropriate is telling the senior consultant about what happened and ask him to speak to Phillip and report it to the police
Appropriate, but not ideal - confidentiality extends to all member of the medical team involved in Philip’s care so the confidentiality is kept, however it would be better if jay spoke directly to Phillip instead ( should not requesting for help if competent )
c) How appropriate is telling Phillip that he should report the incident to the police himself.
A very inappropriate thing to do - Philip has already said that he doesn’t want anyone else so it is likely he won’t do it. Jay has the responsibility to tell the police.
Question 5
Roman is a medical student whose mother is a consultant physician. Throughout his medical training, his mother has frequently compared his progress to her own experiences. Roman has been doing well in his studies and receiving positive feedback from his supervisors, but he increasingly feels pressure from these comparisons and has started to feel inadequate. When Roman mentions feeling stressed about upcoming exams, his mother suggests he should find them straightforward given his family background.
a) How appropriate is this statement' ‘Medical School is demanding for everyone, including people from medical families’
Appropriate but not ideal- not ideal as it only dresses this specific comment rather than the constant comparisons his mother put him through
b) How appropriate is this statement ‘You’re making assumptions that just aren’t true for me’
A very inappropriate thing to do- it is accusatory and confrontational without providing context or inviting constructive dialogue. This could make Roman’s mother defensive and damages their relationship
c) How appropriate is this statement ‘Comments like that are part of why I feel so much pressure.’
Inappropriate, but not awful - it is accusatory and confrontational but he identifies the real issue causing his feelings of inadequacy
Question 6
Cara, a third year medical student, is the leader of a group project that will count towards her end of year grade. A week before the deadline Cara discovers that she has given one of the members of the team, Alan, the wrong deadline date. Alan is yet to realise her mistake, but Cara is sure that he will not be finished by the end of the week and knows this is her fault.
How appropriate is asking one of the other members of the team who has finished their own section to help Alan.
Appropriate, but not ideal- Cara should offer to help since it was her mistake
Question 7
Emma and Bailey are both medical students who are sitting an important exam. Emma has recently had trouble at home and has been extremely stressed so has not had enough time to finish revising for the exam. Emma and Bailey are sitting next to each other in the exam hall and halfway through the exam, Bailey spots Emma looking over at her exam paper. After the exam, Emma asks Bailey not to say anything to anyone about the situation.
a) How appropriate is reporting Emma to the GMC immediately ?
Inappropriate but not awful - Bailey must take action as she witnessed that Emma has cheated. However, Bailey should try to deal with the situation at a direct level before approaching the GMC as it would be more appropriate to contact the medical school first.
Question 8
Rohit is a medical student on placement on a hospital ward. While in the ward stock room, Rohit notices one of his fellow students, Barry, pick up two intravenous giving sets (needles and tubes) and two bags of fluid. Barry then puts them into his bag. When he realises Rohit has seen him, Barry quickly explains that the items are for practising his clinical skills at home.
a) How appropriate is politely ask Barry to return the items
A very appropriate thing to do
b) How appropriate is telling Barry that if he does not return the items, Rohit will inform the consultant
Inappropriate, but not awful - ultimatum given which is insensitive and disrespectful towards a colleague and this damages their professional relationship unnecessarily.
c) How appropriate is observing Barry over the forthcoming week to see if his behaviour is repeated
A very inappropriate thing to do - fails to address barry’s misuse of medical supplies which should be made available for patient care
Question 9
Cara and Neill are in their final year at medical school. Ten days before one of their final exams, Neill asks Cara would allow him to sneak some of her notes into the exam with him. Neill says he has been under a great amount of pressure lately as he has had to manage working in a café alongside his studies. Neill say that he feels that without the help of Cara's notes he will fail this exam, which would not be a true reflection of what he is capable of.
How appropriate is suggesting that Neil speak to Student Services about exam pressures instead of speaking to her
Appropriate, but not ideal - it would be better if Cara were to try helping Neil herself first.
Question 10
John is a medical student on placement in Accident and Emergency (A&E). It is a busy shift and many patients are waiting to be seen. One patient, Mrs Brown, is very angry. She has been waiting for an hour and shouts that she is being ignored and is too busy to be waiting around. She does not require immediate medical attention, but she is loudly accusing the medical team of being negligent.
a) How appropriate is telling the patient that if she continues to raise her voice, the doctor will not see her
A very inappropriate thing to do - it would be very unprofessional to threaten the patient with a lack of treatment based on her behavior (especially at A& E)
b) How appropriate is explaining that some patients unfortunately have to wait longer than others
Inappropriate, but not awful - it doesn’t explain why some patients have to wait longer than others; it isn’t awful as John is attempting to clear the situation even though it is ineffective
Question 11
Natasha is a consultant who works at a busy city hospital. She travels to work everyday by train as she cannot drive and there are no bus routes from her home to the hospital. One morning, Natasha arrives at the train station to find that all the trains have been cancelled due to mechanical issues. The train is the only form of transport that would get her to the hospital on time.
a) How appropriate is Natalie phoning her friend who is also a consultant at the hospital and ask if she will cover her shift ?
A very inappropriate thing to do - Natasha is unprofessional in this situational as she should explore other ways to get to work and inform supervisor of her issue, before trying to find cover
b) How appropriate is ringing the rail company and make a formal complaint about the delay
A very inappropriate thing to do - this is not her primary concern and this will delay her arrival at work even more
Question 12
Cathy is a medical student on a surgical ward observing a consultant, Dr Smith, complete a ward round. Dr Smith decides to prescribe an antibiotic to a patient which will later be administered by a nurse. Once the ward round is complete, Cathy decides to review the patient's notes and realises that the patient is allergic to the antibiotic that was prescribed by the consultant. Dr Smith has now left the ward and is not immediately available.
a) How appropriate is asking the patient if he is allergic to any medications
Appropriate, but not ideal - double-checking this info shows good attention to patient safety, however it is not ideal as Cathy already knows from the patient notes that the allergy exists and time should be spent on alerting qualified medical staff
b) How appropriate is informing the patient that an incorrect medication has been prescribed for him
Inappropriate but not awful- causes unwanted anxiety and alarm without providing a solution to the problem and medical students doesn’t have the authority to discuss this with patients. This would break down the trust between medical team and patients. Not awful as it demonstrates genuine concern for patient safety
Question 13
Dr Hassan has been asked to mentor Sarah, a third-year medical student, during her placement on his ward. Dr Hassan is already managing a heavy workload and feels increasingly that his clinical responsibilities are getting on top of him. During a conversation with Dr Emily, another junior doctor, Dr Hassan admits that he is tempted to provide poor mentoring deliberately so that he will not be asked to mentor students again in the future. He suggests this would solve his workload problem without having to directly refuse the mentoring assignment.
a) How appropriate is ‘maybe you should just be honest about not having capacity for mentoring right now’
Appropriate, but not ideal - suggests a professional approach to managing capacity limitations rather than deliberately performing poorly; not ideal as it doesn’t emphasise how harmful poor mentoring would be to Sarah’s development
b) How appropriate is ‘I can see why you’d want to avoid extra responsibilities when you’re already stretched’
Inappropriate, but not awful - appears to validate Dr Hassan’s thinking about avoiding responsibilities, which can appear that she’s attempting to support her plan; not awful as it demonstrates empathy and acknowledges the stress he’s experiencing
Question 14
Peter and John are 2nd year medical students on a hospital placement in a psychiatric hospital. They have been asked to take a history from one of the patients who has a forensic history. After taking the history, Peter and John have a lunch break. John tells Peter, 'That patient created this style of life for himself... we shouldn't have to waste medical resources on patients like that.'
How appropriate is speaking to the supervising lecturer about what John said
Inappropriate, but not awful - it is important to make supervisors aware of the unprofessional behaviour, to allow them to help address the situation and advise the individual of how to correct their inappropriate actions. However, Peter should have made an attempt to resolve this issue directly with john which is easy to do
Question 15
Pascal, a medical student on a hospital placement, goes to the hospital canteen, which is used by both staff and the public, for his lunch. While he is eating there alone, three other medical students on his rotation enter the canteen and sit down together. The students are engrossed in a discussion and do not appear to notice Pascal. Pascal overhears one of the students, Laura, make a comment about a patient case; Pascal knows the comment to be mistaken, as he interviewed the patient in question that morning and read her chart.
a) How appropriate is informing the patient’s care team back on the ward that misinformation about the patient is circulating
Inappropriate, but not awful- it focusses on the wrong issue(should be about confidentiality) and escalates the situation unnecessarily. However, Pascal recognises that incorrect information about patients requires attention and demonstrates concern for accurate patient care
b) How appropriate is letting them knowing that breaching patient confidentiality could lead to their exclusion from medical school
A very inappropriate thing to do- it is confrontational and threating in tone, doesn’t have authority to say and this will damage relationships and create defensiveness
c) How appropriate is going over to where they are sitting and remind them discreetly not to discuss patients in public
A very appropriate thing to do - directly addresses the confidentiality breach in a professional and non-confrontational manner
d) How appropriate is alerting them to his presence and telling them he will discuss the case privately with them
Appropriate, but not ideal - moves the convo away from public space and can address the misinformation. However, it doesn’t address the breach in confidentiality
Question 16
Samantha is a junior doctor who is working on a chemotherapy ward. This ward is full of patients who are very vulnerable to infections because their immune systems are weak. Jake, a third-year medical student, is on a placement on the same ward. He is aiming to learn more about how cancer can impact a patient's life. When he arrived, Samantha had to remind Jake to wash his hands upon entering the ward. Now, she has noticed that he keeps entering the patients' rooms without wearing an apron or gloves. There is a clear sign on each door telling the person entering to wear a fresh apron and gloves.
a) How appropriate is telling the doctor in charge that Jake is failing to follow protocol
Inappropriate, but not awful - She can deal with the situation herself as she is a doctor. However, this is not awful as Samantha is trying to resolve the issue
b) How appropriate is giving Jake an apron and gloves for him to keep on at all times
A very inappropriate thing to do - poses major infection risk
Question 17
Elizabeth and John are medical students who have been paired together to work on a student research project. They will both share a mark for the project, which will contribute to their final coursework grades. Halfway through the project, with only a couple of weeks before the submission deadline, John calls Elizabeth and tells her he is struggling with several issues related to his mental health. John explains that he needs to take a break from submitting further contributions to the project.
a) How appropriate is reassuring John that Elizabeth can finish most of her project on her own ?
Inappropriate, but not awful - places an unfair academic burden on Elizabeth and does not address John’s need for proper support. However, it is not awful as it demonstrates genuine care for John’s wellbeing
b) How appropriate is discussing John’s mental health concerns with her academic tutor?
A very inappropriate thing to do- it breaches John’s confidentiality by sharing his personal mental health information without his consent.
Question 18
Hooria is a dental student working on a group assignment with three other students. The group has agreed to upload rough drafts to a shared online document to establish their structure and main points before refining their work. After Hooria uploads her draft section, she notices that another member of the group, Marcus, has added several comments throughout her work. The comments rewrite her sentences and reference sources she has not included. At the end of her section, Marcus has added a note offering to review other members' sections as well to ensure the assignment meets appropriate standards.
a) How appropriate is speaking privately with the other group members about Marcus’s approach to feedback
Inappropriate, but not awful - it involves discussing Marcus’s behaviour with other group members behind his back. However, it is not awful, as by doing this, she can understand if this is a broader group issue.
b) How appropriate is politely tell Marcus that he has included references for sources that she did not draw on in her work
Appropriate, but not ideal - Hooria sets a boundary about acceptable changes whilst maintaining a professional tone. However, this response is not ideal as it does not address the boarder problem that he has extensively rewritten her work without permission
Question 19
Sultaan is a junior doctor working in A&E. During his shift, a well-known public figure is admitted to the department. At the end of his shift, as Sultaan walks through the hospital car park to his vehicle, he is approached by someone who identifies themselves as a journalist. The journalist asks Sultaan to confirm whether the patient has been admitted to the department and what their condition is.
a) How appropriate is telling the journalist they shouldn’t be approaching staff in the car park?
A very inappropriate thing to do - creates unnecessary confrontation and could escalate the situation. This response does not address the importance of maintaining patient confidentiality and draw more attention
b) How appropriate is saying that he cannot comment on the patient’s current status
A very inappropriate thing to do - implicitly confirm the public figure is indeed a patient at the hospital which breaches patient confidentiality
c) How appropriate is walking past the journalist without responding and get into his car
A very appropriate thing to do - maintains complete patient confidentiality by avoiding any interaction that could reveal info
d) How appropriate is checking the news websites later to see if the admission has been publicly reported?
Appropriate, but not ideal- nothing wrong with accessing publicly available information, however this approach is not ideal as it does not address the immediate issue of how to respond appropriately
Question 20
Penelope and Rahul are two medical students undertaking a placement at a General Practice (GP). It is a quiet morning, so they have been helping the receptionist with admin and calling patients into their appointments. Rahul looks bored and complains to Penelope that his tasks are pointless. Penelope notices that the patients and the receptionist have heard his remark.
How appropriate is asking Rahul why he does not consider the tasks to be fulfilling
A very inappropriate thing to do - asking him to elaborate would only make the patients feel they are not treated in a professional environment
Question 21
Luke is a second year medical student who has recently moved into a new flat with some of his colleagues. At their housewarming party, Luke notices Sam - one of his flatmates - and some other friends appearing to take drugs. Luke cannot be sure as he has had some alcohol and it is quite dark at the party. Luke knows that this is something that they are specifically warned against by the university, as well as it being illegal. Luke is concerned about the implications on his own career if this were to be found out.
a) How appropriate is telling Sam that I need you and your friends to leave immediately?
Inappropriate, but not awful - it can stop sam and get him and drugs out of the flat. However, it doesn’t give Sam a chance to explain himself or make amends for the mistake he has made.
b) How appropriate is telling Sam that ‘it’s illegal, I am phoning the police’
A very inappropriate thing to do - the police will become involved eventually since Sam is possibly taking illegal drugs
c) How appropriate is telling Sam ‘Sam, you need to stop. Do you realise that you could be putting your career and mine at risk?’
A very appropriate thing to do - By telling Sam to stop and highlighting the risks to both of their careers, Luke is acting firmly and directly in the moment to protect patient safety and professional standards.
Question 22
Dr Green is working in a busy city hospital and is rushed off his feet with many patients to see that day. James is a medical student who is shadowing Dr Green and is currently with Dr Green on a ward round. Dr Green sees a patient, Mrs McMillan, who is complaining of stomach pains. Dr Green prescribes medication to help Mrs McMillan and informs one of the nurses to begin administering it immediately. When Dr Green writes this in the patient's notes, James notices that Dr Green has written down a different drug than the one that he had prescribed.
a) How appropriate is informing Dr Green while they are still on the ward round that he has made a mistake in the situation?
Appropriate, but not ideal - it would be more appropriate to say that he noticed that the name of the medication he prescribed and the one he wrote down were difference.
b) How appropriate is informing one of the nurses of Dr Green’s mistake and tell them to change it
A very inappropriate thing to do - changing the prescription in the patient’s notes without the permission of Dr Green or w/o discussing it with him would be very inappropriate - rmb your authority !
c) How appropriate is reporting Dr Green’s mistake to the head consultant on that ward
a very inappropriate thing to do - x confrontation when it could be easily resolved immediately and it’s not even certain a mistake has been made.
Question 23
Two medical students, Shawn and Laura, are on the wards at their local teaching hospital looking for patients to examine. This is for their learning, to get them used to examining patients and recognising pathologies. One of the consultants suggests that they go to see a patient, Mr Jones, who has a heart murmur. The consultant tells the students to listen to the murmur for their education. When Shawn and Laura approach Mr Jones' bedside, he starts getting agitated and tells them he is sick of students coming to him.
a) How appropriate is telling that the consultant has asked them to see him
Appropriate, but not ideal - Although it might make Mr Jones more willing to be examined if it’s a request of the consultant, this response is unlikely to defuse the situation immediately. Ideally, they will apologise for the situation, spend more time listening to him and explain how grateful they are for the learning opportunities.
b) How appropriate is reassuring Mr Jones that they will not take much of his time
Inappropriate, but not awful - doesn’t try to defuse Mr Jones’ agitation and their assumption that they will be going ahead with the examination. it is not awful as they are trying to reassure Mr Jones although ineffectively.
Question 24
Ryan is a first-year medical student who is currently two weeks away from his end of year exams. Whilst revising in the library one afternoon, Ryan notices that one of his friends, Sarah, is distressed and anxious. Ryan thinks that this is due to the upcoming exams but is unsure. Sarah is clearly upset and unable to focus and carry out her revision effectively.
How appropriate is talking to Sarah’s friends to see if they know the reason for her distress?
Inappropriate, but not awful - it may be seen as gossiping even though talking to her would simply further upset her and he wants to know why . It is better to speak to Sarah directly instead of getting more people involved.
How appropriate is making an appointment for Sarah with the counselling team at the university first?
A very inappropriate thing to do - Ryan must not be do anything w/o discussing with her first. It is not his place to do so. He should try to talk to her first.
Question 25
Kemal is a third-year dental student who has been assigned as group leader by his tutor Dr Peters for a research project on oral health promotion. The group consists of five students who must work together over the next month to produce a presentation and written report. As Kemal opens their first meeting by introducing the project timeline, Sienna, one of the group members, interrupts and suggests that they should discuss leadership roles and vote on who should lead the group rather than having someone imposed on them. The other group members look uncertain about how to respond.
a) How appropriate is saying ‘Perhaps we can discuss this with Dr Peters and see if the group structure can be changed’ ?
Inappropriate, but not awful - undermines the tutor’s arrangements. However it does show some attempt to find a collaborative solution.
b) How appropriate is ‘I am happy to hear everyone’s thoughts about how we should organise the timeline for our project ?’
Appropriate, but not ideal - it demonstrates a collaborative and open approach, inviting the group to contribute to the project planning rather than proceeding unilaterally. However, it is not the most appropriate as it does not directly address Sienna’s challenge to his leadership role, which is assigned by his tutor.
Question 25
Jasmine is a third-year medical student who receives a phone call from Ms Roberts, the head teacher at her former secondary school. Ms Roberts explains that they are organising a careers week and would like Jasmine to give a presentation about her medical school experiences to inspire students who are considering applying for medicine. Ms Roberts mentions that several current students have specifically asked about hearing from someone who attended their school. Jasmine has always been nervous about public speaking and feels anxious at the thought of presenting to a large group.
How appropriate is ‘I’d like to help in other ways but I’m really not comfortable with public speaking at this stage’
Inappropriate, but now awful - As a future healthcare professionals, students need to find ways of managing tasks they find uncomfortable rather than simply declining them, By missing public speaking opportunity, Jasmine misses a chance to develop important professional skills.
How appropriate is saying ‘I’d be delighted to come and speak to the students about my medical school journey’
A very appropriate thing to say - embraces the professional obligation to support aspiring medical students despite personal discomfort
Question 26
Saheem and Rachel, two medical students on placement, have been assigned to check on patients on a hospital ward. One of the patients, Mr Thompson, has dementia and repeatedly asks the same question about when his family will visit. Rachel becomes visibly annoyed by this questioning and starts to ignore Mr Thompson's inquiries, which confuses Mr Thompson further.
How appropriate is asking Rachel if she needs a break before they see the next patient
Appropriate, but not ideal - shows concern for Rachel’s wellbeing and recognises that stress or fatigue might be contributing to her inappropriate behaviour. However, this approach is not ideal as it does not directly address Rachel’s unprofessional conduct
Question 27
Dan is a junior doctor at a busy GP surgery. One afternoon, a patient, Mr Johnson, arrives for a scheduled appointment. Mr Johnson is known for being confrontational and has a history of expressing dissatisfaction with previous medical advice. Today, Mr Johnson is visibly upset and raises his voice in the waiting area, insisting that his pain has not been adequately addressed and demanding stronger medication. As Dan approaches him to discuss his concerns, several other patients are watching the interaction, and Mr Johnson continues to get agitated.
How appropriate is telling the patient that stronger medication may not be the solution and that he cannot prescribe medications based solely on patient demands?
A very inappropriate thing to do - challenges directly patient’s expectations in a confrontational manner that is likely to escalate the situation further. addressing this in front of other patients lacks sensitivity and professionalism.
Question 28
Zihan, a final-year medical student who has just finished his exams, has a summer trip booked with friends before receiving his results. During the flight to his destination, a flight attendant urgently asks if there is a doctor on board. No one responds to the request, and given the small size of the plane, it is unlikely that any of the passengers did not hear the announcement. Zihan is apprehensive about stepping forward as he has not yet graduated from medicine.
How appropriate is asking the flight attendant to call for any healthcare professional on board to help, not just a doctor?
Inappropriate, but not awful - introduces a delay when an urgent medical assistance is needed and no qualified doctor has responded. However it’s not awful as it demonstrates awareness that other healthcare professionals might be qualified to help and shows some intiative in trying to find appropriate assistance.
Question 29
Anna is a junior doctor working at a GP practice. Morning clinic at the practice is extremely busy today and there are many patients waiting to be seen. Whilst checking some patient information at reception, Anna is approached by Mr Johnson, an elderly patient who she has treated several times before. Mr Johnson expresses frustration at the long waiting time and asks Anna for a repeat prescription. Anna's next scheduled appointment, which is not with Mr Johnson, is due to begin very shortly.
a) How appropriate is asking Mr Johnson how long he has been waiting
Appropriate, but not ideal - shows Mr Johnson’s frustration and demonstrates that Anna is listening to his concerns about the waiting time. It is not ideal, however, as it does not address his address his actual request for a prescription
b) How appropriate is delaying her next appointment by a few minutes to quickly assess the patient’s request
Inappropriate, but not awful - not awful as Anna’s motivation is patient-centred
Question 30
Timo is a dental student on a clinic placement. One morning at work, he notices a fellow student, Evie, falsifying her patient encounter logs to meet the required number of cases to pass her class. When Timo challenges Evie about the falsification, Evie fails to acknowledge that her actions are unprofessional. She then suggests that Timo should falsify evidence too as 'nobody ever finds out'.
How appropriate is refusing to follow Evie’s suggestion and tell her he does not want to discuss the matter further?
Appropriate, but not ideal - makes Timo’s position clear and ensure he does not become complicit in Evie’s misconduct . It is not the most appropriate response as it misses an opportunity to encourage Evie to reflect on her actions
Question 31
Aisha is a dental student in her final year. Over the past few weeks, Aisha's fellow student Connor has noticed that Aisha appears increasingly stressed and overwhelmed. She has been arriving late to lectures, seems withdrawn during group discussions and mentioned to Connor privately that she has been struggling to sleep. During a break between classes, Connor approaches Aisha to check how she is coping. Aisha admits that she feels completely swamped by her workload and upcoming exams and confides that she has been having panic attacks but does not want to seek help because she fears this might affect her chances of graduating.
How appropriate is saying ‘I’m really concerned about you. Have you thought about taking some time off to focus on your mental health?
Inappropriate, but not awful - even though it shows genuine concern for Aisha’s wellbeing and acknowledges the seriousness oof her situation, this strategy would be counterproductive as it might reinforce her fears about the impact on her graduation
Question 32
Aisha is a dental student in her final year. Over the past few weeks, Aisha's fellow student Connor has noticed that Aisha appears increasingly stressed and overwhelmed. She has been arriving late to lectures, seems withdrawn during group discussions and mentioned to Connor privately that she has been struggling to sleep. During a break between classes, Connor approaches Aisha to check how she is coping. Aisha admits that she feels completely swamped by her workload and upcoming exams and confides that she has been having panic attacks but does not want to seek help because she fears this might affect her chances of graduating.
a) How important is it to take into account that the picture is poor quality, with only a few details legible when deciding how to respond to the situation?
Of minor importance - not entirely irrelevant as Giovanni would need to consider the scope of the breach
b) How important is it to take into account that the photo has already been sent when deciding how to respond to the situation?
Of minor importance - it confirms the fact that the photo has been sent so unauthorised disclosure has occured, however it is important now to address the patient confidentiality violations regardless of the status
Question 33
Trisha is a junior doctor working in a clinic providing vaccinations to children. She is about to vaccinate 5-year-old Tommy, when he suddenly begins to cry violently and runs away from Trisha. His mother looks embarrassed and urges Trisha to 'just hold him and get it over with'. Tommy becomes increasingly distressed by the situation and is hiding behind his mother.
a) How important to take into account that the mother appears embarrassed when deciding how to respond to the situation?
Not important at all - it ignores the duty to act in Tommy’s best interests rather than simply comply with parental pressure.
b) How important is it to take into account whether the appointment can be rescheduled when deciding how to respond to the situation?
Of minor importance- rescheduling might provide time for alternative approaches or better preparation. However, this does not directly resolve the ethical dilemma of responding to the mother’s request for restrait, nor does it provide a solution for Tommy’s anxiety
Question 34
Marcello and Kira, medical students on placement on a hospital ward, have been paired together to assist with patient rounds. Prior to their first patient interaction, Kira explains to Marcello that she experiences communication challenges that can cause her to miss non-verbal communication cues. She informs Marcello that these have already been disclosed to the medical school. Throughout the day, Marcello notices that Kira's manner of communication between patients can sometimes come across as abrupt. Later in the afternoon, a patient approaches Marcello stating that he found Kira's behaviour to be rude. Now, the two are preparing to attend a debrief with the ward manager to review their performance for the day.
How important is the fact that Kira’s communication challenges have already been disclosed to the medical school when deciding how to respond to the situation?
Important - Knowing that medical school have practices in place helps Marcello recognize there are people better placed than him to manage the broader implications of Kira’s communication style. However, this is not the important as it doesn’t resolve the concern raised by patients
Question 35
Maliha, a first-year dental student, has recently submitted an essay and is now completing a peer review of another student's essay as part of the course feedback process. The peer-reviewed mark that essays receive will be combined with the mark given to each essay by an academic supervisor in order to reach a final grade. Although intended to be anonymous, Maliha recognises the handwriting of the essay as belonging to one of her close friends. Although well researched, the essay is confusingly structured and does not quite reach the requirements for an above-average mark. Maliha knows that her friend put a lot of time and effort into the essay.
How important is it to take into account that her friend will benefit from becoming comfortable with receiving constructive criticism when deciding how to respond to the situation?
Important - not the most important as Maliha should conform to the guidelines and mark the essay honestly even if this was not the case
Question 36
Marc is a junior doctor reviewing the status of a patient scheduled for minor surgery under general anaesthetic, as recommended by the consultant. During this pre-operative check, the patient expresses concern to Marc about the risks of general anaesthetic and asks if the surgery can be done with local anaesthetic instead. Marc explains that as the operation had already been consented to, the anaesthetic would not be able to be changed without first discussing this with the consultant who is currently preparing for surgery. The patient is insistent that the procedure should be performed under local anaesthetic.
a) How important is it to take into account that interrupting the consultant at this time could cause a delay in the patient’s surgery?
Of minor importance- a disruption to the patient’s care may influence their decision
b) How important is it to take into account the impact of a different anaesthetic on how well the surgery can be performed
Important - this factor may be useful to mention to the patient but is not critical as the primary concern is ensuring appropriate expert consultation rather than Marc providing specific clinical details
Question 37
Prentice is a junior doctor working in a GP practice. Over the past month, he has faced a heavier than usual workload due to the absence of his senior colleague, Dr Barlow, who has been on leave for personal reasons. Dr Barlow has recently returned to work; however, Prentice is concerned about several errors that Dr Barlow has made in recent days, such as prescribing penicillin to a patient who is allergic to it. Although there were no serious consequences for the patient, several other staff members have also expressed concern about Dr Barlow performance. However, no one has acted on their concerns up until this point.
How important is to take account that the wrong prescribed penicillin was corrected before the patient received treatment when deciding how to respond to the situation ?
of minor importance- still a bit relevant as it shows immediate harm was prevented
Question 38
Georgina is a final year medical student assigned to a clinical placement at an outpatient centre. During her placement, she builds a good rapport with Leon, a patient who has visited the clinic several times for ongoing treatment relating to his medical condition. At the end of their latest appointment, Leon asks Georgina if she is free to meet him one afternoon for a coffee; he tells her that he feels more comfortable talking to her about his treatments and trusts her more than his doctors.
a) How important is to take into account that Georgina suspects Leon feels more comfortable discussing his treatment with her because they are similar in age
Of minor importance- age similarities should never determine the appropriateness of professional boundaries and ethical obligations remain constant regardless of age demographics
b) How important is to take into account that Georgina is nearing the end of her clinical placement and will have left the clinic by the following week
Not important at all - professional boundary obligations remain constant regardless of contact duration
Question 39
Ravi is a dental student preparing for an important written examination. Two days before the exam, his flatmate Ola, who is also a dental student in the same year, approaches him with what appears to be a copy of the actual examination paper. Ola explains that she obtained it from a friend who works in the administrative office and suggests they should study from it together to ensure they both pass. Ola argues that since the exam is so important for their progression, and many students are struggling with the material, using the paper would just be "levelling the playing field."
How appropriate is Ravi saying "I understand you're worried about the exam but using that paper would be cheating and could get us both expelled."?
Appropriate, but not ideal- it focuses primarily on the risk of punishment rather than the fundamental ethical problems with cheating
Question 40
Elena is a final-year medical student finishing her evening shift on the elderly care ward. As she walks to he car in the hospital car park, she encounters Mrs Thompson, whose father has been a patient on the ward fo the past week. Elena has been involved in Mr Thompson's daily care and has spoken with Mrs Thompson several times during visiting hours. Mrs Thompson approaches Elena and thanks her for the excellent care she has provided. She then asks if she could have Elena's personal mobile number, explaining that she migh need to contact her directly for updates about her father's condition, especially outside of normal visiting hours.
How appropriate is saying "I could get into trouble if I give out my personal number but the nurses on the ward can always help you."
Inappropriate, but not awful - it fails to inform Mrs Thompson about why these boundaries exist. It is not awfula s it does direct her to an appropriate channel for information.
Question 41
Hamish, a medical student on placement at a GP clinic, is receiving feedback from Dr Chaudhry after a shift. Dr Chaudhry begins by praising Hamish's enthusiastic approach to patient interaction. She also explains that during an earlier patient consultation with Mrs Swain, who was receiving some blood test results, Hamish's explanation of the findings was slightly unclear. Dr Chaudhry recalls Mrs Swain's initial confusion - which the doctor quickly clarified - and suggests Hamish practise simplifying complex medical information for patients to ensure their better understanding. Hamish, however, is struggling to identify this moment of confusion and feels that perhaps Dr Chaudhry's intervention at the time was unneeded.
How appropriate is suggesting gently that Dr Chaudhry’s feedback on his patient interaction skills is somewhat contradictory ?
A very inappropriate thing to do - suggestive of being dismissive of her guidance and undermines the professional development process
Question 42
Ravi and Sophie are final-year dental students completing their community dental placement. At the end of their placement they are required to fill out detailed evaluation questionnaires about their learning experiences, clinical skills development and feedback on the placement quality. Sophie finishes her questionnaire within five minutes, whilst Ravi is still working through his responses carefully after fifteen minutes. Sophie asks Ravi why he is taking so long with what she describes as 'just a simple form.'
a) How appropriate is Ravi saying ‘I want to make sure I give thoughtful responses that will be helpful for future students’ ?
A very appropriate thing to do - it explains Ravi’s thorough approach whilst highlighting the constructive purpose of providing thoughtful feedback for future students.
b) How appropriate is saying ‘I prefer to reflect carefully on my experiences before giving feedback
Inappropriate, but not awful - it could be perceived as implying Sophie did not reflect carefully on her experiences, potentially creating tension by suggesting her quick completion was unreflective. However, it’s not awful as it does demonstrate Ravi’s thoughtful approach to feedback.
c) How appropriate is Ravi saying ‘I think it’s important to take time with these evaluations to give proper feedback’.
Appropriate, but not ideal - it is not ideal as it could be interpreted as an indirect criticism of Sophie’s quick completion, potentially creating tension between colleagues.
Question 43
Priya is a third-year medical student on a general medicine ward. During a morning ward round, she notices that Mr Thompson, an elderly patient who appears confused and agitated, has a damp sheet and seems uncomfortable. The consultant leading the ward round is discussing Mr Thompson's case in front of his bed while several medical students, junior doctors, and nursing staff are gathered around. Mr Thompson seems distressed and is trying to cover himself with his bedsheet. Priya can see that Mr Thompson is becoming increasingly upset as the discussion continues.
a) How appropriate is Priya saying ‘ I think Mr Thomspon might be benefit from having fewer people around his bed right now?
Inappropriate, but not awful- it offers a vague suggestion without providing a constructive solution to address Mr Thompson’s immediate needs or the ongoing clinical discussion. However, it’s not awful as it does show some awareness that the patient might be overwhelmed by the crowd around the bed
b) How appropriate is Priya saying ‘Mr Thompson you seem uncomfortable, let’s get you cleaned up first’
Appropriate, but not ideal - it shows compassion and directly addresses Mr Thompson’s immediate care needs. However, it is not ideal as professional relationship should be taken into consideration, Priya should not interrupt the consultant discussion.
c) How appropriate is Priya saying ‘Perhaps we could discuss Mr Thompson’s case in a consultation room to give him some privacy’
A very appropriate thing to do - directly addresses key problem + maintains clinical discussion
Question 44
Jemma is a junior doctor working on a busy hospital ward. Due to staff sickness, she is the only doctor on shift, although she is being aided by a senior nurse and there is a consultant on-call at home. A patient is admitted to the ward requesting prescription strength pain medication. Jemma suspects the patient is using the medication for recreational use due to their known history of drug misuse. The patient is refusing to accept any other form of pain relief.
How appropriate is Jemma saying ‘keeping the patient comfortable until a more experienced doctor is available to review the patient’s history’?
Inappropriate, but not awful - delays the necessary clinical decision-making when Jemma is the responsible doctor on duty. It is not awful as it acknowledges the complexity of the situation and
Question 45
Vikram is a medical student on placement who has been asked to administer sutures to a patient. Vikram has been signed off to undertake this task and feels confident in his ability to perform it. However, the patient declines to consent to Vikram's involvement, stating that she underwent the same procedure by a student years ago, only for the student to lack expertise and cause him distress.
a) How appropriate is Vikram telling the patient he will look for a doctor to carry out the procedure instead?
A very appropriate thing to do - respects the patient’s autonomy and right to refuse treatment from a medical student.
b) How appropriate is asking the patient for more information about his previous experience
Appropriate, but not ideal - shows empathy for the patient’s concern and attempts to understand the source of her reluctance. However, x ideal as it doesn’t directly address arranging alternative care for her and delay finding a solution.
Question 46
Liam is a junior doctor working on a busy accident and emergency ward. Due to staff shortages, he is the only doctor available to attend to medical emergencies as the remaining doctors are busy handling other urgent cases. During his shift, two patients arrive almost simultaneously, both needing urgent care. One is Mrs Gwen, an elderly woman who arrives alone via an ambulance, the other Mr Carter who has been brought in by his daughter.
How appropriate is allocation the patients to adjacent bays so he can alternate between the two patients?
Inappropriate, but not awful - not awful as it does offer a basic level of monitoring and allows Liam to respond quickly to any sudden deterioration in either case.
Question 47
Caleb, a dental student on placement, is assisting Dr Platt during a routine examination of a patient. When Dr Platt asks Caleb to use the dental probe to check for cavities, Caleb carefully begins the examination technique he has been taught. After observing Caleb for a short time, Dr Platt turns to him and says, 'That's not quite right Caleb, you need to apply more pressure to ensure a thorough examination.' The patient looks slightly concerned and glances between them. Caleb notices the patient observing the exchange and feels self-conscious about the feedback.
a) How appropriate is mentioning to the patient that different dentists sometimes have different approaches to examinations?
Inappropriate, but not awful - not awful as it attempts to address the patient’s concern
b) How appropriate is Caleb asking the patient to let him know if Dr Platt’s suggested pressure feels too firm for them?
A very inappropriate thing to do - inappropriately involves the patient in mediating between student and supervisor, putting them in an uncomfortable position to judge clinical techniques. Undermines the professional authority of Dr Platt.
Question 48
Ayesha is a medical student conducting patient interviews with her placement partner John. After talking to most of their allocated patients together, John tells Ayesha that he is too exhausted to speak to any more patients and that he plans to go home early, citing ill health. Students are not permitted to interview patients alone and earlier their consultant communicated to them that he expects the pair to interview all their allocated patients today.
a) How appropriate is reminding John that the consultant told them the task was to be completed today?
Inappropriate, but not awful - prioritises adherence to deadlines over showing concern for John’s reported illness or exploring solutions that address his health needs and their professional obligations.
b) How appropriate is offering to do all the work in the remaining interviews if John agrees to stay?
A very inappropriate thing to do - creates an unfair academic arrangement where Ayesha takes on the entire workload and enables John to avoid his responsibilities without addressing his health concerns properly.
Question 49
Kamal, a junior doctor working on a hospital ward, is nearing the end of a particularly busy shift. Kamal is feeling rather tired and is looking forward to a relaxing evening at home. He has just prepared the discharge letter for a patient who is going home shortly and has included in the medication list the frequency with which the patient should take her newly prescribed medication. However, after handing the patient a copy of the letter and entering the staff changing room to get ready to leave, Kamal begins to doubt whether he wrote 'once a day' - which would be correct -or 'twice a day' in the medication list. The patient is waiting to be picked up by a relative and has not yet left the building.
How appropriate is explaining to the patient he is tired and may have made an error in her discharge letter?
Inappropriate, but not awful - it unnecessarily alarams the patient by sharing his uncertainty and tiredness rather than simply checking the documentation professionally.
Question 50
Vaishnavi is a medical student on placement in a maternity ward. She is assisting with routine post-natal check-ups under the supervision of a qualified midwife. When Vaishnavi approaches a new mother to help with breastfeeding guidance, the patient comments on how young she looks and then asks whether Vaishnavi has children of her own. When Vaishnavi responds that she doesn't, the patient expresses concern about receiving advice from someone who hasn't yet experienced motherhood herself.
How appropriate is explaining that making judgements about competence based on age is a form of prejudice?
A very inappropriate thing to do - directly accuses the patient of prejudice and creates a confrontational dynamic that could seriously damage the therapeutic relationship.