Weinberg6E_PP_chap06 - Tagged

Chapter 6: Feedback, Reinforcement, and Intrinsic Motivation

Session Outline

  • Understanding Feedback and Reinforcement

  • Principles of Reinforcement

  • Approaches to Influencing Behavior

  • Positive Reinforcement Principles

  • Punishment Guidelines

  • Modifying Behavior in Sport

  • Intrinsic Motivation and Extrinsic Rewards

  • Cognitive Evaluation Theory

  • Impact of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation

  • Methods to Increase Intrinsic Motivation

  • Flow

  • Definition and Elements of Flow

  • Factors Affecting Flow

Understanding Feedback and Reinforcement

  • Reinforcement: This involves the strategic use of rewards and punishment to influence behavior in a desired direction. Positive reinforcement increases the likelihood that a behavior will be repeated by offering a rewarding stimulus after the desired action is taken. In contrast, punishment is aimed at reducing the occurrence of undesirable behaviors by introducing negative consequences.

Principles of Reinforcement

  • Positive outcomes (good consequences) lead to a higher likelihood of behavior repetition, while negative outcomes (unpleasant consequences) discourage repetitions. In addition to this, the reaction to reinforcement varies among individuals; different people may respond differently to similar rewards or punishments, leading to complex behavior patterns that can vary widely within a sport or activity.

Approaches to Influencing Behavior

  • Positive Approach: This approach emphasizes rewarding individuals for desirable behaviors, thereby encouraging the repetition of such behaviors.

  • Negative Approach: This method focuses on punishing undesirable behaviors to redirect actions towards more acceptable alternatives.

  • Most coaches blend both strategies. However, they typically emphasize positive reinforcement to maintain a supportive and fear-free environment which helps in fostering better performance.

TARGET Approach to a Positive Climate

  • Coaches can create a mastery-oriented environment by applying the TARGET principles, which stand for:

    • Tasks: Design tasks that are challenging yet attainable.

    • Authority: Allow participants to have a voice in decision-making processes related to the sport.

    • Rewards: Use rewards effectively to motivate and reinforce desired behavior.

    • Grouping: Encourage cooperative learning through strategic group formations.

    • Evaluation: Focus on personal improvement rather than solely on competitive outcomes.

    • Timing: Implement timely interventions that maximize learning and performance.

Principles of Positive Reinforcement

  • Effective reinforcers can be social (praise), material (trophies), or emotional (feelings of accomplishment).

  • The timing of reinforcement is crucial: continuous reinforcement is most effective when skills are newly learned, while intermittent reinforcement better sustains motivation after a skill has been acquired.

  • It is important to reward not just outcomes, but also effort, performance, and emotional skills to promote a holistic improvement in athletes.

Providing Effective Feedback

  • Important types of feedback include knowledge of results, sincere motivational comments, and using varied methods such as verbal communication and non-verbal cues (e.g., facial expressions). This multi-dimensional approach helps athletes understand their performance more thoroughly.

What Not to Do in Motivation

  • Coaches should avoid sarcasm, harsh criticism, physical abuse, and guilt-based motivational techniques as these can damage relationships and create a toxic learning environment.

Understanding Punishment

  • While punishment can influence behavior, it is essential for positive reinforcement to dominate the feedback process (ideally comprising 80-90% of interactions).

  • Although punishment can deter negative behaviors, it may instill fear and cultivate a counterproductive learning atmosphere if not handled appropriately.

Guidelines for Using Punishment

  • It is critical to ensure consistency and focus on the person's actions rather than labeling them negatively.

  • Coaches should avoid using physical activity as a punishment and keep the consequences impersonal, framing them as learning opportunities.

  • Additionally, punishments should not be applied for mistakes, as this may inhibit learning and exploration.

Modifying Behavior in Sport

  • Behavior modification involves applying reinforcement principles in a systematic way to cultivate desired behaviors. Techniques can include structured feedback systems, specific coaching methods, and proactively addressing inappropriate behaviors to mold positive athlete development.

Intrinsic Motivation

  • Intrinsically motivated individuals derive satisfaction from the pursuit of personal mastery, relish competitive experiences, and are driven by the challenge of skill acquisition rather than external rewards.

Factors Influencing Intrinsic Motivation

  • Significant social factors influencing intrinsic motivation include athletes' experiences of success, focus on competition, and the behavior exhibited by coaches.

  • Key psychological factors consist of feelings of autonomy and competence, where athletes feel in control of their actions and capable of achieving their goals.

Cognitive Evaluation Theory

  • This theory examines how external rewards can affect intrinsic motivation. It posits that controlling rewards may diminish intrinsic motivation, while rewards that are informational and affirming can enhance it. Understanding this balance is crucial for coaches in reward strategies.

Increasing Intrinsic Motivation

  • Strategies for increasing intrinsic motivation emphasize creating environments where athletes can experience success, using contingent rewards effectively, and allowing participants to have a say in decisions regarding practice or competition, thus fostering ownership of their training.

Flow and Intrinsic Motivation

  • Flow is characterized as an immersive experience where individuals feel completely engaged in an activity, achieving a state of optimal performance.

  • Key elements comprise a balance between challenge and skill, total concentration, and clearly defined goals.

Factors Facilitating or Disrupting Flow

  • Preparation, self-confidence, positive team interactions, and heightened situational awareness can enhance flow, while distractions and lack of preparation can derail it.

Negative Aspects of Flow

  • While flow experiences are generally beneficial, over-reliance on activities associated with flow can lead to addictive behaviors. This has been observed in some athletes who become dependent on the exhilarating aspects of high-performance environments, thus creating potential issues for their overall health and balance.