W1, L2
Institutions of the New Zealand Executive
The Crown: A complicated and controversial concept representing the state as a body corporate.
The Dignified Executive: Refers to the ceremonial and formal aspects of the branch (Monarch and Governor-General).
The Political Executive: Often called the "engine room" where ministerial power resides. It includes the Prime Minister, high-profile ministers, and Cabinet.
The Administrative Executive: The machinery that delivers public policy daily, including the Public Service, State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs), and Crown Entities.
Local Government: District and City Councils are formally part of the executive branch as they execute public power through statutory authority.
Local Government and Statutory Basis
Legal Status: Local governments are part of the executive because they derive their power from Statute (legislation passed by Parliament) rather than a constitution.
Comparison to the United States:
In the US model (a federal system), states get their authority from the US Constitution, not from Congress.
Other regional/federal models mentioned include Germany, Spain, and Belgium.
Authority in New Zealand:
Police derive power from the Police Powers Act.
Local governments derive power from the Local Government Act and various other acts (e.g., environmental legislation).
Historical Context: New Zealand was once a form of federation with provinces, but provincial governments were abolished. Today, provinces only exist in the context of rugby teams, provincial holidays, and architecture.
Centralization: New Zealand's structure is highly centralized, making local government inferior to the national executive.
Defining 'The Crown'
Definition: The Crown is the "body corporate of the state." It is not synonymous with the monarch as an individual.
Legal Applications:
Criminal Prosecutions: Cases are titled "R versus X," where "R" represents the Crown. The Crown acts as the state prosecuting on behalf of society.
Victimhood in Criminal Law: In legal framing, the individual victim (of assault, robbery, etc.) is not the legal party to the case; the Crown is the victim because the offense is against the state/society.
Etymology and History: Unlike countries that use the term "State" (e.g., France or Germany), New Zealand retains the term "Crown" due to its constitutional history with The United Kingdom.
Republicanism: Transitioning to a republic would require New Zealand to address whether it continues to allow the executive to exercise powers currently vested in the Crown.
Practical Use: The executive exercises Crown powers in international affairs, defense, immigration, and the regulation of the judiciary.
The Dignified and Efficient Constitution
Walter Bagehot (1867): Wrote "The English Constitution" (noting that despite the title, it refers to the British constitution).
Dignified Elements: Ancient and ornamental parts of the constitution that maintain a facade of tradition. Examples include the Governor-General and the ceremonies of Parliament.
Efficient Elements: The "efficient secret" or the reality of how the government actually works. Cabinet and the Prime Minister are the efficient parts where true power resides.
Constitutional 'Advice':
Statutes often state the Governor-General has the power to appoint judges or ministers, but only upon the "advice" of ministers.
In a constitutional monarchy, the word "advice" has shifted from a suggestion to a command. The Governor-General must follow the Prime Minister's instructions.
The Governor-General's Power: Historically, a Governor-General intervened in a political process in Australia in when Gough Whitlam (Labour Prime Minister) was dismissed during a controversy over overseas loans. This intervention remains highly controversial. In modern New Zealand, such an intervention is considered almost "unthinkable."
The Executive Council
Function: A formal body that makes the majority of laws in New Zealand through Orders in Council.
Membership: Presided over by the Governor-General; all Ministers of the Crown are members. The quorum for a meeting is .
Operation: It functions as a "rubber stamp." Decisions are made in Cabinet meetings, and the Executive Council meets immediately after to formally promulgate those decisions into law.
Ministerial Warrants: This body provides ministers with their individual executive powers through warrants.
The Prime Minister
Status: The Prime Minister (currently Christopher Luxon) is the recognized head of government.
Lack of Statutory Basis: Paradoxically, the office of the Prime Minister barely exists in statute. There is no major statute that defines the office's powers.
Power through Convention: The Prime Minister's power is based on Convention rather than law.
Formal Powers: Only two formal powers are typically attributed to the Prime Minister:
The power to call an election.
The power to appoint and dismiss ministers.
Both are exercised through formal advice to the Governor-General.