Moral Development
Moral Development
Theories of Moral Development
Piaget
He says the big transition into adolescence and into formal operation is going from heteronomous morality (which is very much about rules, laws, and justice) and moving more into a sense that rules are there for a reason.
Kohlberg
There six steps
The goal is to get all the way up to level three, step six. We’re forming this in adolescence. There is no guarantee you’ll make it to the top.
Level One: Preconventional
This is before you have any sense of right or wrong, or even that this is the right way to do it. You start to notice that when you do X, people are mad at you and that sucks. So you don’t want to do X anymore because it feels gross. But if you do Y, everyone congratulates you.
Kids learn to share their toys because they are praised for sharing their toys.
Just rewards and punishment; there’s no morality tied to it. Just going with pleasure and pain.
Level Two: Conventional Level
This is very much about laws and judging.
At some point, you realize that bad stuff happens to you, and you’d really like that to stop. And you realize that if we all get together and make a set of rules, then I’m going to have to give up some of my freedom, but what I’ll gain is potentially not having these horrible things happen. Everyone agrees that we’re not going to hit each other.
This is what all countries did; they set laws so people wouldn’t get hurt. We’re saying, let’s put some ground rules down so no one gets super hurt.
You’re very much interested in justice and fairness. Kids at this age will scream out It’s not fair all the time.
Very much going to go by the letter of the law.
Level Three: Postconventional
I know you’d hurt if I hit you, and I don’t want to hurt someone.
A personal set of morals and ethics that develops.
The difference between level two and three is how you respond to a law that violates your own ethics.
Ex: If I was in level two and we had a big Holocaust event and we were being told we can’t house people who are trying to escape. That’s against the law. And someone in level two would choose not to help anyone who was trying to escape.
If you’re in level three, you might say, yeah, it’s against the law, but I don’t think it’s right because it’s personally immoral. They would choose to hide someone based on their own set of ethics.
Gilligan
Feminist author, focused on women’s morality.
Stage One
Thinking about myself: how do I survive, and how do I make the best for myself? Self-focused perspective.
Stage Two
We start to realize that we care about other people. We’re in the abstract in the sense of empathy. I care about other people, and other people are my responsibility. We start to get this morality of care.
The reason she brings it up in the context of women is that they tend to do more of this over self-sacrifice. So putting their needs below every other person. Their entire family gets taken care of, but they don’t give themselves any self-care. It comes from a place of caring and love.
Stage Three
How do I get to the point where we can both be taken care of?
I don’t have to completely sacrifice myself. Your cup will run dry if you only take care of others and not yourself.
Finding this space where all of us matter. My needs matter, and your needs matter, and we can both get our needs met here.
Focusing on nonviolence, resolving conflict. I’m going to resolve conflict not by just rolling over and letting you do whatever. But rather getting my needs met in a very nonviolent, negotiative way.
Influences of Moral Development
Interpersonal
Interacting with other people helps me develop morality.
Social Domain perspective (Smetana, 1997)
Convention- parents only, context-dependent
There are three big categories of things that you’re learning:
Preference
And there is zero morality to this. It’s your preference what you like and prefer.
Moral Imperative
This is good or bad. Evil or good.
At the core, right or wrong.
Most of us get to the point where hurting other people doesn’t feel good. We have that value system that treating someone like trash isn’t good.
Convention
The behavior itself isn’t immoral or moral, but there are certain times and places you should do it.
Running around. Running around at home is fine, but running in the classroom isn’t the right time and place.
We get a lot of feedback about the moral imperative stuff from peers and parents.
You’re going to get conventionalism from parents, teachers, and other authority figures.
Everyone is giving you this idea of right and wrong.
Socialization/ Internalization
Moral Emotions
Help children identify as a moral individual.
I’m going to start by getting messages from other people, and eventually I’ll internalize that. It starts with my parents teaching me this.
Ex: I’m five, and I punch someone in the face. I’m not going to figure out that this is bad on my own. There are a couple of things that are going to clue me in. I’m going to see that my victim is going to be very upset. My parents might get really mad at me. Either one of those things might make me feel uncomfortable. These emotions that pop up make me think that something is wrong. At first, this isn’t linked to the moral emotions. Gradual process of getting it.
Sources
Parents, Peers, Media, Culture, Religion
You’re getting these ideas of what is moral and what is not. From all kinds of sources.
You might get mixed messages.
Intrapersonal
Guilt, Shame, Empathy, Sympathy
What helps inside of me.
These emotions are particularly motivating. If we feel empathy or sympathy, it allows us to behave in accordance with another human being. I might give them grace, my stuff, attention.
It’s going to motivate me to behave in an altruistic way.
Guilt and shame are going to be inhibitory. I don’t like that feeling, and I don’t want to feel that way again, so how can I fix it?
Moral Reasoning
Moral Reasoning in Adolescence
Transistioning away from parents as the sole source of what’s moral or not. You’re starting to take in your peers.
There is a lot of things that are impacting you descisions on morality at this age too. If you lived in a particularly tramatic upbringing that’s going to have a big influence.
Parents who are authoritarian vs. authoritative.
Authoritarian parents teach that these are the rules, and people in authority are right.
Authotitative parents explain the rules and why the rules exist. Working through explaining what they are learning and being very calm and fair and kind.
Morality and Abstract Thinking Exapands
Sees “Gray Areas” more readily
Understanding that things are sometimes just in the middle or complicated.
Not always knwoing what to do because both options make you feel gross.
Develops more personal set of ethics
Question absolute authority.
This is mediated a lot by the parenting style you experienced. You start to figure that your parents are humans and they’re not right about everything because they don’t know everythig.
Dilemma: Morality of Justice vs Morality of Care
Gendee Differences
When we talk about differences we’re taking about averages.
Women are a little bit more likely to have the ethics of care and men tend to a little bit more of the ethics of rights. The variationwithin these two groups is huge.
We are going to see people on all points on the scale.
The very cool headed processing. It’s what’s correct and what’s right. You’re going to try to apply logic and reasoning to your decisions.
You’ll realize that not everything is so universal.
Moral judgement is contaxtual.
You start to get a sense of others, you’re not just thinking about what’s the rules.
My is goal to further relationships in a way that I think will be beneficial. I want to self sacrifice potentially and I need to make sure that everyone is happy and getting along.
You need a leader who is very much about logsitics and very much in charge. And then you need a leader who is paying attention to emotions. In every context you need both of these.