EC4101 - Topic 9: Perfect Competition

Learning Objectives

  • Understanding Perfect Competition:

    • Define what a perfectly competitive market is.

    • Identify the characteristics of a perfectly competitive industry.

  • Profit Maximisation:

    • Learn how a price-taking producer determines its profit-maximising quantity of output.

  • Profit Assessment:

    • Assess whether a producer is profitable and understand why an unprofitable producer might continue operation in the short run.

  • Industry Behavior over Time:

    • Explore why industries behave differently in the short run versus the long run.

  • Industry Supply Curve Determinants:

    • Examine what determines the industry supply curve in both the short run and long run.

Characteristics of Perfect Competition

  1. Many Buyers and Sellers:

    • Numerous participants with small market shares where individuals cannot influence the market price.

    • Market Share: The fraction of total industry output accounted for by a producer's output.

    • Each participant's actions are likened to "a drop in the bucket."

  2. Standardised Product:

    • Products are largely the same across sellers.

    • Standardised Good: Consumers perceive different sellers' products as identical, referred to as homogeneous goods.

  3. Free Entry and Exit:

    • Producers can easily enter or exit the industry without significant barriers.

  4. Firms as Price Takers:

    • No single firm can influence the market price; they sell as much as they want at market price.

  5. Perfect Information:

    • High levels of information are available for buyers and sellers in the market.

Production and Profits

  • Firms in perfect competition are price-takers;

    • Total Revenue (TR): Calculated as the product of price and quantity sold, given by the equation:
      TR=PimesQTR = P imes Q

    • Profit (Profit): Defined as total revenue minus total cost, given by the equation:
      Profit=TRTCProfit = TR - TC

Profit Maximising Level of Output

  • Economic Profit:

    • It includes implicit costs; a zero economic profit is typical for firms.

    • Conditions for profit:

      • If TR > TC, the firm is profitable.

      • If TR=TCTR = TC, the firm breaks even.

      • If TR < TC, the firm incurs a loss.

Economic vs. Accounting Profit

  • Economic Profit:

    • Determined as total revenue minus total cost (including both explicit and implicit costs).

  • Accounting Profit:

    • Calculated as total revenue minus only explicit costs.

    • Often, economic profit is less than accounting profit because of implicit costs.

Marginal Revenue and Optimal Output

  • Marginal Revenue (MR):

    • Defined as the change in total revenue generated by an additional unit of output.

    • Mathematically expressed as:
      MR=racΔTRΔQMR = rac{ΔTR}{ΔQ}

    • For price-taking firms, MR equals the market price of goods.

  • Optimal Output Level:

    • Profit maximised when the marginal revenue of the last unit equals its marginal cost.

Profit Maximisation Condition
  • Why MR = MC?

    • Each additional unit produces extra costs and revenues.

    • If the marginal revenue is greater than marginal cost, producing that unit increases profit.

    • If MR > MC, greater production adds to profit; if MR < MC, reducing output raises profit.

    • Profit-maximising rule for competitive firms states:
      P=MCP = MC.

Short Run vs Long Run

  • Short Run:

    • Fixed plant size; focuses on short-run profit maximisation at a defined plant size.

  • Profit Maximisation Example:

    • At a given price of €18, maximum profit occurs at output quantity Q = 50, where marginal cost equals marginal revenue.

Cost Calculation and Profit

  • Profit Calculation:

    • Given by the formula:
      Profit=TRTC=rac(TRQracTCQ)imesQProfit = TR - TC = rac{(TR}{Q} - rac{TC}{Q}) imes Q

    • Alternatively:
      Profit=(PATC)imesQProfit = (P - ATC) imes Q

  • Break-Even Price:

    • For price-taking firms, the price is at the break-even point where economic profit is zero.

Profitability and Market Price

  • Analysis of break-even situations:

    • If prices cover average total costs (ATC), such as if P > min ATC of €14, a firm is profitable.

    • Example: If market price is €18, then profit per unit is €3.60, leading to total profit calculation of €180 for Q = 50.

Loss Calculation

  • Example of a firm's loss:

    • If the market price is €10 and ATC is €14.67, per unit loss is 1014.67=4.6710 - 14.67 = -4.67; total loss = 30 × -€4.67 = -€140.

Short Run Decisions

  • Producers may remain operational at losses in the short run if they cover variable and some fixed costs.

    • Shut-down Price: Determined by minimum average variable cost.

  • Firms adjust production based on the relationship between market prices and the shut-down price, producing at any price above minimum average variable cost (AVC).

Short Run Supply Curve

  • Individual Supply Curve:

    • The MC curve above the shut-down price (minimum AVC) becomes the firm's supply curve.

Long Run Decisions

  • Firms will exit if total revenue falls below total cost.

    • Exit Condition: TR < TC, or P < ATC.

    • Entry Condition: TR > TC, or P > ATC.

Competitive Market Supply Curve

  • Short-Run Supply Curve:

    • Based on the portion of its marginal cost curve above average variable cost.

  • Long-Run Supply Curve:

    • Based on the marginal cost curve above the lowest point of its average total cost curve.

Long-Run Competitive Equilibrium

  • In long-run equilibrium, firms must achieve zero economic profit.

    • Process of entry and exit leads to price = average total cost, ensuring no incentive for firms to enter or exit the market.

    • Firms operate at efficient scale, which corresponds to the minimum point of average total cost.

Zero-Profit Equilibrium

  • Firms stay in business earning zero profit as revenue compensates owners for implicit costs and time spent on sustaining operation.

Perfect Competition Model Relevance

  • While real markets may not exemplify all characteristics of perfect competition, the model serves as a benchmark to assess real-world deviations.

  • Policy Implications:

    • Recent market liberalisation has engaged with the neoclassical ideal of perfectly competitive markets.

Summary of Key Points

  1. All producers and consumers in a perfectly competitive market act as price takers, influencing no market price.

  2. Characteristics: Large number of producers; standardised products; free entry and exit; perfect information.

  3. Producers aim for profit maximisation where MR = MC; for price-taking firms, MR equals price.

  4. A firm is profitable if total revenue exceeds total cost, with break-even conditions established.

  5. Fixed costs do not affect short-run optimal production decisions, influenced instead by the shut-down price.

  6. In the long run, if prices are below minimum average total costs consistently, firms will exit, and vice versa for profitable conditions.

  7. In long-run equilibrium, firms produce at MC = Market Price, leading to zero economic profit due to free exit and entry.