EC4101 - Topic 9: Perfect Competition
Learning Objectives
Understanding Perfect Competition:
Define what a perfectly competitive market is.
Identify the characteristics of a perfectly competitive industry.
Profit Maximisation:
Learn how a price-taking producer determines its profit-maximising quantity of output.
Profit Assessment:
Assess whether a producer is profitable and understand why an unprofitable producer might continue operation in the short run.
Industry Behavior over Time:
Explore why industries behave differently in the short run versus the long run.
Industry Supply Curve Determinants:
Examine what determines the industry supply curve in both the short run and long run.
Characteristics of Perfect Competition
Many Buyers and Sellers:
Numerous participants with small market shares where individuals cannot influence the market price.
Market Share: The fraction of total industry output accounted for by a producer's output.
Each participant's actions are likened to "a drop in the bucket."
Standardised Product:
Products are largely the same across sellers.
Standardised Good: Consumers perceive different sellers' products as identical, referred to as homogeneous goods.
Free Entry and Exit:
Producers can easily enter or exit the industry without significant barriers.
Firms as Price Takers:
No single firm can influence the market price; they sell as much as they want at market price.
Perfect Information:
High levels of information are available for buyers and sellers in the market.
Production and Profits
Firms in perfect competition are price-takers;
Total Revenue (TR): Calculated as the product of price and quantity sold, given by the equation:
Profit (Profit): Defined as total revenue minus total cost, given by the equation:
Profit Maximising Level of Output
Economic Profit:
It includes implicit costs; a zero economic profit is typical for firms.
Conditions for profit:
If TR > TC, the firm is profitable.
If , the firm breaks even.
If TR < TC, the firm incurs a loss.
Economic vs. Accounting Profit
Economic Profit:
Determined as total revenue minus total cost (including both explicit and implicit costs).
Accounting Profit:
Calculated as total revenue minus only explicit costs.
Often, economic profit is less than accounting profit because of implicit costs.
Marginal Revenue and Optimal Output
Marginal Revenue (MR):
Defined as the change in total revenue generated by an additional unit of output.
Mathematically expressed as:
For price-taking firms, MR equals the market price of goods.
Optimal Output Level:
Profit maximised when the marginal revenue of the last unit equals its marginal cost.
Profit Maximisation Condition
Why MR = MC?
Each additional unit produces extra costs and revenues.
If the marginal revenue is greater than marginal cost, producing that unit increases profit.
If MR > MC, greater production adds to profit; if MR < MC, reducing output raises profit.
Profit-maximising rule for competitive firms states:
.
Short Run vs Long Run
Short Run:
Fixed plant size; focuses on short-run profit maximisation at a defined plant size.
Profit Maximisation Example:
At a given price of €18, maximum profit occurs at output quantity Q = 50, where marginal cost equals marginal revenue.
Cost Calculation and Profit
Profit Calculation:
Given by the formula:
Alternatively:
Break-Even Price:
For price-taking firms, the price is at the break-even point where economic profit is zero.
Profitability and Market Price
Analysis of break-even situations:
If prices cover average total costs (ATC), such as if P > min ATC of €14, a firm is profitable.
Example: If market price is €18, then profit per unit is €3.60, leading to total profit calculation of €180 for Q = 50.
Loss Calculation
Example of a firm's loss:
If the market price is €10 and ATC is €14.67, per unit loss is ; total loss = 30 × -€4.67 = -€140.
Short Run Decisions
Producers may remain operational at losses in the short run if they cover variable and some fixed costs.
Shut-down Price: Determined by minimum average variable cost.
Firms adjust production based on the relationship between market prices and the shut-down price, producing at any price above minimum average variable cost (AVC).
Short Run Supply Curve
Individual Supply Curve:
The MC curve above the shut-down price (minimum AVC) becomes the firm's supply curve.
Long Run Decisions
Firms will exit if total revenue falls below total cost.
Exit Condition: TR < TC, or P < ATC.
Entry Condition: TR > TC, or P > ATC.
Competitive Market Supply Curve
Short-Run Supply Curve:
Based on the portion of its marginal cost curve above average variable cost.
Long-Run Supply Curve:
Based on the marginal cost curve above the lowest point of its average total cost curve.
Long-Run Competitive Equilibrium
In long-run equilibrium, firms must achieve zero economic profit.
Process of entry and exit leads to price = average total cost, ensuring no incentive for firms to enter or exit the market.
Firms operate at efficient scale, which corresponds to the minimum point of average total cost.
Zero-Profit Equilibrium
Firms stay in business earning zero profit as revenue compensates owners for implicit costs and time spent on sustaining operation.
Perfect Competition Model Relevance
While real markets may not exemplify all characteristics of perfect competition, the model serves as a benchmark to assess real-world deviations.
Policy Implications:
Recent market liberalisation has engaged with the neoclassical ideal of perfectly competitive markets.
Summary of Key Points
All producers and consumers in a perfectly competitive market act as price takers, influencing no market price.
Characteristics: Large number of producers; standardised products; free entry and exit; perfect information.
Producers aim for profit maximisation where MR = MC; for price-taking firms, MR equals price.
A firm is profitable if total revenue exceeds total cost, with break-even conditions established.
Fixed costs do not affect short-run optimal production decisions, influenced instead by the shut-down price.
In the long run, if prices are below minimum average total costs consistently, firms will exit, and vice versa for profitable conditions.
In long-run equilibrium, firms produce at MC = Market Price, leading to zero economic profit due to free exit and entry.