2. 2023 April Note - Regular and summary -tute No.2
Regular & Summary Procedure
General Rule: The regular procedure of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) must be applied unless expressly prevented (e.g., Debt Recovery Action).
Exceptions:
The CPC does not provide for a summary procedure.
No provisions under any other law for summary procedure.
In absence of specific laws for procedure, the regular procedure is required.
Case Reference: Jayewardene V Obveysekere and 5 others (2011) 1 SLR 349
Must file action under regular procedure where summary procedure does not apply.
Summary Procedure
Relevant Sections: Sections 373 to 391 of the CPC, especially Section 7 (Illustrations).
Actions Involving Summary Procedure:
Evidence Requirement: Applicants must support their application with proper evidence simultaneously.
Court's Discretion: The court evaluates whether a prima facie case is made out:
If so, it may:
Pass the order against the defendant immediately unless they show good cause against it on a specified day.
Appoint a day for the opposing party to present their case against the application.
Filing an Action under the Summary Procedure
Section 373: Action should be initiated with a duly stamped Written Petition.
Section 374: Petition must contain the following particulars:
I. Name of the court and date of submitting the petition.
II. Petitioner(s): Name, description, and address.
III. Respondent(s): Name, description, and address.
IV. Statement of facts regarding the application, including grounds and circumstances.
V. A specific prayer for relief or order sought.
Formal Requirement: The statement should be in numbered paragraphs.
Supporting an Action under the Summary Procedure
Section 376: Documents to be attached to the petition:
Affidavits.
Authenticated copies of records.
Processes or other documentary evidence.
Section 377:
If prima facie established, the court can:
Issue an order nisi, effective upon the respondent failing to show cause on the appointed day.
If the petitioner is entitled to relief, make an interlocutory order for a hearing date, allowing the respondent to contest the petition.
Judicial Interpretation: In Caderamanpulle Vs. Ceylon Paper Sacks Ltd. [2001 (3) SLR 112]:
Unlike regular actions, Section 377 places the burden on the defendant to show cause against the order nisi.
Summary procedure is designed for expeditious resolution; thus, defendants must act promptly to obtain relief.
Regular Procedure
Section 39: Instituting an action under regular procedure involves:
Presenting a duly stamped written plaint to the court.
Processes Involved:
Filing plaint, responding to the plaint, replicating, pre-trial stages, trial, written submissions, and judgment.
Plaint Compliance: Must comply with Sections 40-46 of the CPC.
Action Defined
Legal Definition: An action is a proceeding aimed at preventing or seeking redress for a wrong.
It generally refers to litigation in civil court for recovery of rights or redress of grievances.
Prescription Ordinance No 22 of 1871: Governs the jurisdiction of the Civil Courts in the Island, applicable only to actions.
Application as Action: Application for curator appointment and property sale regarded as an action under Section 6 of the CPC.
Cause of Action
General Understanding: Refers to the act of the defendant that prompts the plaintiff to pursue a complaint.
Case Reference: Jackson v. Spittle - Defines the cause of action as the act of the defendant that warrants a complaint from the plaintiff.
Lowe V Fernando 16 NLR 398: The term "cause of action" generally signifies:
A. Right of the Plaintiff.
B. Violation of that right by the Defendant.
Also signifies the complete set of facts that together constitute the plaintiff's right to maintain the action.
Legal Specification - Section 5: Cause of action encompasses not just the wrongful act but also any denial of rights, obligation refusals, duty neglect, or infliction of affirmative injury.