2. 2023 April Note - Regular and summary -tute No.2

Regular & Summary Procedure

  • General Rule: The regular procedure of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) must be applied unless expressly prevented (e.g., Debt Recovery Action).

    • Exceptions:

      • The CPC does not provide for a summary procedure.

      • No provisions under any other law for summary procedure.

      • In absence of specific laws for procedure, the regular procedure is required.

  • Case Reference: Jayewardene V Obveysekere and 5 others (2011) 1 SLR 349

    • Must file action under regular procedure where summary procedure does not apply.

Summary Procedure

  • Relevant Sections: Sections 373 to 391 of the CPC, especially Section 7 (Illustrations).

  • Actions Involving Summary Procedure:

    • Evidence Requirement: Applicants must support their application with proper evidence simultaneously.

    • Court's Discretion: The court evaluates whether a prima facie case is made out:

      • If so, it may:

        1. Pass the order against the defendant immediately unless they show good cause against it on a specified day.

        2. Appoint a day for the opposing party to present their case against the application.

Filing an Action under the Summary Procedure

  • Section 373: Action should be initiated with a duly stamped Written Petition.

  • Section 374: Petition must contain the following particulars:

    • I. Name of the court and date of submitting the petition.

    • II. Petitioner(s): Name, description, and address.

    • III. Respondent(s): Name, description, and address.

    • IV. Statement of facts regarding the application, including grounds and circumstances.

    • V. A specific prayer for relief or order sought.

    • Formal Requirement: The statement should be in numbered paragraphs.

Supporting an Action under the Summary Procedure

  • Section 376: Documents to be attached to the petition:

    • Affidavits.

    • Authenticated copies of records.

    • Processes or other documentary evidence.

  • Section 377:

    • If prima facie established, the court can:

      • Issue an order nisi, effective upon the respondent failing to show cause on the appointed day.

      • If the petitioner is entitled to relief, make an interlocutory order for a hearing date, allowing the respondent to contest the petition.

  • Judicial Interpretation: In Caderamanpulle Vs. Ceylon Paper Sacks Ltd. [2001 (3) SLR 112]:

    • Unlike regular actions, Section 377 places the burden on the defendant to show cause against the order nisi.

    • Summary procedure is designed for expeditious resolution; thus, defendants must act promptly to obtain relief.

Regular Procedure

  • Section 39: Instituting an action under regular procedure involves:

    • Presenting a duly stamped written plaint to the court.

  • Processes Involved:

    • Filing plaint, responding to the plaint, replicating, pre-trial stages, trial, written submissions, and judgment.

  • Plaint Compliance: Must comply with Sections 40-46 of the CPC.

Action Defined

  • Legal Definition: An action is a proceeding aimed at preventing or seeking redress for a wrong.

    • It generally refers to litigation in civil court for recovery of rights or redress of grievances.

  • Prescription Ordinance No 22 of 1871: Governs the jurisdiction of the Civil Courts in the Island, applicable only to actions.

  • Application as Action: Application for curator appointment and property sale regarded as an action under Section 6 of the CPC.

Cause of Action

  • General Understanding: Refers to the act of the defendant that prompts the plaintiff to pursue a complaint.

  • Case Reference: Jackson v. Spittle - Defines the cause of action as the act of the defendant that warrants a complaint from the plaintiff.

  • Lowe V Fernando 16 NLR 398: The term "cause of action" generally signifies:

    • A. Right of the Plaintiff.

    • B. Violation of that right by the Defendant.

    • Also signifies the complete set of facts that together constitute the plaintiff's right to maintain the action.

  • Legal Specification - Section 5: Cause of action encompasses not just the wrongful act but also any denial of rights, obligation refusals, duty neglect, or infliction of affirmative injury.