3/14 Assigned Readings

“How the Russia-Ukraine War Challenges Arctic Governance” (Council on Foreign Relations)

  • 20142014
    • Russia Crimea annex
    • not a huge reaction
    • Arctic Chiefs of Defense Forum suspended
    • military-to-military talks stopped
  • January2021January 2021
    • Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty renewed
    • “Russia and US can cooperate militarily”
  • May2021May 2021
    • ^^Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov^^ meets in Reykjavik for Russian council chairmanship
    • same priorities as old chairmanship- “cooperation”
    • ^^US Sec. of State Antony Blinken^^- “no Arctic Military”- Lavrov “opposite”
    • Russian council-giving meeting→ good signs for peace/communication
  • January2022January 2022
    • Russia prepares Ukraine attack
    • Norway parliament nominates Council for Noble Peace Prize to stall Russia?
  • March2022March 2022
    • all countries but Russia “pause participation” (boycott) in Council meetings
    • shows everyone’s disagreement of invasion
    • Russia loses power Council gave it
  • Spring2023Spring 2023
    • Council chairmanship to Norway
    • operations likely resumed
    • many things will be changed
    • Arctic legitimacy and agenda will be less bc seven states don’t trust Russia
  • Arctic Council impact between countries- stopped bc Russia-Ukraine war
  • “Arctic is peaceful area” idea = destroyed
    • only non controversial things addressed when Council resumes → three binding treaties
    • Agreement on Search and Rescue in the Arctic (2011)
    • Agreement on Marine Oil Pollution in the Arctic (2013)
    • Agreement on Enhancing Arctic Scientific Cooperation (2017)
    • working groups will continue bc less political
  • many issues persist bc of continuing Ukraine war
    • fishing
    • energy
    • continental shelf claiming
    • navigation freedom
    • oil drilling
  • possibility of Nordic Plus
    • new Arctic forum with only seven states and Arctic indigenous
    • similar to Council but less power
    • no legitimacy
    • not same progress
    • not as helpful w/o Moscow
    • Russia = majority of Arctic
    • less scientific data
    • less environmental progress

“Lessons from Ukraine for the Arctic: Russian ‘dialogue’ isn’t always what it seems” (Brookings Institute)

  • Calls for creating forums for military security issues
    • Minister Sergey Lavrov
    • security forums = peace or worsening????
    • Arctic Chiefs Defense Forum- old military forum- suspended for Crimea annex
    • not super valuable- esp if Russia-centered
  • Russia wants
    • notifs for submarines bc of big Arctic coast- bad to nato bc Russia doesn’t notif
    • “buffer zones” near borders- impacts Norway Sweden Finland
    • NORAD (North American Aerospace Defense Command) discussion
    • NorAADC- shortened
    • Greenland Iceland activities discussion
  • Russia commonly uses “dialogue” to justify violent/unlawful behavior
  • NATO-Russia council already exsists- Russia wants a new forum where they have upper hand

“‘Nor Night Nor Day No Rest’: Arctic Diplomacy Divided (and United)”

  • Putin regime→ international isolation + sanctions→Arctic communication paused
  • Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) released Polar Region ice erosion report- climate change worries rise
  • Arctic Frontiers conference in Tromsø- May 2022
    • Cooperation paused- Arctic cant be paused
    • “How can we improve Arctic w/o Russia?”
    • “not replacing Council”- US Arctic Regional Coordinator James DeHart
    • “How will we move chairmanship to Oslo with war going on?”
    • Norway Foreign Minister Anniken Huitfeld- “we have plans”
      • Russian cooperation w/ border control, nuclear safety, search and rescue, sustainable resources
      • No Russian cooperation w/ science or policy
  • balance between condemning Russia and combatting climate change
    • Virginijus Sinkevicus, Europeach Union Commisioner for the Environment, Oceans and Fisheries- speech about
    • “The EU is in the Arctic, and the Arctic is in the EU”
  • European Green Deal and FIt for 55’ Policy→EU
    • goal of carbon neutrality by 2025
  • Oil
    • pressures to produce more bc rising prices- Norway
    • pressure to produce less bc climate
  • Finland (Helsinki), Sweden (Stockholm), neutral security → joining NATO
    • if happens, big seven all in NATO- approve
    • Russia >:( at first, then “no” but nicer
    • ^^Russia Senior Arctic Offical Nikolai Korchunov,^^ “can we trust?”
    • no Russia gas in Finland
    • ^^Turkey President Erdogan^^ doesn’t like them, may be hard to get Turkey vote
    • Kurdistan Workers’ Party
      • Turkey sees as terrorists
      • Finland and Sweden sympathetic
    • arms embargo on Ankara after Turkey military to Syria
    • Baltic Sea and Russian Kaliningrad would become surrounded by NATO
    • Russia threatened to increase military in Baltic region
  • Lennart Meri Conference May 2022
    • Ukraine conflict and NATO expansion = topics
    • Estonia (Tallinn),
      • wants to observe Council
    • Latvia, Lithuania, support NATO expansion (Baltic States)
    • Theme: Time Flees
    • ^^Dep. Prime Minister for European and Euro-Atlantic Integration of Ukraine Olha Stefanishyna,^^ Ukraine conflict will make stronger Europe

“The Rise of Persia” (Khan Academy)

  • \

Countries of Africa Quiz