Criminal Justice 1010

Here is a structured study breakdown to help you master all the material in your notes, organized into three core units along with high-yield concepts and practice recall questions.


Unit 1: Foundations & Architecture of the Court System
  • Origins & Structure:

    • Colonial Courts: Transitioned from informal local courts to legislative bodies acting as highest courts, borrowing from English Parliament. Handled local administration (taxes, licenses, infrastructure) alongside civil and criminal cases.

    • Dual-Court System: Established by the Constitutional Convention of 1787. Divides jurisdiction between the federal court system and the 50 state court systems.

    • Jurisdiction: The legal authority to hear a case based on geography and subject matter.

  • Court Hierarchies:

    • State Courts: Limited-jurisdiction lower courts (handle ~85% of judicial caseloads, misdemeanors, preliminary felony stages) →\rightarrow Major trial courts (general jurisdiction, serious felonies) →\rightarrow Intermediate Courts of Appeals (typically 3-judge rotating panels) →\rightarrow State Supreme Court (court of last resort for state law).

    • Federal Courts: U.S. District Courts (federal trial courts, at least one per state) →\rightarrow U.S. Courts of Appeals / Circuit Courts (11 circuits handling regional appeals) →\rightarrow U.S. Supreme Court (9 justices; requires the Rule of Four to grant review, requiring standing and a substantial constitutional or federal question).

  • Adversarial System & Judicial Roles:

    • Adversarial System: Two opposing parties present evidence before an impartial arbiter (judge/jury) to seek truth, utilizing cross-examination and checks and balances.

    • Three Roles of a Judge: Adjudicator (neutral legal referee), Negotiator (facilitating resolutions between parties), and Administrator (managing courtroom/docket).

    • Policy-Making: Courts interpret the law and address major social issues, primarily under the Fourteenth Amendment, though they rely entirely on the executive branch for enforcement.


Unit 2: The Criminal Process (Pretrial to Appeal)
  • Pretrial Sequence:

    1. Booking: Administrative recording of arrest.

    2. Initial Appearance: Defendant is informed of charges, constitutional rights, and bail determination.

    3. Preliminary Hearing: Neutral magistrate evaluates whether probable cause exists.

    4. Arraignment: Formal charges read; defendant enters a plea (guilty, not guilty, or no contest).

    5. Plea Bargaining: Resolves over 90% of criminal cases; exchanges a guilty plea for reduced charges or lighter sentences.

    6. Discovery & Motions: Sharing evidence without surprises; filing motions (e.g., suppress evidence, change venue).

  • Constitutional Protections & Speedy Trial:

    • Speedy Trial Act of 1974: Imposes federal limits of 30 days from arrest to indictment and 70 days from indictment to trial (100 days total).

    • Four Assessment Factors: Length of delay, reason for delay, how/when the defendant asserted the right, and prejudice suffered.

  • Trial Protocols (Sequential Order):

    1. Opening statements →\rightarrow 2. Prosecution's case-in-chief →\rightarrow 3. Motion to dismiss →\rightarrow 4. Defense's case →\rightarrow 5. Rebuttal →\rightarrow 6. Closing arguments →\rightarrow 7. Jury instructions →\rightarrow 8. Deliberations & verdict (unanimous 12-person jury) →\rightarrow 9. Posttrial motions & sentencing (guided by a Presentence Investigation Report / PSI) →\rightarrow 10. Appeal.


Unit 3: Theories, History, and Types of Punishment
  • The Four Goals of Punishment:

    • Retribution: Lex talionis ("eye for an eye"); punishment proportional to harm inflicted.

    • Deterrence: Threat of punishment to prevent crime.

    • Specific Deterrence: Deters the individual offender from future offenses.

    • General Deterrence: Deters the general public through example.

    • Incapacitation: Physical removal of an offender from society to prevent harm outside prison. Selective incapacitation reserves long sentences for chronic or heinous offenders.

    • Rehabilitation: Treating and reforming the offender to eliminate criminal behavior and lower recidivism.

  • Sentencing Structures:

    • Determinate: Fixed term (e.g., exactly 10 years).

    • Indeterminate: Range of time (e.g., 5 to 10 years), allowing parole boards to assess reform.

    • Concurrent: Multiple sentences served at the same time.

    • Consecutive: Multiple sentences served back-to-back.

  • Historical Punishment Eras:   Colonial/Puritan (1600s–1790s) →\rightarrow Penitentiary (1790s–1870s) →\rightarrow Reformatory (1870s–1890s) →\rightarrow Progressive (1890s–1930s) →\rightarrow Medical (1930s–1960s) →\rightarrow Community (1960s–1970s) →\rightarrow Crime Control (1970s–2000s).


Quick Active-Recall Check
  1. What is the difference between specific and general deterrence?

  2. What does the "Rule of Four" refer to in the U.S. Supreme Court?

  3. What distinguishes an indeterminate sentence from a determinate sentence?

  4. What three primary functions does a trial judge perform?

Let me know which topic you would like to quiz yourself on first or explore in greater detail!