Philosophy
Chap 1
Four Divisions
-Metaphysics: study of reality in a broad way
-Epistemology: philosophical study of knowledge
-Axiology: the study of value and ethics (morals and values)
-Logic: the study of correct reasoning
Aesthetics: the study of the feelings, judgments, and views involved in our appreciation and experience of the arts or other objects deemed beautiful.
-mental/third eye
Socrates; The examined life
”an unexamined life, is a life not worth living”
-its a tragedy because it results to grievous harm to the soul
Pre-Socratics
The first philosophers, most of whom flourished before Socrates (fifth century BCE).
-rhetoric
focus on chap 1 (1.1+1.2) + 2 (2.2) + 3 (3.2+3.3)
—
8/20/2026
Title- What is my Philosophy?
—
girl I’m absolutely sick to my stomach down right terrified. don’t question me about my philosophy. girl just pity kill me right now.
—
9/1/26 (idek what I’m writing down right now)
Writing + Reasoning and Review Notes - 10 questions for 2nd grade
-most times it’s 3 questions
1.1(Da basics)
how is reading philosophy is different from reading law?
-sub-division of the 4 divisions
-that focuses on psychology and others
-take the 4 divisions and relate them to each chapter
1.2 (Socrates and the examined life)
-the soul is harmed by a lack of knowledge
-the Socratic method is a question and answering dialogue.
-relate it to the pre-Socratic teaching
3.2(Socratic method)
-there’s a difference between statements and questions. strengthened critical thinking
-Socrates started questioning the state of current life and culture
-his questioning revealed that some “wise” people were not as knowledgeable as thought
3.3(knowledge and ignorance)
-Socrates methods and mission spring from having a good life and the soul
-your soul is damaged or heal with your own actions
-virtue (relates to ethics) is knowledge
-pre-Socratics did not have a mission with their philosophy
-to Socrates a clear sign a person has an unhealthy soul is an exclusive pursuit social status, wealth, power, and pleasure instead of the soul’s wellbeing
-souls wellbeing: being comfortable within oneself
-only the soul is good is searching wisdom and true happiness in life.
Chapter 8.2
Augustine
-a Christian philosopher from the medieval period
-“He was the pivot point between Greco-pagan and Christian thinking, a transition that would change both the Church and future philosophy.”
-His confession
-when he was 16, he struggled with his bubbling curiosity with his sexuality/sensuality. he gave into this temptation instead of with holding, bc he’s Christian and stuff.
-he first adhered to Manicheanism, which says that there’s two gods: good and evil. his adherence lessened once he visited Rome and was introduced to a new belief.
-Christianity: Neoplatonism: The philosophical view consisting of a blend of Plato’s metaphysics (primarily concerning the theory of the Forms) and other nonmaterialist or religious ideas.
-If I am mistaken, I exist.’ A nonexistent being cannot be mistaken; therefore I must exist, if I am mistaken.
-Complete skepticism, says Augustine, is not justified. That we are sometimes mistaken about the objects of our sense experience is no reason to be an extreme skeptic.
-necessary truth (a truth that could not have been false) is extremely precious—more valuable even than rationality
-if truth is the highest good, then truth must be God, because God is the highest good, the most excellent of all things. If an entity is higher and more excellent than truth, then that entity must be God
-the hierarchy of being
-the great chain of being: god is the highest good, therefore everything is less good.
-ranges from material objects (the least good entities), to the simplest living organisms, to animals possessing a degree of consciousness, to thinking and feeling human souls (with good souls higher than bad ones), to angels, and to (at a great distance from everything else) God
third grade (everything up to Augustine chap 8)
-5 terms that are important
-Neoplatonism: blend of Plato’s metaphysics and other nonmaterialistic or religious ideals
-truth: there is truth, complete skepticism is not justified “an eternal, unchanging, and objective reality that is fundamentally identical with God”
-necessary truth: a truth that could not have been false, argues for the existence of god
-hierarchy of being: all-encompassing hierarchy of existing things and their value
-material objects → simple living organisms → animals with consciousness → thinking/feeling human souls → angels → god
good and evil: goodness = being, since god is good everything he creates is good. if something had zero goodness = zero being (nonexistent). so, evil means a deficiency or privation of good.
-moral evil (aka free will): evil that comes from human choices and actions
-Thursday go through Augustine, and then review for rest of chapters
-third grade the week following focus on chap 1 (1.1+1.2) + 2 (2.2) + 3 (3.2+3.3) 8 (8.2)
dude this prof so racist man
questions
how does Augustine (Neoplatonism) relate to Plato’s philosophy
-Plato’s highest in hierarchy was dialogue or his search for knowledge
-”would rather believe then understand”
-unexamined life (Socrates) → who is my leader (Augustine)
9.1-9.3-9.4
skepticism: the philosophical attitude of doubting knowledge and fostering a critical approach.
epistemology: the philosophical study of knowledge
scientific revolution: initially, people believed the view of cosmic reality (late 16th through the 18th centuries, world is built off of hollow spheres, like an onion). but the scientific revolution upended the medieval worldview and ushered in a host of new ideas both in society and philosophy.
Augustine: step by step approach
Descartes wanted to be like Augustine
I think, therefore I am
propositional knowledge: “knowledge of a proposition”
A proposition is a statement that is either true or false, an assertion that something is or is not a fact. This kind of knowledge has been the main focus of philosophers.
three conditions: (1) you must believe it, (2) it must be true, and (3) you must have good reasons for—be justified in—believing it true
a priori: knowledge gained independently of or prior to sense experience
a posteriori: knowledge that depends entirely on sense experience.
rationalists: those who believe that some or all of our knowledge about the world is gained independently of sense experience (Descartes is this)
empiricists: those who believe that our knowledge of the world comes solely from sense experience.
Descartes dream argument: “there are no certain indications by which we may clearly distinguish wakefulness from asleep.”
Descartes concludes that if he can persuade himself of something, if he can have thoughts, he must exist. Even an evil genius cannot rob him of this knowledge. In the very act of doubting, or of experiencing something contrived by the evil genius, Descartes finds unshakeable proof that he himself exists: “I think, therefore I am.”
Descartes is a believer of God also
16 INTRO
-It is easy in philosophy’s history to find eminent male philosophers dismissing, devaluing, or ignoring the female intellect—even though women philosophers have been present in every age, from the classical period to modern times.
Louise M. Antony: “Embodiment and Epistemology”
-Although women were largely ignored by the major philosophers, whenever we were discussed, we were denigrated. Strikingly, the insult often involved a philosopher’s explicitly denying to women some characteristic that that philosopher had elsewhere held to be essential to full personhood, making us, by definition, less than human
Aristotle, who defined “man” as a rational animal, claimed that women’s reason was defective in that it was “without the power to be effective.”
-Feminist philosophy is an attempt to address the disparagement or subordination of women in philosophy and related fields, and feminist ethics and epistemology try to do the same in theories of morality and knowledge.
feminist ethics: An approach to morality aimed at advancing women’s interests, underscoring their distinctive experiences and characteristics, and advancing the obvious truth that women and men are morally equal.
feminism:
second sex: aka women are secondary, while males remain the primary
“what is a women?”:
ethics of care: A moral perspective that emphasizes the unique demands of specific situations and the virtues and feelings that are central to close personal relationships
Ethics of care is a feminist approach to ethics. It challenges traditional moral theories as male-centric and problematic to the extent they omit or downplay values and virtues usually culturally associated with women or with roles that are often cast as ‘feminine’.
those theories emphasize abstract principles, general duties, individual rights, justice, utility, impartial judgments, and deliberative reasoning.
unique demands of specific situations and to the virtues and feelings that are central to close personal relationships—empathy, compassion, love, sympathy, and fidelity
epistemology:
16.1 MARY WOLLSTONECRAFT
-Women were denied property ownership, expected to defer to men in important matters, barred from almost all professions, excluded from voting and government posts, deprived of higher education, and judged by different moral standards than those applied to men. Few societies in the rest of the world treated women any better.
-“Every profession, in which subordination of rank constitutes its power, is highly injurious to morality.”
-Wollstonecraft argues that humanity’s true happiness and ultimate perfection lie in the development of reason, virtue, and knowledge. Yet in women, these human capacities have been deliberately stunted, and the result is a deformity of the soul that society must correct
16.2 SIMONE DE BEAUVOIR
-The Second Sex (1949), her influential study of the inequality and injustice that defines the female condition. In her writings she ranged far and wide, examining radical freedom, the nature of evil, the use of violence, sex and gender, existentialism, good and bad faith, and moral responsibility.
asks a seemingly inane question: What is a woman?
biological sexual difference (male, female) is not the same as gender, which is mostly (or entirely) a socially determined characteristic. So she declares, “one is not born, but rather becomes, a woman.”
woman has been defined by a male-skewed society as the Other
Throughout history the male human has been thought of as the epitome of a human, as the embodiment of humanity—the One. Woman, however, has been cast as the Other, a creature defined in relation to man.
“feminist thinkers had good reason to suspect bias” “although women were largely ignored by the major philosophers, whenever we were discussed, we were denigrated”
16.3 Ethics
-men and women have dramatically different styles of moral decision-making, with men seizing on principles, duties, and rights, and women homing in on personal relationships, caring, and empathy.
-caring is an essential part of morality, and the most influential theories have not fully taken it into account.
-many argue that unlike the ethics of care, most moral theories push the principle of impartiality too far.
We seem to have special obligations (partiality) to close friends, family members, and others we care for, duties that we do not have to strangers or to universal humanity.
writing and reasoning
1.) What kind of education for women did the men of Mary Wollstonecraft’s day prefer? According to her, what were the results of such an education? Do you agree with her analysis? Explain.
* 2.) Do you think women should be granted the same rights, privileges, and opportunities that men have—or do you believe women should be treated differently and provided with opportunities that are more fitting to their gender? Justify your answer.
3.) Do you agree with Beauvoir that woman has been defined by a male-skewed society as the Other and that this has had a damaging effect on women? Why or why not?
4.) What features of the ethics of care do you find plausible? Are there any important elements missing? If so, what elements?
5.) Do you think there are innate differences between men and women in the ways they think about morality or moral issues? Are there culturally engrained differences in moral thinking?
1.)
women during Mary’s time period were subjected to a lesser version of education, if any at all. young women were taught to be obedient and tend to their home, while men had full range to gain an education. men did not want women to engage with education in hopes of keeping women subservient. As a result, women were kept in the housewife role because there were little avenues of escaping this reality. In addition, how can women fight for education if they don’t have the knowledge to fight? All in all, women’s education during Mary’s lifespan were aimed at being submissive towards men, and the culture at the time made it so that was commonplace.
2.)
I believe in a mixture of both, while leaning more so towards total equality between sexes. Women should definitely have the same right, privileges, and opportunities that men have. In that way, both parties are treated equal without discrimination. On the other hand, a more equitable approach would be to consider the strengths and weaknesses of both sexes and work in accordance to that. My issue with this framework is that I believe it can begin to feel limiting on behalf of both genders. Thus, my ideology leans more to equal chances for all.
3.)
I do believe that, especially for Beauvoir’s time, society prioritized men as the default compared to women. As a child, I observed that in influential documents, such as both the bible and law, male pronouns were considered the colloquial default . Women were seen as an afterthought, and were wedged in to the workings of society. For example, the famous quote, “we hold these truths to be self evident that all men are created equal.” The male form is the default, and women have to consciously insert themselves in order to be considered.
4.)
plausible: emotions are needed in deciding complicated decisions. it is not a moral failing for not being completely rational, and is instead expected for a human being. this characteristic is culturally tied to being a woman
implausible: that emotionality and rationality is tied to sex. i do not believe that women are innately more emotional and men are innately more rational, or at least in a substantial way. my belief is that a lot of it is conditioned through societal standards of what how each gender should appropriately preform in situations.
[i guess this response also ties to question 5, so i’m not gonna answer it again. if they are both asked, i am confident that i will remember the connection and expound properly lol]
Chapter 17 Contemporary Philosophers (girl why he playing with me)
17.2 NUSSBAUM: RELIGIOUS TOLERANCE
Martha Nussbaum, born 1947, is a modern day philosopher who speaks on subjects such as sex and social justice, feminism, religious intolerance, gay rights, race and international development, moral relativism, democracy, education, and others.
The New Religious Intolerance: all human beings possess human dignity, and with respect to that dignity, they are equal. People may be unequal in wealth, class, talent, strength, achievement, or moral character—but all are equal as bearers of an inalienable basic human dignity that cannot be lost or forfeited
“At this time we badly need an approach inspired by ethical philosophy in the spirit of Socrates, an approach that combines three ingredients:
Political principles expressing equal respect for all citizens, and an understanding of what these principles entail for today’s confrontations with religious difference. (These principles already inhere in the political traditions of both Europe and, especially, the United States.)
Rigorous critical thinking that ferrets out and criticizes inconsistencies, particularly those that take the form of making an exception for oneself, noting the “mote” in someone’s else’s eye while failing to note the large plank in one’s own eye.
A systematic cultivation of the “inner eyes,” the imaginative capacity that makes it possible for us to see how the world looks from the point of view of a person different in religion or ethnicity”
“can philosophy free us from these evils”
so like racism, racial profiling, islamophobia, religious intolerance, sexism, homophobia, etc
use every philosopher to answer that question. so philosophers like Plato, Socrates, Martin Luther King, feminist philosophers, our peers, etc
17.4 Martin Luther King: Civil Rights
He concentrated most of his efforts in the South, where the norm was segregation, an entrenched system that was invariably accompanied by unequal and abusive treatment of African Americans in countless areas of life. In response to those who thought he should indefinitely postpone attempts to change the status quo, King presented a sad litany of such injustices: A Testament of Hope
In 1954, in its Brown v. Board of Education decision, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that public schools throughout the land must be desegregated
A year later in Birmingham, Alabama, a black seamstress and activist named Rosa Parks became a symbol of courageous resistance to racial segregation and discrimination
For 381 days, King and his followers staged a nonviolent boycott against Montgomery’s public bus system. Ultimately they won
Through the next decade, King and his followers participated in many other boycotts, sit-ins, prayer pilgrimages, mass marches, and mass meetings—all of them nonviolent in accordance with King’s philosophy of nonviolent direct action
On August 28, 1963, King gave his historic “I Have a Dream” speech
King’s philosophy of nonviolent protest is coherent and thorough. He argues that nonviolent direct action is the wise middle road between the paths of militant violence and nonviolent inaction. The nonviolent way works, and “violence solves no social problems; it merely creates new and more complicated ones.
this man has to be tripping good grief.
final will be from Thursday 19th 12pm-1:50pm