ART APP 1/19
Introduction to Art and Its Definition
The speaker invites the audience to establish a common understanding of what art is.
States a personal definition of art and encourages agreement or disagreement among the audience.
Subjectivity vs. Objectivity in Art
The discussion begins with a situation where a friend expresses admiration for a sculpture.
Key Questions:
Is the object pointed at a sculpture or a work of art?
Audience is prompted to express their opinions (majority disagree).
Definitions:
Objective: An object can be viewed objectively as it exists outside of any individual's perception.
The object itself can be seen as evidence of its existence, making it an objective entity.
Subjective: Although the object exists, individual interpretation influences whether it is perceived as art.
Different perceptions might lead individuals to label the same object differently.
Clarifying Perspectives:
The speaker poses a question about distinguishing between the rock itself and its context to clarify meanings.
Encourages critical analysis of how context affects the perception of art.
Contextual Analysis of Natural vs. Artificial Art
The speaker discusses clues indicating that certain objects may have been manipulated by human beings.
Discussion Points:
Examining a rock within a landscape:
Presence of gravel suggests human manipulation.
Human positioning transforms natural rocks into potential artworks.
Definitions:
Natural: Objects resulting from nature’s processes.
Artificial: Objects produced or altered by human activity.
The term "artifice" connects to the concept of creation by human hands, implying that anything influenced by humans could be considered art.
The term "artificial" contains the root word "art".
Examples of Natural and Artificial Objects
The speaker provides an example of rocks that appear either artificial or natural based on human involvement.
Another example provided involves a hillside viewed from a car:
One hill is natural (formed by glaciers).
Another hill is artificial (built from chalk by prehistoric humans).
Characteristics of Artificiality:
Speaker notes differences between hills:
The artificial hill has clear human manipulation evidences, such as symmetry and inconsistency with the surrounding landscape.
Suggests that recognizable human involvement can influence the perception of whether something is art.
Conclusion
The relationship between natural and artificial is pivotal in understanding and defining art.
Due to time constraints, the discussion will continue in future conversations, indicating an open-ended nature of the exploration of art's definition.