The Rise of Conservatism in the United States (1945-1980)

The Rise of Conservatism in the United States (1945-1980)

Context: Liberal Gains (1945-1980)

  • This period saw significant advancements in liberalism, including:
    • Lyndon Johnson's Great Society programs.
    • The women's liberation movement.

Conservative Reaction

  • These liberal advancements caused a conservative backlash.
  • Culminated in the election of Ronald Reagan in 1980 (to be discussed in the next unit).

Roots of the Conservative Backlash (1960s-1970s)

  • Cultural Shifts: Conservatives were alarmed by:
    • Protests against the Vietnam War.
    • Changes in the traditional American family structure due to the women's movement.
    • Gains made by the Civil Rights Movement (particularly in the South).

The "New Right"

  • Young Americans for Freedom: A group of conservative college students who supported Barry Goldwater's 1964 presidential campaign.
  • Barry Goldwater: Coined the phrase "New Right", a coalition of conservatives who:
    • Resisted liberalism.
    • Embraced religious values.
    • Were populist and anti-egalitarian (believed in distinct roles for men and women).
  • John Birch Society: A more radical conservative group that:
    • Opposed communism.
    • Advocated for limited government.
    • Promoted right-wing conspiracy theories (e.g., opposition to water fluoridation).
  • William F. Buckley and The National Review: Represented a more moderate conservatism.
    • Buckley distanced himself from groups like the John Birch Society, fearing their radicalism would damage the conservative movement.

The Religious Right

  • Rapid growth of conservative Christians organizing against liberal trends.
  • Roe v. Wade (1973): The Supreme Court decision legalizing abortion became a major catalyst.
    • Led to unity between Protestant and Catholic Christians, who had previously been suspicious of each other.
  • Moral Majority (1979): Founded by Jerry Falwell, a pastor and evangelist.
    • Merged Christianity with conservative politics.
    • Falwell organized "I Love America" rallies, departing from traditional Southern Baptist views on separation of church and state, arguing that such separation led to moral decay.
  • Focus on the Family: Radio program hosted by James Dobson.
    • Advocated for reintroducing prayer in schools and resisting the expansion of gay rights.

National Events Contributing to Conservative Backlash

  • Economic Turmoil: Oil crisis and stagflation in the 1970s.
    • Stagflation: A combination of high inflation and economic stagnation.
    • President Nixon's attempts to cut federal spending worsened the situation.
    • Resulted in a loss of public confidence in the government's ability to solve economic problems.
  • Watergate Scandal: Illegal activities by President Nixon's reelection committee.
    • Break-in at the Democratic National Committee headquarters in the Watergate office complex.
    • Nixon's denial of involvement, followed by the revelation of his knowledge and endorsement of the activities.
    • Nixon's subsequent resignation due to imminent impeachment, further eroding public trust in the government.

Clashes Between Conservatives and Liberals

  • Equal Rights Amendment (ERA): Proposed constitutional amendment to guarantee equal rights for women.
    • Failed to be ratified due to conservative opposition, led by figures like Phyllis Schlafly.

Affirmative Action

  • Arose from the Civil Rights Movement to address systemic racism.
  • Aimed to correct past injustices by considering race in hiring decisions and college admissions.
  • Led to resentment from some white individuals who felt they were being discriminated against.

University of California v. Bakke (1978)

  • Alan Bakke: A white student who argued he was denied admission to the University of California due to racial quotas.
  • Supreme Court Decision: Ruled that minority quotas were unconstitutional and violated the 14th Amendment's equal protection clause.
  • Race could still be considered as a factor in admissions, but not the sole determinant.

Conclusion

  • The growth of the conservative movement reached its peak in the subsequent period.
  • Continued study to be done in the next unit.
  • Additional study resources are available in Heimler's Review Guides.