Study Notes on Drug Trafficking, Violence, and Control
Chapter 11: Drug Trafficking
Overview of the Illegal Drug Trade
- The illegal drug trade is a highly lucrative enterprise, comparable to many legal industries.
- Global Revenue: The global narcotics industry generates revenue exceeding half a trillion dollars annually.
- This amount exceeds three times the total value of all United States currency in circulation.
- The revenue also surpasses the gross national product of all but a handful of industrialized nations.
- Prevalence of Drug Use: The United Nations Office of Drug and Crime (UNODC) estimates that there are 300 million illicit drug users worldwide.
- Of these users, approximately 10 to 13 percent pose societal problems, primarily through ill health, reduced productivity, and drug-related crime.
Market Prices and Economics of Drugs
- Price Comparison:
- Cocaine is valued at 30 times the price of gold.
- Heroin is valued at 10 times the price of gold.
- Both drugs can be produced at costs similar to those of aspirin but can be resold for significantly more.
- Factors Influencing Illicit Drug Use in a Country:
- Disposable income of the populace.
- Age distribution of the population.
- Sexual equality or imbalance.
- Levels of unemployment and income inequality.
Trends in Drug Use Statistics (per category and year)
| Category | 1988 | 1992 | 1996 | 2000 | 2006 | 2010 | 2016 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cocaine | 107.0 | 49.9 | 39.2 | 35.2 | 38 | 28.3 | 24 |
| Heroin | 26.1 | 17.2 | 12.8 | 10.0 | 11 | 27.0 | 43 |
| Meth | 5.8 | 4.8 | 10.1 | 5.4 | 18 | 13.0 | 27 |
| Marijuana | 12.1 | 14.6 | 9.5 | 10.5 | 34 | 40.6 | 52 |
| Total | 154.3 | 88.0 | 74.3 | 63.5 | 101 | 108.9 | 146 |
Myths About Drug Trafficking
- Market Centralization: A common misconception is that the drug trade operates as a highly organized enterprise with a single dominating leader.
- Reality: The hierarchy and organization of drug trafficking vary significantly depending on the drug and its production/distribution methods.
- The U.S. drug dealing market is highly decentralized, with thousands of independent enterprises involved.
- Illegal drugs are smuggled into the U.S. from many different countries and sold by a diverse range of dealers.
Economic Implications of Drug Trade
- The drug trade contributes to the economy in a manner similar to legal businesses, despite its illicit nature.
- Drug sales support not only those directly involved in the trade but also those in the legal economy who interact with drug workers.
- Removal of the drug industry could devastate economies, similar to the collapse of any major legal industry.
- Demand is the primary catalyst for the persistence of the drug trade, underscoring its critical economic role.
Models of Drug Distribution
- Types of Models:
- Pure Agricultural Model: Refers to drugs derived from plants requiring minimal processing.
- Pure Chemical Model: Involves drugs synthesized entirely from laboratory processes.
- Mixed Model: Combines agricultural and chemical methods.
- Examples: Marijuana and opium primarily fall under the agricultural model, while synthetic drugs like ecstasy and methamphetamine are more aligned with the pure chemical model.
Specific Drugs and Their Trafficking
Heroin
- A significant portion of heroin in the U.S. originates from the Golden Triangle and Golden Crescent regions.
- The production involves farmers harvesting opium, which is then sold to wholesalers who process it into heroin.
Cocaine
- Predominantly sourced from Colombia, Peru, and Bolivia, with Colombia accounting for 92% of the cocaine supply in the U.S.
- Cocaine trafficking has shifted over time with increasing involvement of Mexican traffickers.
- Price example: In 2019, the cost was approximately $150 for a gram at 50% purity.
Methamphetamine
- Sources include labs in China, Canada, and centralized Mexican organizations.
- Meth is highly pervasive, particularly in the western and midwestern U.S.
Ecstasy and LSD
- Ecstasy: Previously dominated by production in Belgium and the Netherlands; current sources include China and Canada.
- LSD: Relatively few U.S. labs supply LSD, primarily in California and the Northwest.
Factors Facilitating Drug Trade
- Prohibition: Acts as a driving force for the drug trade, influencing the surge from licit to illicit markets.
- Poverty and corruption at various governmental levels hinder efforts to control drug trafficking.
- Globalization: Has accelerated drug trafficking due to advancements in technology, trade, and transportation.
- Adaptability: When drug trafficking is curtailed in one area, it often resurfaces elsewhere due to high profitability.
Chapter 12: Drugs and Violence
Nature of the Drug Crime Link
- Sociological Connection: There exists a notable link between drug use and criminal behavior.
- Drug users are often more likely to engage in non-drug-related crimes and vice versa.
- Specific drugs have stronger correlations with violent behavior (e.g., heroin and crack cocaine).
Models Explaining the Drug-Crime Connection
Enslavement Model:
- Suggests that drug addiction leads to a life of crime as addicts engage in illegal activities to support their habits.
Predisposition Model:
- Argues that individuals predisposed to crime are also likely to engage in drug use, highlighting the overlap between criminal behavior and drug use.
Intensification Model:
- Merges aspects of both the previous models, suggesting that criminal behavior can necessitate drug use and vice versa.
The Drug-Violence Nexus: Three Models
Psychopharmacologic Model:
- Suggests violence is a result of the psychological and physical effects of drugs.
Economic-Compulsive Model:
- Proposes that financial pressures faced by addicts increase their propensity for violent crimes.
Systemic Model:
- Emphasizes violence arising from the competitive nature of the drug trade itself (e.g., territorial disputes).
Factors Contributing to Heroin and Cocaine-Related Violence
- Gender impacts violence associated with cocaine use:
- Males are more likely to perpetrate violence, while females tend to be victims.
- Social settings of heavy cocaine use often correlate with an increase in violent behavior.
Chapter 13: Drugs and Crime
Drug Control Systems in the U.S.
- The Controlled Substances Act categorizes drugs based on their abuse potential and medical use.
- Categories of drugs include:
- Legal Drugs: Offered without prescription and regulated by various laws (e.g., alcohol, tobacco).
- Prescription Drugs: Only accessible via medical prescriptions and closely monitored.
- Schedule One Drugs: Classified as having high abuse potential and no recognized medical use (e.g., heroin, LSD).
The Punitive Approach to Drug Control
- Prohibition: Refers to the legal ban on certain drugs, resulting in criminal repercussions for possession/sale.
- Arguments in favor of punitive policies suggest that imposing penalties will reduce drug use.
Drug Courts and Alternatives to Punishment
- Drug Courts: A system initiated to divert nonviolent drug offenders into treatment programs instead of incarceration.
- Evidence suggests that drug court participants have lower rates of recidivism compared to nonparticipants.
Conclusions about Drug Enforcement
- While drug arrests remain high, they often concern less severe offenses, and the broader implications of drug laws continue to raise questions about effectiveness and justice.
- Economic Repercussions:
- It is suggested that simply increasing enforcement won't eradicate drug problems and may lead to unintended consequences, emphasizing the need for a nuanced approach.