Introduction to Moral Philosophy and Bioethics

Human Existence and the Role of Philosophy

  • Human existence is described as an incomprehensible contradiction based on two primary factors:

    • Humans are born without their knowledge.

    • Humans will die, most probably against their will.

  • Life is viewed as a "BIG PROBLEM," which leads to a search for the ultimate meaning of life.

  • Philosophy is defined as the ceaseless, intellectual quest for the existential import of life.

Defining Moral Philosophy (Ethics)

  • Ethics, also known as Moral Philosophy, is characteristically defined as a practical and normative science based on reason.

  • It focuses on the study of human acts and provides the criteria for their goodness or badness.

  • Ethics as a science involves the following components:

    • Human Acts: The subject matter involves actions performed by humans.

    • Norm: It functions as a standard or rule for behavior.

  • Distinction in Human Acts:

    • Ethics specifically deals with human acts insofar as they are performed with intellectual deliberation and freedom.

    • An individual’s moral responsibility is tied to these two factors: deliberation and freedom.

Ethical Postulates and Foundations

  • Ethical postulates are fundamental assumptions or requirements for the existence of morality. There are three primary postulates identified:

    • A. Human Freedom: The capacity for choice and self-determination.

    • B. The Immortality of the Soul: The concept that the soul persists beyond physical death.

    • C. God: The existence of a divine being or ultimate moral authority.

Categories of Ethical Study: General vs. Applied

  • General Ethics:

    • Refers to the diverse ethical formulations of general and universal concepts and principles.

    • These principles serve as the foundation of morality.

    • It is also referred to as Normative Ethical Inquiry.

  • Applied Ethics:

    • Referred to as "special ethics."

    • This involves applying general moral concepts and principles to specific situations in life where they are applicable, valid, and legitimate.

    • Examples include:

      • Legal ethics

      • Professional codes of ethics

      • Nursing ethics

Bioethics as Applied Ethics

  • Etymology: The term Bioethics literally means the "ethics of LIFE."

  • Scope and Definition:

    • It is considered the ethics of medical care but is explicitly noted as not being equivalent to medical ethics (which is specific to the medical profession).

    • It investigates practices and developments within the life sciences and/or biomedical fields.

    • It is an applied study of ethical issues and values across medicine, biology, and the behavioral sciences.

  • Primary Predicaments:

    • Bioethics primarily deals with dilemmas concerning LIFE, HEALTH, and DEATH.

    • These dilemmas often result from modern biological technology and the specific ways they affect human values.

  • Interdisciplinary Nature:

    • The bioethical approach is strictly interdisciplinary.

    • It requires pooling together all pertinent available knowledge, including:

      • Biological data

      • Philosophical analysis

      • Theological perspectives

      • Medical expertise

      • Legal frameworks

      • Psychosocial insights

      • Sociological studies

    • Divergent ethical perceptions are presented so that the relative strengths and weaknesses of alternate positions can be evaluated to settle moral dilemmas.

Evolutionary Phases of Bioethical Studies

  • Primitive Ethics / Group Morality:

    • Even primitive tribes utilized a set of unwritten precepts or codes.

    • These dictated how individuals (such as troglodytes) acted and behaved in relation to others in the group.

    • This is characterized as a system of values established for the sake of survival.

  • Phase 1: Medical Ethics:

    • The oldest phase, dating back to the 3rd3^{rd} century BC.

    • Notable reference: The Hippocratic Oath, which emphasizes the duty to keep a patient away from harm and injustice.

    • Notable reference: Perceival Medical Ethics.

  • Phase 2: Research Ethics (Ethics of Care):

    • This phase involves conducting experiments using humans as specimens.

    • Notable reference: The Nuremberg Code (19471947).

    • Key concepts include informed consent, decision-making, and choice.

  • Phase 3: Public Policy:

    • This stage accentuates the participatory aspect of decision-making within a democratic setup.

    • It concerns the formulation of public policies for the benefit of all members of society.

Dominant Themes in Bioethical Inquiry

  • Beneficence:

    • Defined by the mandates to "Do no harm and produce the good" or "do good and do no harm."

  • Autonomy (Ethics of Care):

    • Defined as the right to self-determination.

  • Justice:

    • Defined as rendering for what is due or merited.

Questions and Discussion

  • The transcript poses a fundamental philosophical debate regarding the necessity of a divine figure for moral structures:

    • Position 1: "There can be no morality without God."

    • Position 2: "Morality is still possible without God."

  • Critical Question for Reflection:

    • "Should an individual be held morally for all his/her acts?" (This refers back to the requirement of intellectual deliberation and freedom).