Study Guide for INR


• Where does Political Science fit into science? What are its subfields?

• What are the ‘Big 3’ IR theories?

• Do you know why the Treaty of Westphalia is important?

Classical Realism:

• Do you know how ethics and classical realism relate?

• Do you know the major historical thinkers who influenced classical realism?

• Are you confident about the definition of anarchy, and how it is explained in

classical and neorealism?

• Are you familiar with the concept of a Thucydides Trap? And about possible

current-day examples of a Thucydides Trap?

• Do you know why so many classical realists are worried about Hubris?

• Do you know why the Peloponnesian War is important for IR scholars?

Thucydides, Machiavelli and Hobbes

• Do you know the main events of Pericles’ Funeral Oration and the Melian

Dialogue?

• What did we cover from Hobbes? Are you familiar with how he relates to

Anarchy?

• Are you comfortable describing the state of nature? Do you know what concept in

IR it is closely related to?

• Do you know Machiavelli’s attitude about being hated vs being feared?

• Are there any other attributes Machiavelli particularly disliked?

Morgenthau

• Do you know Morgenthau’s principles of realism?

• Do you remember Morgenthau’s definition of power? Or how he understands the

study of politics relative to other fields?

• Do you remember Morgenthau’s distinctions between power and other stuff?

• Do you understand the difference between Status Quo and

Revisionist/Imperialist states?

Neorealism/Structural Realism:

• Are you comfortable describing the major differences and similarities between

neorealism and classical realism?

• Do you know what kind of actors neorealists consider states?

• Do you remember what Offence-Defence balance is? Why is it important? What

makes it up?

• Are you comfortable describing the difference between Offensive and Defensive

realists? What about the different ways they explain states going to war?

• Are you clear about the difference between “Offence-Defence balance” and

Offensive and Defensive Realism? (They’re not the same!)

• Do you know what a security dilemma is?

• Do you understand what polarity is, and the three types?

Waltz

• Do you remember Waltz’s way of defining a theory?

• Do you know what Waltz means when he talks about ‘unit’ and ‘system’?

• Are you comfortable describing the differences in behavior between multipolar

and bipolar alliances?

• Do you remember the ways Waltz believes nuclear weapons have changed

international politics?

Walt

• What tends to provoke alliances?

• What are some of the factors that make up how threatening a state is?

• Do you know the difference between power and threat in alliance formation?

• Do you know the kinds of things a state can do to respond to danger in the

international system?

• Do you understand Balancing and Bandwagoning? What are international

politics like when one is more common than the other?

• Do you know the difference between internal and external balancing?

  • Political Science in Science and Its Subfields

    • Place in Science: Classified as a social science that applies systematic, empirical, and theoretical methods to analyze political behavior, institutions, governance, and power dynamics.

    • Major Subfields:

    • Comparative Politics: Domestic politics, institutions, and processes across different countries.

    • International Relations (IR): Interactions among sovereign states, international organizations, and non-state actors.

    • Political Theory / Philosophy: Normative foundations, justice, authority, and historical political thought.

    • Public Policy & Public Administration: Implementation of government policies and organizational operations.

    • Political Methodology: Quantitative and qualitative tools, statistics, and research designs.

  • The 'Big Three' IR Theories

    • Realism: Emphasizes anarchy, national interest, power, and state survival.

    • Liberalism: Emphasizes interdependence, democratic institutions, international law, and cooperation.

    • Constructivism: Emphasizes the social construction of reality, ideas, identities, norms, and culture.

  • Importance of the Peace of Westphalia (1648)

    • Ended the Thirty Years' War in Europe.

    • Established the foundational framework of modern statehood (Westphalian sovereignty).

    • Codified principles of territorial integrity, legal equality among sovereign states, and non-interference in domestic affairs.

Classical Realism
  • Ethics and Classical Realism

    • Rejects universal private morality as an operating standard for statecraft; the prime moral duty of a statesman is state survival (raison d'état).

    • Political prudence—judging actions by their political outcomes—is prioritized above abstract moral ideals.

  • Major Historical Thinkers

    • Thucydides: Ancient Greek historian of the Peloponnesian War.

    • Niccolò Machiavelli: Renaissance political theorist emphasizing pragmatism and political survival.

    • Thomas Hobbes: Enlightenment philosopher who theorized the state of nature and sovereignty.

  • Definition of Anarchy (Classical vs. Neorealism)

    • Classical Realism: Anarchy is the backdrop, but conflict originates from human nature (animus dominandi or the drive for power).

    • Neorealism: Anarchy is the primary structural cause of conflict; the absence of an overarching central authority compels all states into a self-help dynamic regardless of human nature.

  • The Thucydides Trap

    • Coined by Graham Allison based on Thucydides' claim that war became inevitable because of the rise of Athenian power and the fear it instilled in Sparta.

    • Represents structural stress that occurs when a rising power challenges an established ruling power.

    • Current Example: The geopolitical and economic tension between the United States (incumbent power) and China (rising power).

  • Classical Realist Concerns Regarding Hubris

    • Hubris refers to excessive pride, moral righteousness, or overconfidence.

    • Causes leaders to overextend national commitments, abandon prudence, and undertake unsustainable military campaigns (such as the Athenian expedition to Sicily).

  • Significance of the Peloponnesian War for IR

    • Serves as the quintessential case study for balance-of-power dynamics, power transitions, the limits of justice in security politics, and alliance traps.

Thucydides, Machiavelli, and Hobbes
  • Pericles' Funeral Oration vs. Melian Dialogue

    • Pericles' Funeral Oration: An idealistic celebration of Athenian democracy, cultural superiority, civic virtue, and open society.

    • Melian Dialogue: A stark illustration of raw power politics. Athenians proclaim that "the strong do what they have the power to do and the weak accept what they have to accept," rejecting Melian appeals to justice, neutrality, and divine intervention.

  • Hobbes and Anarchy

    • In Leviathan, Hobbes describes the State of Nature as life without a central sovereign power, resulting in a "war of all against all" where life is "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short."

    • Relation to IR: International anarchy directly mirrors the Hobbesian state of nature because there is no global sovereign to enforce rules or guarantee survival.

  • Machiavelli: Fear vs. Hatred

    • Better to be feared than loved if one cannot be both, because love is held by obligation (easily broken), whereas fear is sustained by dread of punishment (consistently effective).

    • Must avoid being hated at all costs, as hatred fosters active resistance, conspiracy, and rebellion; avoided by respecting subjects' property and family.

    • Other Disliked Attributes: Indecision/vacillation, effeminacy, cowardice, inconsistency, and reliance on mercenary or auxiliary troops.

Morgenthau
  • Six Principles of Political Realism

    1. Politics is governed by objective laws rooted in human nature.

    2. The concept of interest is defined in terms of power.

    3. The form and nature of power are context-dependent, but power remains the central currency of politics.

    4. Political actions carry moral significance, but there exists tension between moral law and political survival; prudence is the supreme political virtue.

    5. National moral aspirations must not be equated with universal moral laws.

    6. The political sphere is autonomous, centered on the question: "How does this policy affect the power of the nation?"

  • Morgenthau's Definition of Power and Study of Politics

    • Defines power as psychological control and leverage over the minds and actions of other men.

    • Understands politics as an autonomous sphere with its own logic, distinct from economics (wealth), ethics (goodness), and law (conformity).

  • Power vs. Other Concepts

    • Power is distinct from military force: force is the ultimate physical instrument or threat behind power, whereas actual power achieves goals without resorting to continuous violence.

    • Power is distinct from influence: influence lacks the coercive leverage or sanctions to compel obedience when interests diverge.

  • Status Quo vs. Revisionist / Imperialist States

    • Status Quo States: Seek to preserve the existing distribution of international power and territorial arrangements.

    • Revisionist / Imperialist States: Seek to alter the existing balance of power, acquire dominant status, and overturn the international order.

Neorealism / Structural Realism
  • Differences and Similarities: Classical Realism vs. Neorealism

    • Similarities: Both treat states as self-interested, survival-seeking rational actors; both view anarchy and power balancing as central.

    • Differences: Classical realism traces state behavior to flawed human nature; Neorealism traces behavior to systemic structure (anarchy and the distribution of capabilities).

  • State Actors in Neorealism

    • Rational, unitary, and functionally undifferentiated actors (the "billiard ball" or "black box" model), differing only in their relative capabilities.

  • Offence-Defence Balance

    • Measures the relative ease of conquering territory versus defending territory.

    • Determined by military technology (e.g., machine guns/fortifications favor defense; tanks/blitzkrieg favor offense) and geography (e.g., oceans, mountains favor defense).

    • When defense has the advantage, states feel secure with fewer arms, mitigating the security dilemma. When offense has the advantage, incentives for preemptive strikes increase.

  • Offensive Realism vs. Defensive Realism

    • Defensive Realism (e.g., Waltz, Jervis): States seek an appropriate amount of power sufficient for survival; over-expansion triggers countervailing balances. Wars arise from misperception and the security dilemma.

    • Offensive Realism (e.g., Mearsheimer): States seek to maximize relative power and achieve regional hegemony; supreme power is the only reliable guarantee of security. Wars result from deliberate expansion.

  • Offence-Defence Balance vs. Offensive/Defensive Realism

    • Offence-Defence balance is a specific structural variable evaluating whether military technology and geography favor attack or defense.

    • Offensive and Defensive Realism are broad theoretical paradigms regarding how states behave strategically in anarchy.

  • The Security Dilemma

    • A condition in which measures taken by one state to increase its own security (e.g., arming, alliance-building) are perceived as threatening by other states, compelling them to react, ultimately leaving the initial state equally or less secure.

  • Polarity and Its Three Types

    • Defined as the distribution of power capabilities among great powers in the international system:

    • Unipolarity: One dominant superpower (hegemon).

    • Bipolarity: Two competing superpowers (characterized by structural clarity and stability).

    • Multipolarity: Three or more great powers (prone to fluid alignments, miscalculation, and shifting coalitions).

Waltz
  • Definition of Theory

    • A theory is an abstract, deductive model that explains patterns and recurrent outcomes, rather than an inductive compilation of descriptions or facts.

  • 'Unit' vs. 'System'

    • Unit Level: Domestic attributes of states (e.g., regime type, economic model, culture, leaders).

    • System Level: The overall structure comprising ordering principle (anarchy), differentiation of units (none), and distribution of capabilities (polarity).

  • Multipolar vs. Bipolar Alliance Behavior

    • Multipolarity: Alliances are shifting and fluid; prone to chain-ganging (reckless allies dragging partners into unwanted wars) and buck-passing (waiting for other powers to absorb the costs of countering a threat).

    • Bipolarity: Alliances are rigid and clear; superpowers do not depend fundamentally on minor allies for their survival, eliminating risks of chain-ganging and reducing miscalculation.

  • Nuclear Weapons and International Politics

    • Revolutionized deterrence: shifted strategic calculation from war-fighting capability to mutual assured destruction.

    • Vastly reduced the likelihood of direct great-power warfare, creating stability between nuclear-armed states.

Walt
  • Alliance Formation (Balance of Threat)

    • States align against the greatest perceived threat, rather than simply balancing against aggregate power.

  • Factors Determining Level of Threat

    • Aggregate Power: Total national capabilities (population, economy, military size).

    • Geographic Proximity: Nearby states pose a greater immediate danger than distant ones.

    • Offensive Capability: Possessing military equipment designed specifically for rapid cross-border invasion.

    • Perceived Intentions: Aggressive, expansionist, or hostile posture.

  • Power vs. Threat in Alliances

    • An exceptionally powerful state that appears unthreatening or geographically distant may not provoke balancing, whereas a moderately powerful state with aggressive intentions and offensive forces nearby will trigger a balancing coalition.

  • State Responses to Danger

    • Balancing, bandwagoning, buck-passing, hide-and-wait strategies, or appeasement.

  • Balancing vs. Bandwagoning

    • Balancing: Allying with other states against a dominant or threatening power (the primary historical pattern).

    • Bandwagoning: Allying with the dominant or threatening power to ensure survival or claim secondary spoils.

    • Systemic Implications: If balancing predominates, the system is stable and aggression is contained; if bandwagoning predominates, the system is volatile and expansionist powers rapidly snowball into hegemons.

  • Internal vs. External Balancing

    • Internal Balancing: Relying on domestic efforts—mobilizing national wealth, expanding military recruitment, and developing indigenous defense technologies.

    • External Balancing: Relying on international diplomacy—forging formal alliances, entering security agreements, and neutralizing adversaries' potential coalition partners.