PSYCH 11/13

Suicidal Social Model Overview

  • Introduced the concept of the suicidal social model in relation to serial homicide.

  • Key takeaway: Several varying factors must conspire together to create deviant behavior.

    • Consists of biological, psychological, and social variables.

Biological Factors

  • Genetic Predispositions:

    • Certain genetic predispositions may influence behavior.

    • Particularly in men, these predispositions can lead to:

    • Increased testosterone levels.

    • Underdevelopment of the frontal lobe, which may influence impulse control.

    • Underdevelopment of the amygdala, impacting emotional regulation.

    • Specific chemical imbalances that may increase aggression.

  • Vulnerability to Aggression:

    • While genetic predispositions do not predict serial homicides outright, they create a biological platform that could increase vulnerability to aggression or violence as individuals age.

Psychological Factors

  • Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs):

    • ACEs refer to negative childhood experiences that can lead to deviant behavior in adolescence and adulthood.

    • Types of ACEs include:

    • Physical, emotional, or sexual abuse during childhood.

    • Exposure to domestic violence or parental absence (e.g., incarceration).

    • Peer bullying, substance exposure at early age, systemic issues like poor access to education and health care.

  • Impact on Relationships:

    • ACEs can hinder the ability to form meaningful attachments and lead to feelings of rejection and abandonment.

    • These feelings create a psychological profile that can predispose an individual to violent behaviors, especially during puberty.

Conditioning and Violent Fantasies

  • Classical Conditioning:

    • Refers to how individuals can be unintentionally conditioned by their environment, as seen in Pavlov's classic experiment with dogs.

    • Boys aged 12-14 may develop sexualized revenge fantasies and violent fantasies associated with bullying or past trauma, which can become entwined.

    • The overlap of revenge and sexual fantasies may lead to a psychological association between sexual arousal and violent thoughts or actions, particularly as adolescence progresses.

Social Factors

  • Cultural Influences:

    • American culture may enhance the probability of serial killings through inadequate adult socialization, where individuals lack strong social support networks.

    • Those who do not belong to community-oriented groups or suffer from social isolation are more vulnerable to engage in violent behavior.

  • Diathesis-Stress Model:

    • Describes how predisposition (diathesis) combined with significant stressors can lead to deviant behavior.

    • Metaphorically, if predisposition is like a shaken soda bottle, significant life events may trigger violent outbursts as the pressure is released.

Comparisons to Modern Offenders

  • Discussion of similarities between serial offenders from previous decades and contemporary mass shooters, highlighting that the psychological backdrop may share common elements with modern-day violence.

Causation Models for Sexual Violence

  • Transition to discussing causation models specific to sexual violence.

  • Offenders who engage in sexual homicide share psychological traits with those who commit other forms of sexual violence.

General Information about Sexual Violence

  • Sexual assault as a legal term encompasses different forms of non-consensual sexual acts:

    • Examples include unwanted touching, exhibitionism, and extortion.

  • Rape is defined specifically as sexual intercourse without consent.

  • Important distinction: sexual assault includes rape, but not all sexual assault incidents are categorized as rape.

Statistics and Reporting Rates

  • Around 20-25% of women in the U.S. have experienced rape or attempted rape.

  • Approximately 10% of men in the U.S. have experienced similar violence.

  • Reporting rates for rape are low; most cases go unreported, and anonymous prevalence surveys yield higher and more accurate figures.

  • Generally, most rape cases do not involve strangers, but rather are committed by acquaintances or in relationship contexts.

  • FBI notes approximately 2% of reported rapes are false accusations, indicating the majority of reports are credible.

  • Lifetime prevalence at UNH showed 12% of women experienced rape or attempted rape and 5% of men showed similar rates, reflecting lower rates than the general public due to the privileged status of the population.

Unwanted Sexual Experiences

  • UNH data shows:

    • 16% of women had at least one unwanted sexual experience in the past year, and 7% of men reported similar experiences.

    • 32% of women who had been raped had never disclosed the event to anyone.

Typologies of Sexual Offenders (based on Brent Turvey's model)

  1. Power Reassurance Offenders:

    • Most common type.

    • Characterized by narcissism and insecurity.

    • Assaults are compensatory; often lack overt violence and may exhibit a desire to feel power through the act.

  2. Anger Retaliatory Offenders:

    • Less common, higher likelihood of violence and attacking strangers.

    • Driven by displaced anger rather than a need for power or control.

  3. Sadistic Offenders:

    • Characteristics include well-planned and organized attacks, a desire to dominate, and likely to use weapons.

    • Primarily motivated by the desire to inflict pain and humiliation on victims.

Repeat Offenders and Undetected Rapists

  • Research shows that a small percentage of offenders commit the majority of sexual offenses.

  • Studies by LeSack and Miller reveal that 6% of men in their sample accounted for over 90% of documented rapes, and that most sexual offenders do not fit the typical violent profile assumed in criminal cases.

  • Analysis indicates a culture of male-to-male social influence exists among offenders, often leading them to reinforce harmful behaviors and justifications for their actions.

Implications of Research Findings

  • Understanding the interplay of biological and social influences is fundamental for addressing prevention of sexual violence.

  • Efforts should focus on improving social networks and support systems to mitigate risks associated with isolation and vulnerability.