Interest Rates and Their Effects

Interest Rates and Lending

  • High inflation is detrimental to lenders because the money they receive back is worth less than what they originally lent. To compensate, lenders increase interest rates.

Federal Funds Rate

  • The federal funds rate (or BSP Rate in the Philippines) is the interest rate financial institutions charge each other for short-term loans.

  • The U.S. Federal Reserve uses the federal funds rate to influence the economy:

    • Lowering the rate encourages borrowing during economic slowdowns.

    • Raising the rate discourages borrowing when the economy grows too fast to curb inflation.

  • The federal funds rate serves as a baseline for the prime rate, which is the interest rate banks offer to their most creditworthy customers.

  • As the federal funds rate increases, other interest rates tend to increase as well.

Factors Influencing Interest Rates (Borrower's Control)

  • The primary goal for lenders is to minimize risk. Borrowers can secure better interest rates by making themselves less risky.

Credit Scores

  • Credit scores reflect creditworthiness. Lenders assess credit scores and history to determine lending risk.

  • High credit scores indicate a strong ability to repay debts, resulting in lower risk for lenders.

  • Low credit scores suggest a higher risk of default, leading to higher interest rates or loan rejection.

  • Credit scores can be improved, and services exist to help repair credit.

Loan Amount and Duration

  • Larger loan amounts and longer repayment terms increase interest rates due to the increased risk for the lender.

  • Larger loan amounts mean higher monthly payments.

  • Longer repayment terms increase vulnerability to inflation and life events that could impact repayment ability (though fixed-rate loans are immune to inflation).

  • Before borrowing, borrowers should assess the necessary loan amount and strive for the shortest realistic repayment period.

Guarantee

  • A guarantee is an agreement to settle a debt in an alternate way if the borrower defaults.

  • Guarantees can include collateral, cosigners, or a personal guarantee.

  • Adding a guarantee can reduce interest rates by lowering the lender's risk.

  • Borrowers should carefully review guarantee agreements due to potentially unusual terms.

  • Some loans, like auto loans (which use the vehicle as collateral), have mandatory guarantees.

The Effect of Interest Rates on Business

  • Businesses are affected by the economic environment, including interest rates.

  • Interest rates can signal whether to expand or contract business operations.

The Cost of Borrowing

  • Rising interest rates increase the cost of business loans, reducing profits.

  • High-interest rates may deter new projects or expansions.

  • Low-interest rates facilitate borrowing for business growth and profitability.

Customers’ Ability to Pay

  • High-interest rates on personal loans, home loans, and car loans reduce customers' disposable income, which can decrease sales for businesses.

  • Low-interest rates leave customers with more cash to spend, benefiting businesses.

Boosting Business Investment

  • High-interest rates encourage businesses to invest excess cash in interest-bearing accounts.

  • Low-interest rates may prompt businesses to invest in new equipment and plant improvements.

  • Banks benefit from business investments that boost assets, allowing them to make more loans.

Too Low, Too Long

  • If banks cannot earn reasonably high interest rates, they become less likely to take risks on loans, which can hinder start-ups, expansions, and innovation.

  • Short-term loans for cash flow can be difficult to obtain, potentially disrupting the delivery of goods and services.

Disadvantages of Low-Interest Rates

  • While low-interest rates are typically desired to stimulate the economy, they can also have negative effects.

  • The Federal Reserve lowers interest rate targets to encourage borrowing and spending during recessions.

  • Low rates increase the money supply, supporting economic recovery up to a point.

Low-Interest Rates and the Economy

  • When savings accounts and certificates of deposit (CDs) offer unattractive returns, people may pay down debt or invest in goods, services, or assets, reducing bank deposits.

  • Insurance companies may increase premiums due to lower interest-based returns on premiums.

  • Low-interest rates negatively impact individuals who rely on interest income, leading to decreased spending.

  • Decreased spending by large groups like retirees can slow overall economic activity.

Negative Interest Rates

  • Negative interest rates occur when a central bank sets interest rates below zero during severe economic downturns.

  • In a negative interest rate environment, borrowers are paid to borrow money, while savers are penalized. This is intended to stimulate borrowing and lending.

  • Depositors must pay to keep their money in the bank, incentivizing banks to lend money and businesses/individuals to invest and spend it.

  • Negative interest rates are intended to combat deflationary periods where people hoard money, leading to decreased demand, falling prices, reduced production, and increased unemployment.

  • Loose or expansionary monetary policy is used to address economic stagnation; however, if deflationary forces are strong, cutting the central bank's interest rate to zero may not be sufficient.

Theory Behind Negative Interest Rate Policy (NIRP)

  • Negative interest rates are considered a last-resort effort to boost economic growth when traditional policies have failed.

  • Theoretically, negative interest rates reduce borrowing costs for companies and households, encouraging investment, consumer spending, and demand for loans.

  • Retail banks may absorb the costs of negative interest rates rather than passing them on to small depositors to avoid deposit withdrawals.

Real-World Examples of NIRP

  • An example of NIRP is setting the key rate at -0.2 percent, where bank depositors pay two-tenths of a percent on their deposits instead of receiving interest.

    • Switzerland used negative interest rates in the early 1970s to counter currency appreciation.

    • Sweden (2009, 2010) and Denmark (2012) used negative interest rates to stem hot money flows.

    • The European Central Bank (ECB) instituted negative interest rates in 2014 to prevent the Eurozone from deflation.

  • Fears of moving money into cash (M1) did not materialize, but evidence suggests negative interest rates in Europe reduced interbank loans.

Overnight Rate

  • The overnight rate is the interest rate large banks use for borrowing and lending in the overnight market.

  • In some countries, the central bank targets the overnight rate to influence monetary policy.

  • The central bank participates in the overnight lending market, lending or borrowing money to banks.

  • The overnight rate is the interest rate banks charge each other on loans for meeting reserve requirements.

  • It's frequently confused with the discount rate, which is the interest rate central banks charge on loans, but they are different rates.

Fractional Reserve Banking System

  • Banks receive income from loans; they ideally want to loan out as much as possible.

  • To prevent bank failure during a "run on the bank," the Federal Reserve uses a fractional reserve banking system.

  • The fractional reserve banking system requires banks to keep a percentage of their deposits liquid to accommodate normal withdrawals.

  • If a bank cannot meet reserve requirements, it can obtain a Federal Funds loan, which is unsecured and short-term (typically overnight).

Impact of Overnight Rate Changes

  • An increase in the overnight rate discourages banks from borrowing to meet reserve requirements, encouraging them to retain more reserves and lend less money.

  • A reduction in the overnight rate encourages banks to borrow to meet reserve requirements, making more money available for lending.

  • Changes in the overnight rate can alter the economy by putting upward or downward pressure on interest rates.