Hegel Notes

George Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel

14.1 Introduction

  • Hegel was inspired by German Idealism, drawing from Rousseau and Kant.
  • He integrated these ideas with the desire for German unification and the rise of nation-states.
  • Hegel, like Fichte, supported idealism.
  • Hegel believed the rational will of the individual is expressed in the totality of the will of the state.
  • The state's consciousness and moral authority are more important than individual will.
  • History moves from imperfect to perfect through dialectical logic.
  • The distinction between 'is' and 'ought' vanishes as real becomes rational.
  • The state, civil society, and family are important components of this ideal.
  • Hegelian freedom is associated with rationality, unlike British liberalism's focus on liberty and individuality.

14.2 Life and Times

  • Born in 1770 in Württemberg, Southern Germany.
  • Studied theology due to his father's wishes.
  • Received a Ph.D. in 1793 from the University of Tubingen.
  • Worked as a tutor in Bern and Frankfurt for about seven years.
  • Lecturer at the University of Jena, later becoming a Professor in 1801.
  • Appointed Professor of Philosophy at the University of Heidelberg in 1816.
  • Became Professor of Philosophy at the Berlin University in 1818, succeeding Fichte.
  • Worked as an official advisor to the Emperor of Prussia.
  • Held these positions until his death in 1830.

Writings

  • Wrote extensively on Political Philosophy.
  • Phenomenology of Mind was published in 1807, written at Jena.
  • Science of Logic was published in 1811-12, earning him recognition as an outstanding philosopher.
  • Encyclopedia of the Philosophical Sciences was written during his time at Heidelberg, making him famous in Europe.
  • Philosophy of Right, his major work in political theory, was written at Berlin.
  • His lectures were published by his son after his death under the title Philosophy of History.
  • His writings and positions as advisor earned him international fame.
  • Became known as the King of philosophers and the philosopher of kings.

14.3 Spiritual Ancestry

  • Hegel was influenced by several philosophers.
  • Borrowed the dialectical method from Socrates.
  • Hegel's doctrine traces back to Greek thinkers like Socrates and Plato.
  • Aristotle's teleology influenced Hegel, with teleology understanding a thing in terms of its purpose. Example: A watch's purpose is to tell time.
  • Immanuel Kant's influence is visible in Hegel's writings.
  • Hegel's idea that the state is founded on reason is similar to Kant's position.
  • Like Kant, Hegel did not give individuals the right to resist the state.
  • Traces of Rousseau's influence are discernable.
  • Like Rousseau's General Will, Hegel's Idea, Spirit, or Reason is infallible.
  • Hegel prioritizes public interest over private interest, similar to Rousseau.
  • Rousseau distinguished between actual will (self-interest) and real will (public interest).
  • The general will is the sum total of all the real wills and is infallible.
  • Hegel's philosophy was historicist.
  • Historicism assumes limits to scientific knowledge about human activities and achievements.
  • Some link historicism to ambitions for rationally controlling human happenings.
14.3.1 Influence of Historical Events
  • Hegel was influenced by major contemporary events.
  • The French Revolution (1789) and the subjugation of Germany by Napoleon influenced him.
  • The French Revolution overthrew the feudal order and projected values of liberty, equality, and fraternity.
  • The values of liberty and fraternity influenced his writings.
  • The subjugation of Germany by Napoleon disillusioned him, leading him to resolve political problems of the states.
  • The reconciliation he advocated is unique and paradoxical.

Synthesis of Ideas

  • Hegel borrowed ideas from Plato, Socrates, Aristotle, Kant, and Rousseau.
  • He used their ideas to evolve his own philosophy.
  • Hegelian political philosophy stands apart from each of them.

14.4 Idealism

  • In political ideas, there are two schools: idealism and naturalism, rationalism and empiricism.
  • The nature of reality is ontological; knowing it is epistemological.
  • Idealists, like Hegel and Plato, believe true knowledge comes from the idea of the thing.
  • The idea of a thing is more important than the thing itself.
  • What is real and permanent is the ''idea of a thing