Chapter 5: Federalism: Forging a Nation

  • The power of government must be equal to its responsibilities

  • Federalism is the result of political bargaining

  • Federalism is not a fixed principle but rather one that has changed over time in response to political needs and partisan ideologies

  • Federal grants to local government are a defining feature of contemporary federalism and have enabled the fed govt to exert influence in policy areas that were traditionally controlled by states


Federalism: National and State Sovereignty

  • Sovereignty had initially been regarded as indivisible

  • Unitary system

    • Sovereignty is vested solely in the national govt

  • Confederacy

    • Govt under AoC

    • States alone are sovereign


The Argument for Federalism

  • Correct defects in the Articles

  • National govt had neither power to tax or regulate commerce

  • National govt had no money to maintain an army

  • National govt could not prevent inter-state trade wars


Protecting Liberty

  • Hamilton argued state and national governments could check each other


Moderating the Power of Government

  • Madison argued in Federalist No.10 that a government is better if it serves the range of interests that share political power and that larger governments are less likely to be controlled by a powerful faction


The Powers of the Nation and the States

  • Implied powers

    • Authority not granted to the national govt is implied for the states


Enumerated Powers and the Supremacy Clause

  • Enumerated (expressed powers)

    • Powers granted to Congress through the Constitution

  • Supremacy Clause

    • National law > state law


  • “Necessary and proper” clause / elastic clause

    • Congress has powers to make laws necessary to execute enumerated powers

    • Gave national govt implied powers


  • Reserved powers

    • Rights not delegated by the Constitution nor prohibited for states are reserved for the states


Federalism in Historical Perspective


McCulloch v. Maryland

  • Maryland levied taxes on the bank to try to drive it out

  • McCulloch refused to pay the taxes

  • McCulloch v. Maryland argued through necessary and proper clause that powers to bank things were reserved for national govt and that it could protect it from state actions


Gibbons v. Ogden

  • Used presedence from above


Dred Scott

  • Doctrine of nullification

    • Calhoun’s declaration that a state has the constitutional right to nullify a national law

  • SC ruled that slaves were not citizens and could not become citizens

  • Invalidated the Missouri Compromise by holding that slaves were property not people



Summary