Inventory Valuation Principles: Cost vs. Net Realizable Value (IAS 2)

Inventory Valuation and the Statement of Comprehensive Income

  • Conceptual Overview of the Income Statement:

    • Revenue: Consists primarily of the sales of inventory.

    • Cost of Sales (COGS): Consists mainly of the cost price of the inventory sold. It also accounts for normal wastages and Net Realizable Value (NRV) write-downs.

    • Gross Profit: The result of Revenue minus Cost of Sales (Revenue−Cost of Sales=Gross ProfitRevenue - Cost\,of\,Sales = Gross\,Profit).

    • Other Operating Expenses: Expenses required to keep the business operational and facilitate sales. These are included below the Gross Profit line. Examples include:

      • Distribution costs.

      • Advertising costs.

      • General administrative expenses.

    • Net Profit: The final result after deducting operating expenses from gross profit (often referred to as profit before tax for the year).

  • NRV vs. Standard Income Statement Logic:

    • The NRV calculation specifically looks forward to the next year to determine if a loss is imminent.

    • While Revenue reflects historical sales, NRV starts with the estimated selling price of inventory currently held.

    • The NRV definition ignores the original cost price and initial gross profit during the calculation phase; it focuses purely on the net value achievable from the specific batch of inventory.

Net Realizable Value (NRV) Principles and Calculations

  • Core Measurement Rule (IAS 2):

    • According to IAS 2 Paragraph 9, inventory must be measured at the lower of cost and Net Realizable Value.

  • NRV Definition and Formula:

    • NRV is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business, less the estimated costs of completion and the estimated costs necessary to make the sale.

    • The calculation focuses on the "bottom line" of the potential sale:

      • Estimated Selling Price\text{Estimated Selling Price} (excluding VAT)

      • Minus: Estimated Costs to Complete\text{Minus: Estimated Costs to Complete}

      • Minus: Estimated Costs to Sell\text{Minus: Estimated Costs to Sell} (e.g., advertising, transport, labels, commissions)

      • Equals: Net Realizable Value\text{Equals: Net Realizable Value}

  • Evaluating Results:

    • If NRV > Cost: The company expects to generate a total net profit from that inventory in the future. The inventory remains recorded at its original cost.

    • If NRV < Cost: The company expects an overall loss from that inventory. An adjustment (write-down) must be made immediately to reflect this loss in the current period.

Case Study: Example 15 - CD Entity

  • Entity Profile and Assumptions:

    • The entity is a vendor located in Durban that purchases CDs.

    • VAT Rate: 14%14\%

    • Profit Formula: Cost plus 50%50\%

  • Determining Total Inventory Cost:

    • Unsold inventory on hand at year-end was given as a sales price of 25 650 R25\,650\,R including VAT.

    • Step 1: Remove VAT

      • 25 650×100114=22 500 R25\,650 \times \frac{100}{114} = 22\,500\,R (Selling Price excluding VAT)

    • Step 2: Remove Profit Margin (Markup of 50%)

      • 22 500×100150=15 000 R22\,500 \times \frac{100}{150} = 15\,000\,R (Total Cost Price of inventory on hand)

  • Identifying Problematic Inventory:

    • The business identified a subset of inventory as "outdated" (this is a hint for NRV testing, along with terms like "close to expiry" or "damaged").

    • The sales price (including VAT and profit) for the outdated portion was used to find its cost price: 8 000 R8\,000\,R.

    • Inventory Segmentation:

      • Healthy Inventory: 15 000−8 000=7 000 R15\,000 - 8\,000 = 7\,000\,R (Valued at Cost).

      • Problematic/Outdated Inventory: 8 000 R8\,000\,R (Requires NRV testing).

  • NRV Calculation for Outdated Inventory:

    • Starting Point (Normal Selling Price): 8 000×1.50=12 000 R8\,000 \times 1.50 = 12\,000\,R

    • Revised Selling Price: A 60%60\% discount is planned for January.

      • 12 000×0.40=4 800 R12\,000 \times 0.40 = 4\,800\,R

    • Estimated Costs to Sell (Excluding VAT):

      • Labels: Recorded at 600 R600\,R in the calculation (after removing VAT from the 6.84 R6.84\,R figure mentioned in context or specific label expense units).

      • Transportation costs: Deducted.

    • Final NRV Result: 3 400 R3\,400\,R

  • Comparing Cost vs. NRV for Outdated Items:

    • Cost=8 000 RCost = 8\,000\,R

    • NRV=3 400 RNRV = 3\,400\,R

    • Since 3 400<8 0003\,400 < 8\,000, the inventory is written down to 3 400 R3\,400\,R.

    • Total Inventory Value for SFP: 7 000 (Healthy)+3 400 (NRV)=10 400 R7\,000\,(\text{Healthy}) + 3\,400\,(\text{NRV}) = 10\,400\,R

    • Write-down Amount: 8 000−3 400=4 600 R8\,000 - 3\,400 = 4\,600\,R (This increases Cost of Sales).

Accounting in Perpetual and Periodic Systems

Perpetual Inventory System
  • In this system, transactions are recorded directly in the Inventory account as they occur.

  • Ledger Entries:

    • Opening Balance: 20 000 R20\,000\,R

    • Purchases: Debit Inventory, Credit Bank/Creditors for 45 000 R45\,000\,R.

    • Sales (at cost): Credit Inventory, Debit Cost of Sales for 50 000 R50\,000\,R.

    • NRV Adjustment: At year-end, the inventory account shows a balance of 15 000 R15\,000\,R. To reach the required value of 10 400 R10\,400\,R, a write-down of 4 600 R4\,600\,R is necessary.

    • NRV Journal Entry:

      • Debit: Cost of Sales 4 600 R4\,600\,R

      • Credit: Inventory 4 600 R4\,600\,R

  • The final balance in the Inventory account correctly reflects 10 400 R10\,400\,R.

Periodic Inventory System
  • The write-down is handled implicitly during the closing of accounts; no unique additional journal entry is required for the NRV adjustment itself.

  • Ledger Entries:

    • The opening balance (20 000 R20\,000\,R) and purchases (45 000 R45\,000\,R) are transferred to the Cost of Sales account.

    • The inventory is physically counted at year-end (15 000 R15\,000\,R at cost).

    • Year-end Valuation Adjustment: Instead of taking the cost price (15 000 R15\,000\,R) out of Cost of Sales, the accountant takes the lower of cost or NRV target (10 400 R10\,400\,R) out of Cost of Sales and moves it to the Inventory asset account.

    • The Results:

      • Inventory Account: Automatically shows 10 400 R10\,400\,R.

      • Cost of Sales Balancing Figure: Calculated as: 20 000 (Opening)+45 000 (Purchases)−10 400 (Closing Stock)=54 600 R20\,000\,(\text{Opening}) + 45\,000\,(\text{Purchases}) - 10\,400\,(\text{Closing Stock}) = 54\,600\,R.

      • This balancing figure (54 600 R54\,600\,R) inherently includes both the original cost of goods sold (50 000 R50\,000\,R) and the NRV write-down (4 600 R4\,600\,R).

Presentation in Financial Statements

  • Statement of Financial Position (SFP):

    • Inventory is recorded under Current Assets at the value of 10 400 R10\,400\,R, representing the lower of cost and net realizable value.

  • Statement of Comprehensive Income (SCI):

    • Cost of Sales: Reported as 54 600 R54\,600\,R.

    • The figure is interpreted as: Cost price of goods actually sold+Normal wastages+NRV write-down\text{Cost price of goods actually sold} + \text{Normal wastages} + \text{NRV write-down}.

    • The NRV write-down represents the difference between the original cost price and the net realizable value, not the NRV amount itself.