Com: 10/27 - 10/29

10/27 - The Culture Industry

The Culture Industry

  • Developed by thinkers associated with the Institute for Social Research

  • Frankfurt School - Founded by Frankfurt , focuses on critical cultural perspective

    • Covers how power relations influence society and who benefits from cultural opportunities

    • Highly influenced by the enlightenment, where individual autonomy, freedom to chose, and knowledge is crucial to a meaningful life

    • Believes culture industry is a trap that

      • Keeps us passive with entertainment

      • Prevents critical thinking

    • Relocates to US after Nazis take power in 1933, remaining until 1950

    • Key figures

      • Max Horkheimer

      • Theodor Adorno

      • Herbert Marcuse

      • Walter Benjamin

      • Jurgen Habermas

  • Core concern: explaining the support of working classes for totalitarian governments (Stalinism, Nazism)

    • Believes that support for totalitarian governments is caused by changes in mass culture and entertainment

    • Media creates and transition from active thinking to numbness/apathy, making us less likely to question authority and more likely to look for scapegoats or support political systems we’d otherwise oppose

      • AKA palliating entertainment

  • Question: Does palliating entertainment drive people to support authoritarian politicians? → Yes

    • People are easily influenced by factors such as appearance or demeanor, without paying as much attention to values and intentions

    • Media creates suggestability by feeding us certain perspectives before we can form our own

    • Palliating entertainment can earn people’s favor over time by having them get used to seeing a certain perspective frequently

  • Rise of the “Culture Industry”

    • Viewed as a trap that keeps us passive and prevents critical thinking with entertainment

    • Merger of culture with big businesses

      • Ex: movie studios, music, tv, news

        • Mass produced

        • Aimed primarily at making money

      • Greater opportunity to make a career/profit off of providing entertainment

      • In the 20th c., people with jobs in culture are likely to make more money

    • Abolition of the pleasure and emancipatory impulses that once characterized culture in favor of palliating entertainments

      • Constant availability/affordability of content/entertainment → greater exposure 

      • Doesn’t challenge you, but entertains you 

      • Producing consent → makes people less likely to question authority bc they’d rather be entertained by the media despite disagreeing with current politics/events

      • Ex: Films provide escape from the brutalizing effects of work and a means of integrating desires into the capitalist economy

    • Pseudo-individualism - illusion of identity through superficial variation in standardized products

      • Disguises products as unique options that pacify our desire for actual novelty

      • Standardization - assembly line production of culture; cultural products follow predictable blueprints, formulas, and trops to guarantee predictable profit

      • Ex: streaming device recommendations, which are personal but follow algorithmic patterns

      • Ex: Everyone buys an item because they believe it makes them unique → becomes the standard so no one is unique

    • The role of the culture industry involves

      • Investigative reporting exposes corruption

      • Documentary reveals and publicizes social problems

      • Art challenges assumptions

      • Diverse voices enter the convo

  • Common Criticisms

    • Elitist - judgemental of American culture

    • Lacking empirical evidence - difficult to measure 

    • Questions

  1. To what extent do they provide opportunities for expression and audiences chances to engage critically?

    1. Do they provide symbolic value?

    2. Why would someone take a job that pays less? → Personal enjoyment

  2. Or do they mostly generate profit while ensuring social conformity?

    1. Dream Job Narrative - How do the careers we pursue reflect our values and interests?

Careers in Social Media

  • Duffy: The “dream job” narrative emphasizes:

    • Fun, flexibility, expression, authenticity

    • Visibility replaces stability (always on and self promoting vs unpredictable pay, few benefits, pressure to self promote)

    • Individualized risks (failure reflects lack of motivation and hustle rather than poor job market)

    • Works by consent rather than coercion

      • You have to initiate to be successful




10/29 - The Public Sphere & Democratic Communication




Habermas & the Public Sphere

  • Second gen Frankfurt school

  • More optimistic about the potential for rational communication

  • Interested in capacity for democratic dialogue

    • More optimistic in the potential of communication than Frankfurt

  • Public sphere - realm of social life where private citizens come together to discuss matters of public concern, forming public opinion via rational critical debate

    • Traits:

      • Realm of Social Life - not government, not purely private

      • Private citizens - regular ppl, not just elites

      • Matters of public concern - issues that impact the common good

      • Rational critical debate - based on reason, not just emotion

        • Discussing matters without the influence of authority

    • Historical Context: 18th c coffeehouses and salons

      • Ppl gathered to discuss politics, literature, philosophy

      • Egalitarian in principle  (though not in practice)

      • From this, Haberman wants to recover two important values

        • Status doesn’t matter; best argument wins

        • Critical rationality - questioning authority and tradition

      • The account is both descriptive (describing historical events) and normative

      • Describes real development, where newspapers, coffeeshops, and arguments were important

        • Idealistic for how democratic communication should work

        • States that it’s a skill that can be learned by anyone

  • Common criticisms

    • Exclusionary nature of the actually existing public sphere (women, working classes)

      • Coffeehouses were mostly occupied by men

      • The opinions of women/lower classes were not equally considered 

    • Overly rational assumptions, downplays importance of emotion and storytelling

  • The Public Sphere Today

    • Where does public debate happen today?

      • Mainstream media, social media, podcasts, community meetings, public demonstrations

      •  Public Sphere in Action → Habermas believes that there is more to it than just palliating entertainment

      • What role does the culture industry play?

        • Investigative reporting exposes corruption

        • Documentary reveals and publicizes social problems

        • Art challenges assumptions

        • Diverse voices enter the conversation

        • All question authority and tradition rather than remaining passive

    • Examples:

      • #MeToo - Public attitudes towards sexual harassment - questioning authority and tradition

      • #BlackLivesMatter - challenging police brutality, questioning racist traditions

  • Colonization of the Public Sphere

    • Colonization - takeover of public sphere by either market forces or state power

      • Intersects with beliefs of the Frankfurt School → Horkheimer + Adorno

    • Markets - desire for profit leads to emphasis on news that is “sell-able” rather than fostering debate

      • Connection to Viewing - Cory Doctorow

        • Enshittification - platforms start out useful, but profit aims lead to degraded experience in favor of profits

        • Platforms organize for engagement, not truth

        • Outrage and emotion are more attractive than careful reasoning

        • Ex: Facebook- connecting with friends to algorithm driven rage bait; Twitter/X - public conversation to paying for visibility

        • Doctorow argues that platforms follow a cycle: serve users, exploit users for advertisers and business, and exploit both to serve shareholders

          • Ex: Instagram taking user data to tell brands what they’re interested in, making brands pay to advertise on their platform to make money

    • State power/ Media capture -  control of media by the state to further partisan interest rather than common good

      • Examples:

        • Frivolous lawsuits 

        • Regulatory interference

        • Preferential treatment to aligned outlets

        • Physical intimidation against journalists

        • Defunding public media outlets

      • Also leads to degradation of discourse

        • Difficulty in knowing what’s true; all sources become suspect

        • People tune out entirely

    • Both factors tie into Adorno and Horkheimer’s concern about use of media to manipulate opinions