Com: 10/27 - 10/29
10/27 - The Culture Industry
The Culture Industry
Developed by thinkers associated with the Institute for Social Research
Frankfurt School - Founded by Frankfurt , focuses on critical cultural perspective
Covers how power relations influence society and who benefits from cultural opportunities
Highly influenced by the enlightenment, where individual autonomy, freedom to chose, and knowledge is crucial to a meaningful life
Believes culture industry is a trap that
Keeps us passive with entertainment
Prevents critical thinking
Relocates to US after Nazis take power in 1933, remaining until 1950
Key figures
Max Horkheimer
Theodor Adorno
Herbert Marcuse
Walter Benjamin
Jurgen Habermas
Core concern: explaining the support of working classes for totalitarian governments (Stalinism, Nazism)
Believes that support for totalitarian governments is caused by changes in mass culture and entertainment
Media creates and transition from active thinking to numbness/apathy, making us less likely to question authority and more likely to look for scapegoats or support political systems we’d otherwise oppose
AKA palliating entertainment
Question: Does palliating entertainment drive people to support authoritarian politicians? → Yes
People are easily influenced by factors such as appearance or demeanor, without paying as much attention to values and intentions
Media creates suggestability by feeding us certain perspectives before we can form our own
Palliating entertainment can earn people’s favor over time by having them get used to seeing a certain perspective frequently
Rise of the “Culture Industry”
Viewed as a trap that keeps us passive and prevents critical thinking with entertainment
Merger of culture with big businesses
Ex: movie studios, music, tv, news
Mass produced
Aimed primarily at making money
Greater opportunity to make a career/profit off of providing entertainment
In the 20th c., people with jobs in culture are likely to make more money
Abolition of the pleasure and emancipatory impulses that once characterized culture in favor of palliating entertainments
Constant availability/affordability of content/entertainment → greater exposure
Doesn’t challenge you, but entertains you
Producing consent → makes people less likely to question authority bc they’d rather be entertained by the media despite disagreeing with current politics/events
Ex: Films provide escape from the brutalizing effects of work and a means of integrating desires into the capitalist economy
Pseudo-individualism - illusion of identity through superficial variation in standardized products
Disguises products as unique options that pacify our desire for actual novelty
Standardization - assembly line production of culture; cultural products follow predictable blueprints, formulas, and trops to guarantee predictable profit
Ex: streaming device recommendations, which are personal but follow algorithmic patterns
Ex: Everyone buys an item because they believe it makes them unique → becomes the standard so no one is unique
The role of the culture industry involves
Investigative reporting exposes corruption
Documentary reveals and publicizes social problems
Art challenges assumptions
Diverse voices enter the convo
Common Criticisms
Elitist - judgemental of American culture
Lacking empirical evidence - difficult to measure
Questions
To what extent do they provide opportunities for expression and audiences chances to engage critically?
Do they provide symbolic value?
Why would someone take a job that pays less? → Personal enjoyment
Or do they mostly generate profit while ensuring social conformity?
Dream Job Narrative - How do the careers we pursue reflect our values and interests?
Careers in Social Media
Duffy: The “dream job” narrative emphasizes:
Fun, flexibility, expression, authenticity
Visibility replaces stability (always on and self promoting vs unpredictable pay, few benefits, pressure to self promote)
Individualized risks (failure reflects lack of motivation and hustle rather than poor job market)
Works by consent rather than coercion
You have to initiate to be successful
10/29 - The Public Sphere & Democratic Communication
Habermas & the Public Sphere
Second gen Frankfurt school
More optimistic about the potential for rational communication
Interested in capacity for democratic dialogue
More optimistic in the potential of communication than Frankfurt
Public sphere - realm of social life where private citizens come together to discuss matters of public concern, forming public opinion via rational critical debate
Traits:
Realm of Social Life - not government, not purely private
Private citizens - regular ppl, not just elites
Matters of public concern - issues that impact the common good
Rational critical debate - based on reason, not just emotion
Discussing matters without the influence of authority
Historical Context: 18th c coffeehouses and salons
Ppl gathered to discuss politics, literature, philosophy
Egalitarian in principle (though not in practice)
From this, Haberman wants to recover two important values
Status doesn’t matter; best argument wins
Critical rationality - questioning authority and tradition
The account is both descriptive (describing historical events) and normative
Describes real development, where newspapers, coffeeshops, and arguments were important
Idealistic for how democratic communication should work
States that it’s a skill that can be learned by anyone
Common criticisms
Exclusionary nature of the actually existing public sphere (women, working classes)
Coffeehouses were mostly occupied by men
The opinions of women/lower classes were not equally considered
Overly rational assumptions, downplays importance of emotion and storytelling
The Public Sphere Today
Where does public debate happen today?
Mainstream media, social media, podcasts, community meetings, public demonstrations
Public Sphere in Action → Habermas believes that there is more to it than just palliating entertainment
What role does the culture industry play?
Investigative reporting exposes corruption
Documentary reveals and publicizes social problems
Art challenges assumptions
Diverse voices enter the conversation
All question authority and tradition rather than remaining passive
Examples:
#MeToo - Public attitudes towards sexual harassment - questioning authority and tradition
#BlackLivesMatter - challenging police brutality, questioning racist traditions
Colonization of the Public Sphere
Colonization - takeover of public sphere by either market forces or state power
Intersects with beliefs of the Frankfurt School → Horkheimer + Adorno
Markets - desire for profit leads to emphasis on news that is “sell-able” rather than fostering debate
Connection to Viewing - Cory Doctorow
Enshittification - platforms start out useful, but profit aims lead to degraded experience in favor of profits
Platforms organize for engagement, not truth
Outrage and emotion are more attractive than careful reasoning
Ex: Facebook- connecting with friends to algorithm driven rage bait; Twitter/X - public conversation to paying for visibility
Doctorow argues that platforms follow a cycle: serve users, exploit users for advertisers and business, and exploit both to serve shareholders
Ex: Instagram taking user data to tell brands what they’re interested in, making brands pay to advertise on their platform to make money
State power/ Media capture - control of media by the state to further partisan interest rather than common good
Examples:
Frivolous lawsuits
Regulatory interference
Preferential treatment to aligned outlets
Physical intimidation against journalists
Defunding public media outlets
Also leads to degradation of discourse
Difficulty in knowing what’s true; all sources become suspect
People tune out entirely
Both factors tie into Adorno and Horkheimer’s concern about use of media to manipulate opinions