Pelagic ecosystems part 2

Pelagic Food Chains – The Simplified Model

2.1 Food chains as simplified schematics

  • Food chains = linear models used to simplify complex ecological interactions.

  • Analogy: London Tube map → schematic, not literal.

2.2 Trophic levels

  • Autotrophs

    • Photoautotrophs (sunlight)

    • Chemoautotrophs (chemical energy)

  • Heterotrophs

    • Obtain energy by consuming prey.

2.3 Open ocean context

  • “Open ocean” in this lecture = subtropical gyres (marine deserts).

  • Low nutrients due to Ekman convergence + downwelling → thermocline deep → nutrients isolated from photic zone.

3. Cast of Characters: Trophic Levels in Pelagic Systems

3.1 Primary producers (autotrophs)

  • Phytoplankton:

    • Cyanobacteria

    • Protists (broad group including many algae)

  • Mostly unicellular eukaryotes.

  • Build organic matter from inorganic nutrients + sunlight.

3.2 Primary consumers (herbivorous zooplankton)

  • Copepods (many herbivorous, some carnivorous).

  • Krill, salps, appendicularians (free‑swimming tunicates).

3.3 Secondary & tertiary consumers

  • Carnivorous zooplankton, small fish, jellyfish, squid.

3.4 Top predators

  • Sharks, tuna, billfish, marine mammals (pinnipeds, cetaceans), seabirds.

3.5 Plankton life‑history categories

  • Meroplankton – planktonic only in larval stage.

  • Holoplankton – planktonic for entire life.

4. Trophic Dynamics & Energy Transfer

4.1 Secondary production

  • Total animal biomass produced at higher trophic levels.

  • Expressed per unit area per unit time (e.g., g C m⁻² yr⁻¹).

4.2 Nutrient vs energy flow

  • Nutrients: cyclical → remineralised by bacteria → re‑enter base of food chain.

  • Energy: unidirectional → lost as heat via respiration.

4.3 Ecological efficiency

  • 10–20% transfer efficiency (≈10% “magic number”).

  • 80–90% energy lost at each trophic step.

  • Microbial loop recovers some lost energy.

4.4 Size & generation time

  • Higher trophic levels = larger organisms + longer generation times.

  • “Bigger is better” for predation success.

  • Biomass decreases up the pyramid, but not as sharply as abundance because organisms are larger and live longer.

5. Food Webs vs Food Chains

5.1 Why food chains are insufficient

  • Real ecosystems = food webs with multiple, shifting interactions.

  • Seasonal and climate‑driven variability alters food‑web structure.

5.2 Complications in food‑web construction

  • Omnivory – organisms feeding at multiple trophic levels.

  • Detritivory – difficult to place in linear chains.

  • Parasitism – trophic position unclear.

  • Cannibalism – violates simple trophic hierarchy.

5.3 Methods for studying food webs

  • Gut content analysis

    • Snapshot only; shows recent meals.

  • Stable isotopes (industry standard)

    • δ¹³C → identifies source of primary production.

    • δ¹⁵N → increases with trophic level (light isotope excreted, heavy retained).

    • Provides integrated dietary history.

6. Oceanographic Regimes & Dominant Phytoplankton

Three major regimes:

6.1 Open ocean (subtropical gyres)

  • Dominant group: nanoplankton (very small).

  • Environment: low nutrients, strongly stratified, low turbulence.

  • Nanoplankton advantages:

    • Low nutrient requirements

    • Very low sinking rates → remain in photic zone.

6.2 Continental shelves

  • Dominant groups: diatoms + dinoflagellates (microphytoplankton).

  • Intermediate nutrient levels.

6.3 Upwelling regions

  • Dominant group: large chain‑forming diatoms.

  • Environment: nutrient‑rich, turbulent, strong vertical velocities.

  • Advantages for large diatoms:

    • Highly efficient nutrient uptake

    • Turbulence keeps them suspended despite high sinking rates.

7. Phytoplankton Size Determines Food‑Chain Length

7.1 Open ocean (nanoplankton)

  • Very small cells → must be eaten by progressively larger consumers.

  • Long food chain: ~6 trophic levels (5 transfers).

7.2 Continental shelves

  • Larger phytoplankton → fewer intermediate consumers needed.

  • Medium food chain: ~4 trophic levels.

7.3 Upwelling regions

  • Large chain‑forming diatoms → can be eaten directly by krill or planktivorous fish.

  • Short food chain: 2 transfers, 3 trophic levels.

  • Energy reaches top predators (e.g., whales) efficiently.

8. Why Food‑Chain Length Matters

8.1 Energy loss across trophic levels

  • Longer chains = more cumulative energy loss.

  • Shorter chains = more energy retained for higher trophic levels.

8.2 Mathematical expression

Secondary production at trophic level n+1:

Pn+1=P1×EEn

Where:

  • P1 = primary production

  • EE = ecological efficiency (≈0.1)

  • n = number of transfers

Implication:

  • Open ocean (5 transfers): 0.15=0.00001 → extremely low energy at top.

  • Upwelling (1–2 transfers): far higher retained energy.

9. Global Comparison of Regimes

Regime

% Ocean Area

Primary Productivity (g C m⁻² yr⁻¹)

Trophic Transfers

Fish Production (mg C m⁻² yr⁻¹)

Open ocean

89%

~75

5

0.75

Coastal

10%

~300

3

8,000

Upwelling

1%

Very high

1–2

44,700

Key insight

Upwelling regions = 1% of ocean area but ~50% of global fish catch
→ due to double effect:

  1. High primary productivity (nutrient supply)

  2. Short food chain (efficient energy transfer)

10. Summary of Core Concepts

  • Different oceanographic regimes support different dominant phytoplankton.

  • Phytoplankton size determines food‑chain length.

  • Shorter food chains = higher secondary productivity.

  • Upwelling regions are disproportionately important for global fisheries.

  • Energy transfer efficiency (~10%) explains why long food chains are energetically “expensive”.