Pelagic ecosystems part 2
Pelagic Food Chains – The Simplified Model
2.1 Food chains as simplified schematics
Food chains = linear models used to simplify complex ecological interactions.
Analogy: London Tube map → schematic, not literal.
2.2 Trophic levels
Autotrophs
Photoautotrophs (sunlight)
Chemoautotrophs (chemical energy)
Heterotrophs
Obtain energy by consuming prey.
2.3 Open ocean context
“Open ocean” in this lecture = subtropical gyres (marine deserts).
Low nutrients due to Ekman convergence + downwelling → thermocline deep → nutrients isolated from photic zone.
3. Cast of Characters: Trophic Levels in Pelagic Systems
3.1 Primary producers (autotrophs)
Phytoplankton:
Cyanobacteria
Protists (broad group including many algae)
Mostly unicellular eukaryotes.
Build organic matter from inorganic nutrients + sunlight.
3.2 Primary consumers (herbivorous zooplankton)
Copepods (many herbivorous, some carnivorous).
Krill, salps, appendicularians (free‑swimming tunicates).
3.3 Secondary & tertiary consumers
Carnivorous zooplankton, small fish, jellyfish, squid.
3.4 Top predators
Sharks, tuna, billfish, marine mammals (pinnipeds, cetaceans), seabirds.
3.5 Plankton life‑history categories
Meroplankton – planktonic only in larval stage.
Holoplankton – planktonic for entire life.
4. Trophic Dynamics & Energy Transfer
4.1 Secondary production
Total animal biomass produced at higher trophic levels.
Expressed per unit area per unit time (e.g., g C m⁻² yr⁻¹).
4.2 Nutrient vs energy flow
Nutrients: cyclical → remineralised by bacteria → re‑enter base of food chain.
Energy: unidirectional → lost as heat via respiration.
4.3 Ecological efficiency
10–20% transfer efficiency (≈10% “magic number”).
80–90% energy lost at each trophic step.
Microbial loop recovers some lost energy.
4.4 Size & generation time
Higher trophic levels = larger organisms + longer generation times.
“Bigger is better” for predation success.
Biomass decreases up the pyramid, but not as sharply as abundance because organisms are larger and live longer.
5. Food Webs vs Food Chains
5.1 Why food chains are insufficient
Real ecosystems = food webs with multiple, shifting interactions.
Seasonal and climate‑driven variability alters food‑web structure.
5.2 Complications in food‑web construction
Omnivory – organisms feeding at multiple trophic levels.
Detritivory – difficult to place in linear chains.
Parasitism – trophic position unclear.
Cannibalism – violates simple trophic hierarchy.
5.3 Methods for studying food webs
Gut content analysis
Snapshot only; shows recent meals.
Stable isotopes (industry standard)
δ¹³C → identifies source of primary production.
δ¹⁵N → increases with trophic level (light isotope excreted, heavy retained).
Provides integrated dietary history.
6. Oceanographic Regimes & Dominant Phytoplankton
Three major regimes:
6.1 Open ocean (subtropical gyres)
Dominant group: nanoplankton (very small).
Environment: low nutrients, strongly stratified, low turbulence.
Nanoplankton advantages:
Low nutrient requirements
Very low sinking rates → remain in photic zone.
6.2 Continental shelves
Dominant groups: diatoms + dinoflagellates (microphytoplankton).
Intermediate nutrient levels.
6.3 Upwelling regions
Dominant group: large chain‑forming diatoms.
Environment: nutrient‑rich, turbulent, strong vertical velocities.
Advantages for large diatoms:
Highly efficient nutrient uptake
Turbulence keeps them suspended despite high sinking rates.
7. Phytoplankton Size Determines Food‑Chain Length
7.1 Open ocean (nanoplankton)
Very small cells → must be eaten by progressively larger consumers.
Long food chain: ~6 trophic levels (5 transfers).
7.2 Continental shelves
Larger phytoplankton → fewer intermediate consumers needed.
Medium food chain: ~4 trophic levels.
7.3 Upwelling regions
Large chain‑forming diatoms → can be eaten directly by krill or planktivorous fish.
Short food chain: 2 transfers, 3 trophic levels.
Energy reaches top predators (e.g., whales) efficiently.
8. Why Food‑Chain Length Matters
8.1 Energy loss across trophic levels
Longer chains = more cumulative energy loss.
Shorter chains = more energy retained for higher trophic levels.
8.2 Mathematical expression
Secondary production at trophic level n+1:
Pn+1=P1×EEn
Where:
P1 = primary production
EE = ecological efficiency (≈0.1)
n = number of transfers
Implication:
Open ocean (5 transfers): 0.15=0.00001 → extremely low energy at top.
Upwelling (1–2 transfers): far higher retained energy.
9. Global Comparison of Regimes
Regime | % Ocean Area | Primary Productivity (g C m⁻² yr⁻¹) | Trophic Transfers | Fish Production (mg C m⁻² yr⁻¹) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Open ocean | 89% | ~75 | 5 | 0.75 |
Coastal | 10% | ~300 | 3 | 8,000 |
Upwelling | 1% | Very high | 1–2 | 44,700 |
Key insight
Upwelling regions = 1% of ocean area but ~50% of global fish catch
→ due to double effect:
High primary productivity (nutrient supply)
Short food chain (efficient energy transfer)
10. Summary of Core Concepts
Different oceanographic regimes support different dominant phytoplankton.
Phytoplankton size determines food‑chain length.
Shorter food chains = higher secondary productivity.
Upwelling regions are disproportionately important for global fisheries.
Energy transfer efficiency (~10%) explains why long food chains are energetically “expensive”.