Notes on Adherence Determinants and Continuum Theories (HBM, Self-Efficacy, TPB)
Adherence determinants and continuum theories
Overview: Adherence to medical advice is influenced by a combination of patient characteristics, treatment factors, and health-issue/treatment context. Perception of seriousness, treatment complexity, and individual differences (age, mental state, social factors) all shape whether people follow recommendations.
Perceived severity and health problem perception
People with HIV or arthritis tend to follow medical advice more than those with diabetes or pulmonary disease, but the checkpoint is the individual’s perception of seriousness, not the objective severity.
If I perceive my health issue as serious, I am more likely to adhere; if I don’t, adherence drops.
Characteristics of the health issue and the treatment
Health issue characteristics influence adherence (e.g., perceived seriousness).
Treatment characteristics matter: if the regimen is complex (e.g., diet changes, exercise, supplements, medicines), adherence drops due to the sense of overwhelm.
For medication adherence specifically, having more than four doses is associated with lower adherence.
Perceived sacrifice matters: if the medicine is believed to have low sacrifice/low cost, adherence may decrease (paradoxical note: low sacrifice can reduce motivation to adhere to a regimen perceived as easy or not burdensome).
Overall formulation: adherence is affected by the health issue, the treatment, and the patient’s characteristics.
Age and adherence
Older adults are generally more adherent than younger adults, a finding echoed across literature on adult age differences.
Younger adults tend to take more risks and may believe health problems are unlikely to occur in the near future, which lowers adherence.
The mental set of older adults differs: if they don’t follow medical advice, consequences are more serious, which can motivate adherence.
Short-term predictors of adherence: stress and emotional factors
Higher stress is linked to lower adherence; when life is full of problems, focus on one health issue diminishes.
Fewer life issues/stress bolster mental energy to engage with medical advice.
Anxiety is associated with nonadherence, though the trend is modest; depression is linked to substantially reduced adherence.
Biopsychosocial model: biological, psychological, and social factors matter; social support is critical for adherence.
Social support and economic/cultural factors
Strong social support (family, friends) increases adherence; lack of support reduces motivation.
Income and socioeconomic status influence adherence; lower income is sometimes linked to poorer adherence, potentially due to higher life stress or resource constraints.
Cultural norms influence adherence: cultures that value modern medicine and follow medical advice show higher adherence, whereas cultures with norms against following professional advice show lower adherence.
Barriers to adherence
Common barriers include cost, time, optimistic bias, and other factors.
Optimistic bias: the belief that negative health outcomes will not happen to me, reducing adherence motivation. More common among youth/adolescents and to a lesser extent among young adults.
Overcoming optimistic biases is crucial for improving adherence.
Shifts in adherence over time and information environment
In the 20th century, adherence was easier when medical guidance was more limited (e.g., basic medication-taking). Modern guidelines are more numerous and nuanced (diet, exercise, supplements, medications), making adherence more complex.
Today, people may follow some aspects of advice while neglecting others; mistakes occur even with knowledge of what’s best for health.
Summary of factors influencing adherence (key takeaways)
Perceived severity of disease is important: higher perceived seriousness increases adherence. Reference: Dometteo (2007) study indicating higher perceived seriousness → greater adherence.
Treatment characteristics: complexity and side effects reduce adherence; more than four medication doses lowers adherence; perceived sacrifice can reduce adherence.
Age and life stage: older adults more adherent than younger; young adults engage in riskier behaviors and perceive lower near-term consequences.
Personal factors: stress and depression reduce adherence; anxiety has a smaller effect.
Social factors: social support and cultural norms strongly influence adherence; economic status affects adherence through stress and resources.
Barriers and cognitive biases: cost, time, and optimistic bias impede adherence; addressing these barriers is essential.
Contextual model: adherence reflects interactions among health issue, treatment, and patient characteristics within a biopsychosocial framework.
Transition to theories of adherence
The lecture moves from describing factors to explaining adherence dynamics using continuum theories versus staged (transtheoretical) theories.
Continuum theories apply a single set of factors to predict behavior across people, regardless of stage or motivation.
Stage theories classify people into stages of behavioral change and tailor variables to the stage.
Today’s focus: four continuum theories and their role in explaining adherence; later, stage theories will be discussed.
Four continuum theories of health behavior (overview)
Health Belief Model (HBM)
Self-Efficacy Theory (Bandura)
Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB)
Behavioral Theory (as labeled in the text; note: details for this one are not elaborated in the transcript)
Central idea: these theories emphasize individual beliefs, attitudes, and perceptions as key predictors of health-related actions.
Health Belief Model (HBM)
Origin and purpose
A social psychology theory developed in the 1950s to understand why people do or do not engage in disease prevention or screening.
Core ideas
People decide to act based on: perceived threats, values, and expected effectiveness of actions.
Four main components
Perceived susceptibility: likelihood of getting a health condition (e.g., smoking and lung cancer risk).
Perceived severity: seriousness of the health condition and its consequences.
Perceived benefits: effectiveness of taking action to reduce risk or severity.
Perceived barriers: obstacles or costs of taking action.
Behavioral prediction
Change is more likely when perceived benefits outweigh perceived barriers:
Let = perceived benefits, = perceived barriers. Behavior change is favored when .
Practical implications for programs
Effective smoking cessation programs should educate about risks and seriousness, communicate benefits of quitting, and provide strategies to overcome barriers.
Limitations and criticisms
Does not specify how the variables combine to produce behavior; lacks explicit dynamical mechanism for change.
Does not fully explain differences across individuals or groups (e.g., why two people with similar susceptibility and severity react differently based on barriers).
Additional theoretical integration
Bandura’s concept of reciprocal determinism and self-efficacy adds to HBM by acknowledging environment and beliefs and the belief in one’s capability to act.
Self-Efficacy Theory (Bandura) and reciprocal determinism
Core concept: self-efficacy = belief in one’s ability to successfully perform a behavior.
Reciprocal determinism: behavior, environment, and personal beliefs interact continuously to shape outcomes.
Ways self-efficacy can be strengthened
Mastery experiences: successfully performing the behavior increases confidence (e.g., successfully resisting a cigarette craving).
Vicarious experience: observing others with similar abilities succeed increases belief in one’s own abilities.
Verbal persuasion: encouragement from trusted others strengthens belief in capability.
Physiological/affective states: stress or anxiety can undermine self-efficacy and hinder performance.
Relevance to health behaviors
Higher self-efficacy is associated with better adherence, lower relapse risk, and more successful management of chronic conditions (e.g., diabetes, HIV).
Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB)
Core idea: behavior is predicted by intention, which is shaped by three factors:
Attitude toward the behavior: evaluation of whether the behavior leads to positive or negative outcomes.
Perceived behavioral control: perceived ease or difficulty of performing the behavior (similar to self-efficacy).
Subjective norm: perceived social pressure or expectations from others about whether to perform the behavior.
Example: stopping smoking is more likely if it aligns with others’ expectations (subjective norm) and if one believes it is positive and controllable.
Strengths
Identifies specific beliefs that shape behavior and highlights the role of social norms in driving behavior across individuals.
Weaknesses
May not account for group differences in how intentions, control, and norms influence behavior.
Less effective at predicting risky or impulsive behaviors.
Behavioral Theory (not elaborated in depth in the transcript)
Included as one of the continuum theories, though explicit content from the lecture is limited in the transcript.
Practical implications for research and coursework
In health behavior papers, use at least one continuum theory as the theoretical framework to explain behavior change over an eight-week period.
It is strongly recommended to apply a second theory to compare explanatory power and provide a richer analysis.
Connections to prior and real-world concepts
Biopsychosocial model is used to frame adherence, integrating biological, psychological, and social factors.
Emphasis on social support and cultural norms aligns with broader public health approaches to improve adherence (community and family involvement).
Recognizes the evolving information environment: modern guidance is more complex, making adherence a multi-faceted task.
Ethical, philosophical, or practical implications
Recognizing optimistic bias and targeted interventions can improve adherence but may raise questions about autonomy and paternalism in health messaging.
Tailoring interventions to individual stages or beliefs must balance respect for individual differences with public health goals.
Key definitions and concepts to remember (glossary)
Adherence: extent to which a person’s behavior corresponds with agreed recommendations from a healthcare provider.
Perceived susceptibility: belief about the likelihood of acquiring a health condition.
Perceived severity: belief about the seriousness of a health condition and its consequences.
Perceived benefits: belief that taking action will reduce risk or severity.
Perceived barriers: belief about the costs or obstacles to taking action.
Self-efficacy: belief in one’s own ability to perform a specific behavior.
Reciprocal determinism: ongoing interaction between a person, their behavior, and their environment.
Attitude, perceived behavioral control, subjective norm: core determinants of intention in the Theory of Planned Behavior.
Quick study tips based on this content
When evaluating adherence, categorize factors into health issue characteristics, treatment characteristics, and patient characteristics.
Use the HBM components to structure questions in exams or essays: What would increase perceived susceptibility/severity, or what barriers exist?
For theoretical questions, illustrate with clear causal arrows: e.g., in TPB, attitude and subjective norm influence intention, which drives behavior, moderated by perceived behavioral control.
In essay prompts, compare how HBM vs. TPB would explain a specific adherence scenario (e.g., quitting smoking or medication adherence) and discuss strengths/limitations.
Next steps mentioned in the lecture
The instructor indicates a continuation of continuum theories in the next session and plans to cover staged theories later.
For coursework, students should be prepared to apply one stationary theory (also called a behavior change model) to explain behavior change in an eight-week period, and ideally use a second model as well.