133-135

Disorder and Crime

  • Foundational Article: "Broken Windows" by Wilson and Kelling (1982)

    • Key Argument: Disorder signifies urban decay which can independently contribute to fear and crime.

    • Disorder as a Symbol: Evidence of disorder (e.g., litter, public intoxication) correlates with residents' fear of crime and may provoke criminal behavior as it signifies a breakdown of social control.

  • Disorder's Dual Impact:

    1. Fear of Crime: Physical decay leads residents to associate such environments with crime risk.

    2. Encouragement of Criminality: Potential offenders may see disorder as a sign that neighborhoods lack informal social control, making them targets for crime.

Measuring Disorder

  • Concept of Perception: Distinction between physical presence of disorder and its perception by community members.

    • Physical Presence: Measured by systematic observations; studies like Sampson & Raudenbush (1999) found few visible signs of disorder.

    • Perceived Disorder: Assessed through surveys, recognizing that acceptance of behaviors like public drinking varies by community.

  • Example Survey Questions:

    1. Survey on loitering impact: "Is loitering a big problem, some problem, or almost no problem?"

    2. Survey on loitering frequency: "How common are loiterers: very common to not at all common?"

  • Analysis of Questions:

    • First question measures perception of loitering as a problem, while the second tracks frequency—crucial to understanding community perception of disorder.

  • Categories of Disorder:

    • Social Disorder:

      • Groups of loiterers

      • Drug use and sales

      • Vandalism

      • Gang activity

      • Public drinking

      • Street harassment

    • Physical Disorder:

      • Abandoned buildings

      • Garbage and litter

      • Junk in vacant lots

  • Index Creation:

    • Respondents rated each type of disorder, leading to two indexes:

      • Social Disorder Index (e.g., groups loitering, drug sales)

      • Physical Disorder Index (e.g., abandoned buildings, litter)

    • Example scoring system allows quantitative analysis of perceived disorder in neighborhoods.

  • Benefits of Composite Measures:

    • Validity: Composite indexes capture the multifaceted nature of disorder better than single questions.

    • Variability: An aggregated index introduces more variation than analyzing each item separately.

    • Efficiency: Fewer variables enable simpler data analysis and interpretation.

Measurement Summary

  • Conceptual Understanding:

    • Concepts are mental summaries that help categorize shared observations and experiences.

    • Concepts require operationalization for empirical measurement—defining how to capture these ideas in research.

  • Key Quality Criteria:

    • Reliability: Is the measurement consistent across different instances?

    • Validity: Does the measurement accurately reflect what it intends to measure?

  • Composite Measures: Combining various related variables often yields a more comprehensive and valid measurement of complex constructs in criminal justice.

Key Terms

  • Concepts, Operational Definition, Operationalization, Validity, Reliability, Composite Measures

Review Questions and Exercises

  1. Conceptualize and operationalize "recidivism" and assess potential reliability and validity issues.

  2. Create an operational definition based on the FBI's definition of "domestic terrorism."

  3. Discuss validity and reliability in the context of measuring "pace of life" through a composite approach.